- Practice
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
The Prime Minister, the Council of Ministers and the Cabinet
Explain how the Prime Minister is appointed and why he or she is first among equals, the Prime Minister's Office, the Council of Ministers under Articles 74 and 75, collective responsibility, the Cabinet, and the Cabinet Secretary.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain how the Prime Minister is appointed under Article 75 and why there is no fixed term.
- List the functions that show the Prime Minister's pre-eminent position.
- Describe the Prime Minister's Office.
- Explain the three ranks of ministers, collective responsibility, and the roles of the Cabinet and the Cabinet Secretary.
India adopted the British (Westminster) model of parliamentary executive, with the Prime Minister as head of government. The Constitution provides a collegiate executive: a Council of Ministers chaired by the Prime Minister. Lord Morley described the head of the cabinet as primus inter pares, first among equals, and as the keystone of the cabinet arch.
Appointment of the Prime Minister
The Constitution lays down no specific procedure for choosing the Prime Minister, and there is no direct election to the post. Article 75 says only that the President shall appoint the Prime Minister. By convention the President appoints the leader of the majority party or coalition in the Lok Sabha; if no party has a majority, the person most likely to win majority support. The Prime Minister has no fixed term and remains in office as long as he or she leads the majority.
Functions and pre-eminent position
- prepares the list of ministers and, with the President, forms the Council of Ministers; decides their rank (Cabinet, Minister of State, Deputy Minister) and may designate a Deputy Prime Minister;
- advises the President on allocating portfolios, may keep any department, reshuffle portfolios, and split or merge departments;
- may advise the President to dismiss a minister or ask a minister to resign;
- chairs the Cabinet, summons and presides over its meetings, and heads bodies such as the Inter-State Council, the NITI Aayog and the Nuclear Command Authority;
- coordinates the policy of the government and supervises all departments;
- the resignation of a minister merely creates a vacancy, but the resignation or death of the Prime Minister ends the whole Council of Ministers;
- is the sole channel of communication between the President and the ministers, and between Parliament and the ministers, and is the chief spokesperson of the government in foreign affairs.
The Prime Minister's Office (PMO)
The PMO gives secretarial help and advice to the Prime Minister. It is an extra-constitutional body (not created by the Constitution) with the status of a department of the Government of India. It came into existence in 1947 and was called the Prime Minister's Secretariat until 1977. It is headed politically by the Prime Minister and administratively by the Principal Secretary. It keeps the Prime Minister in touch with ministries and state governments, assists with the NITI Aayog, handles press and public relations, deals with matters that come to the Prime Minister under the Rules of Business, keeps relations with the President, Governors and foreign representatives, and acts as the Prime Minister's think-tank. Cabinet business, however, is handled by the Cabinet Secretariat, not the PMO.
The Council of Ministers (Articles 74 and 75)
- Article 74: there shall be a Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister to aid and advise the President, who shall act in accordance with that advice. So there must always be a Council of Ministers.
- Article 75: the President appoints the Prime Minister, and the other ministers on the Prime Minister's advice. Ministers hold office during the President's pleasure, but in practice the President appoints only those the Prime Minister recommends.
- Three ranks: Cabinet Ministers (who make policy), Ministers of State and Deputy Ministers (mainly administrative); they differ in rank, pay and political weight.
- Collective responsibility: the whole Council is jointly responsible to the Lok Sabha for every act of the government; ministers must speak with one voice in public. A defeat on a no-confidence motion brings down the whole Council.
The Cabinet and its helpers
The Cabinet is the smaller body of Cabinet-rank ministers within the Council: its nucleus and the highest policy-making body. The whole Council rarely meets; the Cabinet takes the decisions. It deals with all major legislative, financial and foreign-policy matters; controls higher appointments; recommends ordinances; supervises implementation; appoints commissions of inquiry and settles disputes between departments; and recommends emergencies, dissolution of the Lok Sabha and prorogation. The textbook calls the Cabinet extra-constitutional; the word 'Cabinet' entered the Constitution only through the 44th Amendment (1978), in Article 352.
- Kitchen (inner) cabinet: an informal circle of the Prime Minister's most trusted colleagues within the Cabinet, which helps keep important decisions secret.
- Shadow cabinet: in Britain, the opposition assigns its members to follow each minister's portfolio. It keeps the opposition informed and the government alert.
- Cabinet Secretary: the senior-most civil servant, head of the Cabinet Secretariat. As the textbook describes, he or she chairs the board that selects senior officers for Joint Secretary posts, presides over the annual conference of state Chief Secretaries, is chief adviser to the Prime Minister on administration, and links the PMO with the administrative agencies and the civil service with the political leadership.
The Union executive
-
President
- Constitutional head
- Acts on ministerial advice (Article 74)
-
Prime Minister
- Head of government
- Primus inter pares
- Assisted by the PMO
-
Council of Ministers
- Cabinet Ministers
- Ministers of State
- Deputy Ministers
-
Cabinet
- Highest policy body
- Cabinet Secretariat
- Cabinet Secretary
Ministers are appointed by the President on the Prime Minister's advice and are collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha. The Prime Minister's exit ends the whole Council.
Worked example 1: what happens to the government?
(a) A Minister of State resigns. (b) The Prime Minister resigns. (c) The Lok Sabha passes a no-confidence motion. Working: (a) only one post falls vacant and the government continues. (b) the entire Council of Ministers comes to an end, because it exists around the Prime Minister. (c) because the Council is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha, the whole government must resign.
Worked example 2: hung House
After an election no party has a majority in the Lok Sabha. Analysis: the Constitution sets no procedure, so the President uses judgement and appoints the person most likely to command a majority, usually the leader of the largest party or of a coalition. That person must then prove majority support on the floor of the House.
Key takeaways: the President appoints as Prime Minister the leader who commands a Lok Sabha majority; the Prime Minister has no fixed term and is first among equals, forming the ministry, allotting portfolios, chairing the Cabinet and acting as the link with the President. The PMO, set up in 1947, is extra-constitutional. Article 74 requires a Council of Ministers to aid and advise the President; ministers are of three ranks and collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha. The Cabinet is the highest policy body, served by the Cabinet Secretary.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which Article provides that the President shall appoint the Prime Minister?
- Article 74
- Article 52
- Article 75
- Article 63
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 75 provides that the Prime Minister is appointed by the President and other ministers on the Prime Minister's advice. Article 74 creates the Council of Ministers to aid and advise the President.
-
2. Until 1977 the Prime Minister's Office was known as:
- The Prime Minister's Secretariat
- The Cabinet Secretariat
- The Planning Commission
- The Central Secretariat
Show answer
Answer: A. The PMO came into existence in 1947 and was called the Prime Minister's Secretariat until 1977.
-
3. What happens to the Council of Ministers when the Prime Minister resigns?
- Only the Prime Minister's post falls vacant
- The senior-most minister becomes Prime Minister automatically
- The President takes over the government
- The whole Council of Ministers comes to an end
Show answer
Answer: D. A minister's resignation creates a vacancy, but the resignation or death of the Prime Minister ends the entire Council of Ministers.
-
4. To whom is the Union Council of Ministers collectively responsible?
- The President
- The Lok Sabha
- The Rajya Sabha
- Both Houses equally
Show answer
Answer: B. The Council is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha, which can remove it by a no-confidence motion. The Rajya Sabha can criticise but cannot remove it.
-
5. Lord Morley described the Prime Minister as 'primus inter pares'. What does this mean?
- Head of state
- Leader of the opposition
- First among equals
- Supreme commander
Show answer
Answer: C. Primus inter pares means first among equals: the Prime Minister is a minister like the others but leads them, and Morley called the office the keystone of the cabinet arch.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.