• Practice
  • About 19 min
  • 5 practice questions

UPSC, State Public Service Commissions and the Staff Selection Commission

Trace the history of the Public Service Commission in India and explain the organisation, independence, functions, limitations and role of UPSC and State Public Service Commissions, and the work of the Staff Selection Commission.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Trace the Public Service Commission from 1919 to the UPSC of 1950.
  • Explain the composition, term, removal and independence of a State Public Service Commission.
  • List the functions and limitations of a State Public Service Commission and the work of the Staff Selection Commission.

A fair recruitment system is the first defence against favouritism. India's Constitution gives this job to independent commissions. This lesson studies the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC), the State Public Service Commissions and the Staff Selection Commission.

From 1919 to 1950: the history of UPSC

Steps towards the Union Public Service Commission

  1. 1919 First Dispatch on constitutional reforms (5 March 1919); Section 96(C) of the Government of India Act, 1919 provides for a Public Service Commission
  2. 1924 The Lee Commission (Royal Commission on the Superior Civil Services) urges that it be set up without delay
  3. 1 October 1926 Public Service Commission set up: a Chairman and four Members; first Chairman Sir Ross Barker
  4. 1937 Under the Government of India Act, 1935 it becomes the Federal Public Service Commission (from 1 April 1937)
  5. 26 January 1950 Renamed the Union Public Service Commission under Article 378(1)

Today UPSC is a constitutional body established under Article 315. According to the textbook it consists of a Chairman and ten Members. Under Articles 320 and 321, its mandate includes recruitment through competitive examinations and interviews, advising on promotions and deputations, advising on methods of recruitment, framing recruitment rules, disciplinary cases, extraordinary pensions and legal expenses, any matter the President refers to it, and, at a Governor's request and with the President's approval, the recruitment needs of a state. A Secretariat headed by a Secretary supports it.

Articles 315-323 (Part XIV) on Public Service Commissions
ArticleSubject
315Public Service Commissions for the Union and the states
316Appointment and term of members
317Removal and suspension of members
318Regulations on conditions of service
319Offices barred to members after they leave
320Functions
321Power to extend functions
322Expenses
323Reports

State Public Service Commission: composition and term

A State Public Service Commission has a chairman and members appointed by the Governor. The Constitution does not fix its strength; the Governor decides. No qualifications are laid down except that half the members must have held office for at least ten years under the Government of India or a state. Members hold office for six years or until age 62, whichever is earlier (for UPSC the age limit is 65). They may resign by writing to the Governor. When the chairman's post is vacant or the chairman cannot work, the Governor may appoint a member as acting chairman.

Removal and independence

Although the Governor appoints them, members can be removed only by the President, on the same grounds as UPSC members: insolvency, paid employment outside their duties, or unfitness through infirmity of mind or body. For misbehaviour, the President must refer the matter to the Supreme Court; its advice after enquiry is binding, and the Governor may suspend the member meanwhile. Misbehaviour includes being interested in, or profiting from, a government contract (other than as an ordinary shareholder of a company).

  • security of tenure: removal only on the grounds and in the manner in the Constitution;
  • conditions of service cannot be changed to a member's disadvantage after appointment;
  • expenses are charged on the Consolidated Fund of the State, so they are not voted by the legislature;
  • after leaving, the chairman may become chairman or member of UPSC or chairman of another State PSC, but may take no other government job; a member may become chairman or member of UPSC or chairman of a State PSC;
  • a chairman or member is not eligible for a second term in the same office.

Functions, limitations and role

A State PSC conducts examinations for state services and is consulted on methods of recruitment, principles for appointments, promotions and transfers, suitability of candidates, disciplinary matters (from censure and withholding increments to compulsory retirement, removal and dismissal), legal expenses of civil servants and pensions for injuries on duty. The textbook notes the Supreme Court's view that failure to consult the commission does not invalidate a decision: the provision is directory, not mandatory. The state legislature can give it extra functions. It reports annually to the Governor, who places the report before the legislature with a memorandum explaining any advice not accepted.

It is not consulted on reservations for backward classes or on the claims of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in appointments. The Governor may exclude posts from its purview by regulations laid before the legislature for at least 14 days. The textbook calls it the 'watchdog of the merit system', but its advice is not binding, it is only a central recruiting agency (the Department of Personnel or General Administration Department is the central personnel agency), and the State Vigilance Commission (from 1964) also advises on discipline.

Staff Selection Commission

The Staff Selection Commission (SSC) recruits for Group B and Group C non-technical posts in Union ministries and their offices. It holds open competitive examinations for posts such as lower division clerks, stenographers, assistants, inspectors of central excise, sub-inspectors in the CBI and central police organisations, auditors and accountants, junior engineers in CPWD, statistical investigators, tax assistants and section officers. It also holds departmental examinations for promotion (for example lower division clerk to upper division clerk) and performs other functions the Union government gives it.

A State PSC is appointed by the Governor but removed only by the President; for misbehaviour, only after a Supreme Court enquiry. Its advice is advisory, not binding.

Worked example 1: who can remove the member?

A made-up member of a State PSC is accused of taking a share of profit from a state road contract. Working: this is misbehaviour as defined in the Constitution. The Governor cannot remove the member, but may suspend the member while the President refers the matter to the Supreme Court. If the Supreme Court's enquiry upholds the charge, the President removes the member, and the Court's advice binds the President.

Worked example 2: is the decision invalid?

A made-up state government promotes an officer without consulting its PSC. The officer who was passed over goes to court claiming the promotion is void. Reasoning: the textbook reports the Supreme Court's view that consultation is directory, not mandatory, so lack of consultation does not by itself invalidate the decision. The safeguard is political: the government must answer to the legislature.

Key takeaways: the Public Service Commission began in 1926, became federal in 1937 and became UPSC in 1950 (Article 315). A State PSC is appointed by the Governor, serves six years or until 62, and is removed only by the President. Its independence rests on tenure, protected service conditions, charged expenses and bars on later jobs. Its advice is not binding, and it is not consulted on reservations. The SSC recruits Group B and C staff for the Union.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. When was the Public Service Commission, the forerunner of UPSC, first set up in India?

    1. 5 March 1919
    2. 1 April 1937
    3. 1 October 1926
    4. 26 January 1950
    Show answer

    Answer: C. It was set up on 1 October 1926 after the Lee Commission's 1924 recommendation. 1919 is the Act that provided for it, 1937 is when it became federal and 1950 is when it became UPSC.

  2. 2. Who can remove the chairman of a State Public Service Commission?

    1. The Governor
    2. The Chief Minister
    3. The state legislature
    4. The President
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Members are appointed by the Governor but can be removed only by the President, on the grounds in the Constitution; for misbehaviour, after a Supreme Court enquiry.

  3. 3. For how long does a member of a State Public Service Commission hold office?

    1. Six years or until age 62, whichever is earlier
    2. Five years or until age 65, whichever is earlier
    3. Until age 60 only
    4. As long as the Governor wishes
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook gives six years or age 62, whichever is earlier, for a State PSC. The age limit of 65 applies to UPSC.

  4. 4. On which matter is a State Public Service Commission NOT consulted?

    1. Methods of recruitment to civil services
    2. Reservation of posts in favour of backward classes
    3. Disciplinary matters of state civil servants
    4. Suitability of candidates for appointment
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook lists reservations for backward classes, and the claims of SCs and STs, as matters outside its consultation. The other three are among its functions.

  5. 5. Why does the textbook describe the consultation provision for a State PSC as 'directory and not mandatory'?

    1. Because the Commission's advice binds the Governor
    2. Because the President must approve every consultation
    3. Because the Supreme Court held that failure to consult does not invalidate the government's decision
    4. Because consultation is required only for judges
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Supreme Court held that the aggrieved servant has no remedy in court if the commission was not consulted; acting without consultation does not invalidate the decision. So the provision directs but does not compel.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery