• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Election Commission, CAG and financial administration

Explain the roles of the Election Commission and the CAG, and describe the objectives, principles and history of financial administration in India, the budget cycle and preparation, and the structure of direct and indirect taxes including GST.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the constitutional basis and role of the Election Commission and the CAG.
  • List the objectives and principles of financial administration and its four historical phases.
  • Describe the budget cycle, how budget estimates are prepared, and the difference between direct and indirect taxes.

Administration needs two more supports to be trusted: fair elections that choose the government, and honest handling of public money. This final lesson covers the Election Commission, the Comptroller and Auditor General and the textbook's account of financial administration.

Election Commission

The Election Commission is a permanent, independent body set up by the Constitution to ensure free and fair elections. Under Article 324, superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament, state legislatures, and the offices of President and Vice-President are vested in it. It is common to the Union and the states. It does not conduct elections to panchayats and municipalities; for these the Constitution provides separate State Election Commissions.

Comptroller and Auditor General of India

Article 148 provides for an independent Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG), head of the Indian Audit and Accounts Department. The CAG is the guardian of the public purse at both Union and state levels and upholds the Constitution and Parliament's laws in financial administration. The textbook recalls Dr B. R. Ambedkar's view that the CAG would be the most important officer under the Constitution, and calls the CAG one of the bulwarks of democracy, together with the Supreme Court, the Election Commission and UPSC.

Financial administration: objectives and principles

Eight objectives and eight principles
Objectives (textbook's list)Principles (textbook's list)
Managing the finances of the public householdPrimacy of public interest, public choice and public policy
Implementing projects and programmesPolitical direction and control
Providing public goods and social servicesCorrespondence
Growth, employment and price stabilityUnity of organisation and management
Capital formationStability and balance
Productive use of national fundsSimplicity and flexibility
Smooth parliamentary processesConduct, discipline and regularity
Equity and equalityPublic trust and accountability

The textbook divides India's financial administrative history into four phases: 1765-1858 (creating the structure), 1860-1919 (developing systems and procedures), 1919-1947 (democratisation and decentralisation) and 1950 onwards (development orientation). Emerging trends include controlling the fiscal deficit, cutting non-development expenditure, a zero-base perspective, a de-emphasised public sector, non-bureaucratic delivery of services, decentralised responsibility for financing plans, and deregulation and liberalisation.

The budget cycle

The four phases of the budget cycle

  1. Preparation and submission Departments prepare estimates on the Finance Ministry's circular
  2. Approval The legislature examines and passes the budget
  3. Execution Departments spend the money as approved
  4. Audit Accounts are checked, and lessons feed the next preparation

Then back to step 1: Preparation and submission

Several cycles run at the same time and overlap.

Budget preparation begins with a circular from the Ministry of Finance around September or October, about six months before presentation. The general rule is that whoever spends the money prepares the estimates. Proposals contain the accounts classification, budget estimates and revised estimates of the current year, actuals of the previous year, and proposed estimates for the next year. When the first modern budget was presented in 1860, the financial year ran from 1 May to 30 April; from 1866 it became 1 April to 31 March, following the practice in England.

Tax structure

A direct tax is paid by the taxpayer directly to the government: income tax, corporate tax, wealth tax, capital gains tax and securities transaction tax are examples in the textbook. An indirect tax is imposed on the manufacture or sale of goods and services and passed on to buyers: customs duty, excise duty, sales tax, entertainment tax, luxury tax and the Goods and Services Tax (GST). GST subsumed many earlier taxes. Within a state it is levied as CGST (Central GST) and SGST (State GST); between two states it is IGST (Integrated GST). Items such as petrol, diesel, natural gas, aviation fuel and liquor were kept outside GST in the textbook's account.

Election Commission: Article 324. CAG: Article 148. Budget cycle: preparation, approval, execution, audit. Direct tax: paid by the taxpayer to the government. Indirect tax: on goods and services, passed on to buyers.

Worked example 1: direct or indirect?

Classify: (a) a company pays tax on its yearly profit; (b) a shopper pays GST included in the price of a schoolbag; (c) an importer pays duty on machines brought from abroad. Working: (a) is corporate tax, paid directly by the taxpayer: direct. (b) GST is collected through the seller from the buyer: indirect. (c) customs duty on imports: indirect.

Worked example 2: which GST?

A made-up trader in Chennai sells goods (i) to a buyer in Madurai and (ii) to a buyer in Bengaluru. Working: (i) is a sale within Tamil Nadu, so CGST and SGST apply. (ii) crosses state borders, from Tamil Nadu to Karnataka, so IGST applies.

Key takeaways: the Election Commission (Article 324) conducts elections to Parliament, state legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President, but not local bodies. The CAG (Article 148) guards the public purse. Financial administration has eight objectives and eight principles, four historical phases, and a four-phase budget cycle. Since 1866 India's financial year runs from 1 April to 31 March. Taxes are direct or indirect; GST is levied as CGST and SGST within a state and IGST between states.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Elections to which body are NOT under the Election Commission of India?

    1. Lok Sabha
    2. State Legislative Assemblies
    3. Office of the Vice-President
    4. Panchayats and municipalities
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 324 gives the Election Commission control of elections to Parliament, state legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President. Panchayat and municipal elections are conducted by State Election Commissions.

  2. 2. Which Article of the Constitution provides for the Comptroller and Auditor General of India?

    1. Article 148
    2. Article 280
    3. Article 324
    4. Article 320
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 148 provides for the CAG. Article 324 is the Election Commission, 320 deals with the functions of Public Service Commissions and 280 with the Finance Commission.

  3. 3. What is the correct order of the four phases of the budget cycle?

    1. Approval, preparation, audit, execution
    2. Preparation and submission, approval, execution, audit
    3. Execution, audit, approval, preparation
    4. Audit, preparation, execution, approval
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A budget must be prepared before it is approved, approved before money is spent, and spending is audited afterwards: preparation and submission, approval, execution, audit.

  4. 4. From 1866, the Indian financial year was changed to run from

    1. 1 May to 30 April
    2. 1 January to 31 December
    3. 1 April to 31 March
    4. 1 July to 30 June
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The first modern budget of 1860 used 1 May to 30 April. From 1866 the year was changed to 1 April to 31 March, in line with the practice in England.

  5. 5. A made-up company in Coimbatore sells goods to a buyer in Kerala. Which form of GST applies?

    1. IGST
    2. SGST only
    3. CGST only
    4. No GST, since it is a sale between states
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A sale between two states attracts Integrated GST (IGST). CGST together with SGST applies to sales within one state.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery