- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Sources of the Indian Constitution
Identify the provisions the framers borrowed from the Government of India Act, 1935 and from the constitutions of Britain, the USA, Ireland, Canada, Australia, Germany, the USSR, France and South Africa.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Name the features taken from the Government of India Act, 1935.
- Match borrowed features to the country whose constitution inspired them.
- Explain why borrowing did not make the Constitution a mere copy.
The framers of the Constitution studied many existing constitutions and adapted features that suited Indian conditions. Questions that ask you to match a feature to its source are common, so this lesson organises the textbook's list so that it is easy to remember.
The Government of India Act, 1935
The single largest source was a law made by the British Parliament for India: the Government of India Act, 1935. The textbook names these features as adopted from it:
- federal provisions (a federation of units with a division of powers);
- the office of Governor;
- the judiciary (a federal court system);
- public service commissions;
- emergency provisions;
- administrative details.
Because so much of the administrative structure came from the 1935 Act, India's transition to independence was orderly: officials and courts continued to work within a familiar framework.
Constitutions of other countries
| Source | Features adopted |
|---|---|
| Britain | Parliamentary government, cabinet system, single citizenship, rule of law, legislative procedure, prerogative writs |
| United States | Fundamental Rights, judicial review, independence of the judiciary, impeachment of the President, removal of Supreme Court and High Court judges, removal of the Vice-President |
| Ireland | Directive Principles of State Policy |
| Canada | Federation with a strong centre, residuary powers with the centre, appointment of state Governors by the centre, advisory jurisdiction of the Supreme Court |
| Australia | Concurrent List, freedom of trade and commerce, joint sitting of the two Houses of Parliament |
| Weimar Germany | Suspension of Fundamental Rights during an emergency |
| USSR (Soviet Union) | Fundamental Duties; the ideal of social, economic and political justice in the Preamble |
| France | Republic; the ideals of liberty, equality and fraternity in the Preamble |
| South Africa | Procedure for amending the Constitution; election of members of the Rajya Sabha |
Note that the Fundamental Duties, inspired by the Soviet model, were not in the original Constitution. They were added by the 42nd Amendment in 1976.
Two groups of borrowings
-
Machinery of government
- Parliamentary system: Britain
- Strong-centre federation: Canada
- Governor, PSCs, emergency: 1935 Act
- Joint sitting: Australia
-
Rights and ideals
- Fundamental Rights, judicial review: USA
- Directive Principles: Ireland
- Liberty, equality, fraternity: France
- Fundamental Duties: USSR
Borrowed, but not copied
Borrowing does not mean the Constitution is a patchwork. The framers adapted each feature. India took Britain's parliamentary system, for example, but gave it a written constitution and judicial review, which Britain does not have. It took America's judicial review but not its presidential system. The textbook describes the framers as having improvised the features before incorporating them, so that they fit India's diversity, its federal needs and its goal of social and economic justice.
Remember the big four: Britain for the parliamentary system, the USA for rights and judicial review, Ireland for Directive Principles, the 1935 Act for the administrative framework.
Worked example 1: trace the source
Question: a bill is stuck because the two Houses of Parliament disagree, and the President calls both Houses to sit together. Which source inspired this, and which inspired the President's power to proclaim an emergency that suspends rights? Working: a joint sitting of the two Houses comes from the Australian constitution. Emergency provisions as such come from the Government of India Act, 1935, while the specific idea of suspending Fundamental Rights during an emergency comes from the Weimar constitution of Germany.
Worked example 2: odd one out
Question: which of these was NOT taken from Britain: rule of law, single citizenship, cabinet system, judicial review? Working: rule of law, single citizenship and the cabinet system are all British features. Judicial review came from the United States; in Britain, Parliament is sovereign and courts cannot strike down its laws. So judicial review is the odd one out.
Worked example 3: a two-part source
Question: the Preamble promises justice (social, economic and political) and also liberty, equality and fraternity. Are these from the same source? Working: no. The ideal of social, economic and political justice is linked to the Soviet constitution, while liberty, equality and fraternity come from the French Revolution's ideals as written into the French constitution.
Key takeaways: the Government of India Act, 1935 supplied the federal scheme, the Governor, public service commissions, emergency provisions and much administrative detail. Britain gave the parliamentary system; the USA gave Fundamental Rights and judicial review; Ireland gave the Directive Principles; Canada a strong-centre federation; Australia the Concurrent List and joint sittings; Weimar Germany the suspension of rights in emergencies; the USSR Fundamental Duties; France the republic and its ideals; South Africa the amendment procedure and election of Rajya Sabha members. The framers adapted all of these to Indian needs.
Check your understanding
-
1. From which source did the framers take the Directive Principles of State Policy?
- The US Constitution
- The Irish Constitution
- The Canadian Constitution
- The Government of India Act, 1935
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook lists the Irish Constitution as the source of the Directive Principles of State Policy. The US gave Fundamental Rights and judicial review; Canada a strong-centre federation.
-
2. Which feature was adopted from the Government of India Act, 1935?
- Public service commissions
- Fundamental Duties
- Judicial review
- Liberty, equality and fraternity
Show answer
Answer: A. The 1935 Act supplied federal provisions, the office of Governor, the judiciary, public service commissions, emergency provisions and administrative details. Fundamental Duties are Soviet-inspired, judicial review is American and the three ideals are French.
-
3. Residuary powers resting with the Centre and a federation with a strong centre were inspired by which constitution?
- Australian
- Irish
- French
- Canadian
Show answer
Answer: D. Canada's federation gives residuary powers to the centre and has a strong centre. India also took from Canada the appointment of state Governors by the centre and the advisory jurisdiction of the Supreme Court.
-
4. The procedure for amending the Constitution and the election of Rajya Sabha members were inspired by the constitution of:
- Weimar Germany
- the USSR
- South Africa
- the United Kingdom
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook names South Africa as the source of the amendment procedure and the election of members of the Rajya Sabha.
-
5. Consider: (1) Fundamental Duties came from the Soviet model. (2) Fundamental Duties were part of the Constitution from 1950. Which is correct?
- Only statement 1
- Only statement 2
- Both statements
- Neither statement
Show answer
Answer: A. Statement 1 is correct: the Fundamental Duties follow the Soviet model. Statement 2 is wrong: they were added later, by the 42nd Amendment in 1976, so only statement 1 is correct.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.