- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Planning: meaning, evolution and objectives
Explain what economic planning means, why a welfare state plans, how planning ideas evolved in India before independence, and the objectives the Constitution and the government set for planning after 1947.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define a planned system and contrast a police state with a welfare state.
- Trace pre-independence planning ideas: Visvesvaraya, the National Planning Committee, the Bombay, People's, Gandhian and Sarvodaya plans.
- State the objectives of planning after independence and their link to the Directive Principles.
A family that wants to build a house saves, chooses what to buy first and fixes a timetable. A country that wants to end poverty must do the same on a vast scale. That is planning. This chapter of the Tamil Nadu textbook studies how India planned its development and what politics shaped it.
What is planning?
The textbook says planning exists in all economies and political systems. A planned system aims at the systematic use of a state's resources for long-term progress: raising output, national income and employment and improving social welfare. In such a system productive units use resources according to the directives of the government, which sets targets for public and private enterprises and regulates both.
| Police state (older idea) | Welfare state (modern idea) |
|---|---|
| Concerned only with security, law and order | Also responsible for the social and economic well-being of citizens |
| Limited role in the economy | Plans and carries out socio-economic reforms |
| Does not aim at social justice | Aims at socio-economic justice and good governance |
The textbook adds that democracy gives the best scope to realise welfare-state goals, and it raises a question for discussion: development for one group may not be development for another. Higher wages help workers but raise costs for employers; a dam gives cheap power but displaces people. Hence it recommends sustainable development.
Planning ideas before independence
| Year | Plan or body | Key idea (as in the textbook) |
|---|---|---|
| 1936 | 'Planned Economy for India' by M. Visvesvaraya | Proposed a ten-year plan; he is called a pioneer of planning in India |
| 1938 | National Planning Committee of the Congress, initiated under Subhas Chandra Bose's presidency | To prepare an economic plan; work halted by the Second World War and leaders' imprisonment |
| 1944 | Bombay Plan | Prepared by leading Indian industrialists |
| 1945 | People's Plan of M. N. Roy | Gave more importance to agriculture and small-scale industries |
| 1944 | Gandhian Plan of Shriman Narayan Agarwal | Based on Gandhian ideas of development |
| 1950 | Sarvodaya Plan of Jayaprakash Narayan | Development for the welfare of all |
Planning after independence
After independence, the Directive Principles of State Policy in Part IV of the Constitution directed the state to secure socio-economic justice. Its makers understood that economic development must go with social justice, so the government adopted planning as a means of development. The textbook lists the objectives:
- increase production so that national and per capita income rise;
- guarantee employment;
- narrow the gap between rich and poor;
- build an egalitarian society by giving the state a wider role, so that socio-economic justice and economic development are both achieved.
From ideas to a planning institution
- Ideas (1930s-1940s) Visvesvaraya, National Planning Committee, Bombay, People's, Gandhian plans
- Constitution (1950) Directive Principles in Part IV call for socio-economic justice
- Planning Commission (March 1950) Set up by a government resolution to plan the use of resources
- Five-Year Plans Targets for growth, employment and justice
Planning = systematic use of a nation's resources for long-term growth and welfare. In India it grew from the Directive Principles' promise of socio-economic justice.
Worked example 1: police state or welfare state?
A made-up government (a) runs free schools and hospitals and (b) keeps an army and police force. Another (c) only keeps the army and police. Working: (b) and (c) are duties every state performs; a government that does only these is a police state in the textbook's sense. (a) adds responsibility for citizens' welfare, so the first government is a welfare state.
Worked example 2: whose development?
A made-up plan proposes a large dam. Factory owners welcome cheap power; farmers whose fields would be flooded protest. Analysis: the textbook's point is that development has different meanings for different groups. A planner following sustainable development would weigh power needs against displacement and the environment, look for smaller or alternative projects, and plan rehabilitation for those affected.
Key takeaways: planning is the systematic, government-directed use of resources for long-term progress and welfare. A welfare state, unlike a police state, takes responsibility for socio-economic justice. Planning ideas in India came from Visvesvaraya (1936), the National Planning Committee (1938) and several plans in the 1940s. After 1950, guided by the Directive Principles, planning aimed at higher income, employment, less inequality and an egalitarian society.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who is called a pioneer of economic planning in India for his 1936 book 'Planned Economy for India'?
- Jayaprakash Narayan
- M. Visvesvaraya
- M. N. Roy
- Shriman Narayan Agarwal
Show answer
Answer: B. M. Visvesvaraya proposed a ten-year plan in that 1936 book. Jayaprakash Narayan drafted the Sarvodaya Plan, M. N. Roy the People's Plan and Shriman Narayan Agarwal the Gandhian Plan.
-
2. Which part of the Constitution contains the Directive Principles that guided planning?
- Part III
- Part XIV
- Part IV
- Part I
Show answer
Answer: C. The Directive Principles of State Policy are in Part IV. Part III contains Fundamental Rights and Part XIV the services and Public Service Commissions.
-
3. How does a welfare state differ from a police state, according to the textbook?
- It is always ruled by a monarch
- It has no police
- It does not maintain law and order
- It also ensures the social and economic well-being of its citizens
Show answer
Answer: D. A police state is concerned only with security and law and order; a welfare state does that too, but also takes responsibility for socio-economic justice and well-being.
-
4. Why could the National Planning Committee of 1938 not complete its task?
- It was abolished by the Constituent Assembly
- It was merged with the Bombay Plan
- Industrialists refused to fund it
- The Second World War broke out and some national leaders were imprisoned
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook says the committee could not finish because of the outbreak of the Second World War and the imprisonment of some leaders.
-
5. Which of these is NOT an objective of planning listed in the textbook?
- Increasing national and per capita income
- Guaranteeing employment
- Concentrating wealth in a few hands
- Narrowing the gap between rich and poor
Show answer
Answer: C. Planning aimed at higher income, employment, a narrower rich-poor gap and an egalitarian society. Concentrating wealth is the opposite of these goals.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.