- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Meaning, functions and significance of a constitution
Explain what a constitution is, the jobs it does for a diverse country like India, how its legitimacy comes from the way it is made, and what makes a constitution well drafted.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define a constitution and explain why a diverse country needs one.
- List the functions of a constitution described in the Tamil Nadu textbook.
- Explain formulation, legitimacy and the idea of a referendum.
- Describe the qualities of a well-drafted constitution, with Indian examples.
Unit 1 of the Tamil Nadu textbook for Class 12 Political Science opens the study of Indian government by asking what a constitution is and why India needed one. Every later unit (Parliament, the President, the courts, the Union and the states) rests on the answers in this lesson.
Why India needed agreed basic rules
The textbook points out that the national movement against colonial rule aimed at more than political independence. It also worked for territorial integration, constitutionalism and democratisation. India is culturally very diverse, yet it is one political state, and its people depend on and cooperate with each other in many ways. Such a society needs agreed basic rules so that people can live together. Without them, the very statehood of India could be endangered and people would feel insecure.
Under colonial rule, India was governed through Charters, Councils Acts and Government of India Acts made in Britain. Independent India chose instead to base its politics and administration on a definite written constitution, drafted by a Constituent Assembly. That constitution had to bind many regions and many groups of people into one state: a union of states with cooperation and coordination between its parts.
What a constitution is
A constitution is a body of basic codes according to which a state is constituted and governed. It is often called the fundamental law of the land, because every other law, and every institution, draws its authority from it. A law that conflicts with the constitution cannot stand.
Functions of a constitution
Drawing on the textbook, we can list the main jobs a constitution does:
- Coordination: it provides a set of basic rules that allow members of the state to work together. The textbook calls this the most critical function.
- Allocation of power: it specifies how power is divided between the parts of the state. Indian diversity called for a union of states, and the freedom movement favoured democracy, so in India Parliament decides the laws and policies of the country.
- Enabling a just society: it empowers government to meet the aspirations of society. Part IV of the Indian Constitution (Directive Principles of State Policy) guides the state to make laws on problems in Indian society.
- Identity: it expresses the fundamental identity of a people. People may share ethnic identities before a constitution exists; they gain a common political identity by accepting the fundamental laws it lays down. Individual aims and freedoms must then fit within those rules.
- Rights and citizenship: it protects fundamental rights, defines who the citizens are, and sets out how the states relate to each other and to the central government.
A constitution is the fundamental law of the land: it constitutes the state, allocates its powers, protects rights and gives a diverse people one political identity.
Written and unwritten constitutions
Most constitutions in the world are written documents made of articles and schedules. A few, such as that of the United Kingdom, have no single document called the constitution. Britain relies on customs, conventions and historical precedents, which together make up its constitution. India's Constitution is written and very detailed.
Formulation, legitimacy and referendum
Formulation means how a constitution comes into being: who wrote it and with what authority. The Indian Constitution has legitimacy because it was drafted by a Constituent Assembly made up of people's representatives, and it reflected the agreement of most sections of Indian society at Independence.
Some countries go further and put their constitution to a referendum: the question is referred directly to the voters instead of being settled by representatives in the legislature. Referendums are also used for moral questions that divide coalition governments and for local matters best left to individuals; they are seen as giving popular approval. Neither the Indian Constitution nor any of its amendments was put to a referendum. The textbook suggests that the conditions at the time may not have allowed one, and invites students to study how referendums work in Switzerland.
What makes a constitution well drafted
- It accommodates the aspirations of all sections of society. A constitution that discriminates by religion, caste or language will not win wide acceptance.
- It preserves the freedom and equality of all citizens.
- It does not concentrate all power in one person or institution. India divides power horizontally between the legislature, the executive and the judiciary.
- It is neither too rigid nor too flexible. India's amending provisions allow change, while the basic structure of the Constitution limits what can be changed. So the document keeps its core values but adapts to new conditions.
The textbook's example of a core value is secularism. The 42nd Amendment of 1976, passed during the National Emergency, changed the Preamble's description of India from 'Sovereign Democratic Republic' to 'Sovereign Socialist Secular Democratic Republic', and changed 'unity of the nation' to 'unity and integrity of the nation'. A state that is not secular, which has an official religion and favours its followers for high posts, is called a theocratic state.
Functions of a constitution (Tamil Nadu textbook)
-
Coordination
- Basic rules for living together
- Called the most critical function
-
Allocation of power
- Union of states
- Parliament makes laws and policies
-
Just society
- Part IV directs the state
- Laws on social problems
-
Identity
- Political identity
- Citizenship defined
-
Limits and rights
- Fundamental rights protected
- Centre-state framework
Worked example 1: which function?
Match each provision to a function. (a) 'Parliament shall make laws for the whole of India.' (b) 'The State shall try to secure equal pay for equal work for men and women.' (c) 'No citizen shall be denied freedom of speech except under reasonable restrictions.' Working: (a) says who holds law-making power, so it is allocation of power. (b) asks the state to act to remove an injustice, so it enables a just society (it is in the spirit of Part IV). (c) protects the individual against the state, so it is a fundamental right that limits government.
Worked example 2: is this a well-drafted constitution?
A made-up country's constitution gives one leader the power to make laws, run the government and decide court cases, and says it can never be amended. Analysis: it fails two tests from this lesson. It concentrates all power in one person instead of separating legislative, executive and judicial power, and it is completely rigid, so it cannot adapt to changing conditions. India's Constitution avoids both faults: it separates powers and balances flexible amendment with limits set by the basic structure.
Key takeaways: India needed agreed basic rules to hold a diverse people together as one state. A constitution is the fundamental law that constitutes the state, allocates power, enables a just society, protects rights and gives a political identity. India's Constitution draws legitimacy from its elected Constituent Assembly, though it was never put to a referendum. A good constitution includes everyone, protects freedom and equality, divides power and is neither too rigid nor too flexible.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the Tamil Nadu textbook, what is the most critical function of a constitution?
- To fix the salaries of public servants
- To provide basic rules that allow coordination among members of the state
- To decide which party will form the government
- To list the country's natural resources
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook calls coordination the most critical function: a constitution provides a set of basic rules so that the members of a diverse state can live and work together. It does not decide which party wins power.
-
2. Which country is the textbook's example of a constitution that is not one single document?
- The United States
- India
- Switzerland
- The United Kingdom
Show answer
Answer: D. The United Kingdom has no single document called its constitution. Its constitution is made up of customs, conventions and historical precedents. The US and Indian constitutions are written documents.
-
3. Why does the Indian Constitution have legitimacy, according to the textbook?
- It was approved in a nationwide referendum
- It was written by British officials
- It was drafted by a Constituent Assembly of people's representatives
- It was copied entirely from one foreign constitution
Show answer
Answer: C. Legitimacy comes from formulation: the Constitution was drafted by a Constituent Assembly made up of people's representatives and reflected a broad consensus. It was never put to a referendum, and although it borrowed ideas, it was not copied from one constitution.
-
4. Which words did the 42nd Amendment (1976) add to the Preamble's description of India?
- Socialist and Secular
- Sovereign and Democratic
- Republic and Federal
- Justice and Liberty
Show answer
Answer: A. The Preamble originally read 'Sovereign Democratic Republic'. The 42nd Amendment made it 'Sovereign Socialist Secular Democratic Republic' and also changed 'unity of the nation' to 'unity and integrity of the nation'.
-
5. Assertion (A): The Indian Constitution is described as neither too rigid nor too flexible. Reason (R): It allows its provisions to be amended, but the basic structure limits what amendments can do.
- Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true. The amending provisions give flexibility and the basic structure gives rigidity; that balance is exactly why the Constitution is called neither too rigid nor too flexible, so R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.