• Practice
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

The State executive: the Governor and the Chief Minister

Describe the Governor's appointment, term and executive, legislative, financial, judicial and discretionary powers, the Advocate General, President's rule under Article 356, and the Chief Minister with the state council of ministers.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the constitutional provisions on the Governor (Articles 153 to 156).
  • Classify the Governor's powers, including the discretionary powers.
  • Explain the Governor's role under Article 356.
  • Describe the Chief Minister's position and the state council of ministers.

Articles 153 to 167 in Part VI of the Constitution deal with the State Executive: the Governor and the Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister. The states follow the same parliamentary pattern as the Union: the Governor is to the state what the President is to the Union.

The Governor: provisions

  • Article 153: there shall be a Governor for each state; since the 7th Amendment of 1956, one person may be Governor of two or more states.
  • Article 155: the Governor is appointed by the President.
  • Qualifications: a citizen of India, at least 35 years old, holds no other office of profit, and is not a member of Parliament or a state legislature.
  • Article 156: the term is five years, but the Governor holds office during the President's pleasure, may be removed at any time and may be transferred to another state. Salary is fixed by Parliament.
  • The Governor is the constitutional head of the state: executive power is vested in the Governor and exercised in his or her name, but real power lies with the Council of Ministers, collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly.

Powers of the Governor

Powers of the Governor
KindMain powers
ExecutiveExecutive power exercised directly or through subordinate officers (Article 154) over State List matters; appoints the Chief Minister and, on his or her advice, other ministers; appoints the Advocate General and the chairman and members of the State Public Service Commission; may report to the President under Article 356 and runs the state for the President during President's rule
LegislativePart of the state legislature (Article 168); summons, prorogues and dissolves the Assembly; addresses the legislature; assents to, withholds assent from, returns, or reserves bills for the President; issues ordinances (Article 213); nominates one-sixth of the Legislative Council where there is one
FinancialNo Money Bill without the Governor's prior recommendation; no demand for grants without recommendation; controls the Contingency Fund of the state
JudicialAppointments, postings and promotions of judges of subordinate courts (district and munsif courts); consulted by the President on High Court appointments; pardons, reprieves, remissions and commutations for offences against state laws

A bill returned for reconsideration and passed again, with or without amendments, must receive the Governor's assent. An ordinance must be approved by the legislature within six weeks of its reassembly, or it lapses. (The textbook also mentions nominating an Anglo-Indian member to the Assembly; that ended in January 2020.)

Discretionary powers

Unlike the President, the Governor has some powers to act on his or her own judgement. The textbook lists:

  • appointing a Chief Minister when no party or leader has a clear majority;
  • dismissing a ministry that refuses to resign after losing its majority or a no-confidence vote;
  • deciding on dissolution of the Assembly when advised by a Chief Minister who has lost majority support;
  • reporting to the President that the constitutional machinery has failed, leading to President's rule;
  • decisions on assent to bills, such as reserving a bill for the President.

President's rule (Article 356)

The Governor has no emergency powers to deal with war or armed rebellion. But if the government of the state cannot be carried on in accordance with the Constitution, the Governor may report this to the President, who may then take over the functions of the state government. During President's rule there is no Council of Ministers; the Governor runs the state on the President's behalf. Because this power has often been used, its proper use is a frequent question for critical analysis.

Advocate General

Each state has an Advocate General, the state's counterpart of the Attorney-General of India. He or she must be qualified to be a judge of a High Court and is appointed by the Governor.

The Chief Minister and the state council of ministers

As studied in Unit 2, the Chief Minister is appointed by the Governor under Article 164(1) and is the real executive head. He or she recommends ministers and their ranks, allocates and changes portfolios, presides over the cabinet, is the sole channel of communication between the council of ministers and the Governor, scrutinises papers and bills for the legislature, and in practice advises on all major appointments. Under Article 163(1) the council aids and advises the Governor except where the Governor must act in discretion; ministers are individually responsible to the Chief Minister and collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly. Cabinet decisions bind every minister.

President and Governor

  • President
    • Elected by an electoral college
    • Removed only by impeachment
    • Acts on ministerial advice
    • Can proclaim three emergencies
  • Governor
    • Appointed by the President
    • Holds office during the President's pleasure
    • Has some discretionary powers
    • Can only report under Article 356

The Governor is the constitutional head; the Chief Minister is the real head. The Governor reports, the President proclaims, under Article 356.

Worked example 1: power or discretion?

(a) The Governor appoints the leader of a party with a clear majority as Chief Minister. (b) After an election with no clear majority, the Governor invites the leader thought most likely to win a confidence vote. Working: (a) is a formal executive power exercised by convention: there is no real choice. (b) is a discretionary power, because the Governor must judge who can command a majority.

Worked example 2: which power?

(a) The Governor commutes the sentence of a person convicted under a state law. (b) The Governor recommends a demand for grants. (c) The Governor issues an ordinance while the Assembly is not in session. Working: (a) judicial power; (b) financial power; (c) legislative power under Article 213, which must be approved within six weeks of the Assembly reassembling.

Key takeaways: a Governor is appointed by the President for five years during pleasure, must be at least 35, and is the state's constitutional head. The Governor's executive, legislative, financial and judicial powers are exercised on ministerial advice, but some discretionary powers remain, including the report under Article 356. The Advocate General is the state's chief law officer. The Chief Minister, appointed under Article 164(1), is the real executive, and the council of ministers is collectively responsible to the Assembly.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which amendment made it possible to appoint one person as Governor of two or more states?

    1. The 42nd Amendment
    2. The 7th Amendment of 1956
    3. The 44th Amendment
    4. The 52nd Amendment
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The 7th Amendment (1956) allowed the same person to be appointed Governor of two or more states.

  2. 2. Who appoints the Advocate General of a state?

    1. The Governor
    2. The Chief Justice of the High Court
    3. The President
    4. The Chief Minister
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Advocate General, the state's counterpart of the Attorney-General, is appointed by the Governor and must be qualified to be a High Court judge.

  3. 3. Within what time must the state legislature approve a Governor's ordinance after it reassembles?

    1. 14 days
    2. Six months
    3. One year
    4. Six weeks
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Under Article 213 the ordinance lapses six weeks after the legislature reassembles unless approved.

  4. 4. Which of these is a discretionary power of the Governor?

    1. Appointing the leader of a party with a clear majority as Chief Minister
    2. Addressing the legislature
    3. Choosing a Chief Minister when no party has a clear majority
    4. Signing a bill passed again after reconsideration
    Show answer

    Answer: C. When no party has a majority, the Governor must use judgement to choose a Chief Minister: a discretionary power. Appointing a clear majority leader is a formal act, and a bill passed again after reconsideration must be assented to.

  5. 5. Under Article 356, what is the Governor's role?

    1. Proclaiming a national emergency
    2. Reporting to the President that the state government cannot be carried on according to the Constitution
    3. Declaring a financial emergency
    4. Dissolving Parliament
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Governor reports to the President, who may then impose President's rule. The Governor has no power to proclaim a national or financial emergency.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Executive

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery