- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
The Planning Commission, social justice and the mixed economy
Describe the setting up, functions and composition of the Planning Commission and the National Development Council, and explain how planning addressed poverty, social justice and the rural-urban divide through democratic socialism and a mixed economy.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State when and how the Planning Commission was set up and list its functions.
- Describe its composition and divisions, and the roles of the National Planning Council and the National Development Council.
- Explain poverty reduction, Article 38(2), the rural-urban divide, democratic socialism and the mixed economy.
For more than six decades, one body in New Delhi drew up India's Five-Year Plans. This lesson studies the Planning Commission: how it was organised, what it did, and the ideas of social justice and mixed economy behind its work.
Setting up and functions
The Planning Commission was set up on 15 March 1950 by a resolution of the Government of India, with Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru as chairman, to prepare a plan for the 'most effective and balanced utilisation of the country's resources'. It was advisory; the Union and state governments implemented the plans. Its functions, as the textbook lists them, were:
- assessing the nation's material, capital and human resources;
- preparing plans for their effective and balanced use;
- allocating resources among sectors according to priorities and laying down stages of the plan;
- identifying conditions that hinder development;
- deciding how the plan could be implemented and reviewing progress periodically;
- advising the Union and state governments on planning strategies and on particular issues;
- fixing the growth rate and the targets for each sector in the plan period.
Composition and organisation
The textbook says the Commission had the Prime Minister as chairman, who presided over meetings, and, after the Administrative Reforms Commission's recommendations, a Deputy Chairman as de facto executive head who placed the draft plans before the Union Cabinet, full-time members who were experts in technical fields, economics and administration, some Cabinet ministers as part-time members (the Finance Minister and the Planning Minister were ex-officio members), and a member secretary, usually a senior IAS officer. There were no representatives of the states: it was a central body. It worked on the principle of collective responsibility and had a General Division (the whole economy), Subject Divisions (food and agriculture, power and irrigation, transport and so on) and an Administrative Division, along with an evaluation division.
| Body | Members | Role |
|---|---|---|
| National Planning Council | Experts in science, engineering and economics | Studied sectors such as agriculture, irrigation, education, industry and transport and supplied data to the Commission |
| National Development Council (NDC) | The Prime Minister (chairman), all Chief Ministers, Union ministers, administrators of Union Territories and members of the Planning Commission | Reviewed the working of plans, considered major social and economic policy questions, and gave the states a voice; an extra-constitutional, non-statutory body whose first meeting was held in November 1952 |
Poverty, social justice and the rural-urban divide
Planning aimed not only at higher per capita income but at a better quality of life: food, clothing and shelter, and also education and health care. Growth and poverty reduction do not always go together, so from the Fourth Plan the government focused directly on poverty, with the slogan 'garibi hatao' (remove poverty) in the early 1970s. Employment generation was stressed in every plan. Planners kept in mind Article 38(2), which directs the state to minimise inequalities of income and to try to eliminate inequalities of status, facilities and opportunities among individuals and groups. The textbook links the Fundamental Rights (Part III, justiciable) and the Directive Principles (Part IV, non-justiciable) as two supports of social and economic justice. It also notes that the Commission recommended rural development programmes to reduce the rural-urban divide.
The textbook also describes the Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI), which looks beyond income. It measures deprivation in three dimensions (health, education and standard of living) through ten indicators such as nutrition, child mortality, years of schooling, school attendance, cooking fuel, sanitation, drinking water, electricity, housing and assets. A person deprived in at least one-third of the weighted indicators is counted as multidimensionally poor.
Democratic socialism and the mixed economy
Nehru, the textbook says, was the architect of planning in India. Inspired both by the Soviet model of planning and by liberal principles, he combined them in democratic socialism. India adopted a mixed economy: private enterprise was encouraged, while a public sector was built for the good of society and the state was given powers to guide the economy. The Industrial Policy Resolution of 1956 became the basis of the plans and aimed at a socialistic pattern of society. After the Seventh Plan ended in 1990, economic conditions meant that annual plans were made for 1990-91 and 1991-92, and the Eighth Plan began in 1992, after the economic reforms of 1991.
Planning Commission and National Development Council
-
Planning Commission
- Set up by resolution, March 1950
- Chairman: Prime Minister
- Experts and ministers; no state representatives
- Prepared the plans; advisory
-
National Development Council
- First met November 1952
- Chairman: Prime Minister
- All Chief Ministers included
- Reviewed and approved plans; gave states a voice
Article 38(2): the State shall strive to minimise inequalities in income and to eliminate inequalities in status, facilities and opportunities, among individuals and among groups.
Worked example 1: who does what?
Sort: (a) drafting the targets of a Five-Year Plan; (b) a Chief Minister raising her state's irrigation needs before the plan is finalised; (c) building the canals. Working: (a) is the Planning Commission's work; (b) happens in the National Development Council, where Chief Ministers sit; (c) is implementation by the Union and state governments, since the Commission was only advisory.
Worked example 2: is this family multidimensionally poor?
A made-up household has one child not attending school (education weight 1/6), cooks with wood (1/18) and has no electricity (1/18). Working: total weighted deprivation = 1/6 + 1/18 + 1/18 = 3/18 + 1/18 + 1/18 = 5/18. One-third is 6/18. Since 5/18 is less than 6/18, the household is not counted as multidimensionally poor by this rule, though it is deprived. If it also had no improved sanitation (another 1/18), the total would be 6/18 = 1/3 and it would be counted.
Key takeaways: the Planning Commission (15 March 1950, by government resolution) was an advisory central body chaired by the Prime Minister, with a Deputy Chairman, expert members and divisions. The NDC brought in the Chief Ministers. Planning tried to cut poverty (garibi hatao), create jobs and fulfil Article 38(2), within Nehru's democratic socialism and a mixed economy based on the 1956 Industrial Policy Resolution.
Check your understanding
-
1. How was the Planning Commission of India set up?
- By an amendment of the Constitution
- By a resolution of the Government of India in March 1950
- By an Act of Parliament in 1952
- By an order of the Governor-General in 1947
Show answer
Answer: B. It was set up by a government resolution on 15 March 1950, so it was neither constitutional nor statutory.
-
2. Which body included all the Chief Ministers of the states with the Prime Minister as chairman?
- The Planning Commission
- The National Planning Council
- The Administrative Reforms Commission
- The National Development Council
Show answer
Answer: D. The National Development Council included the Prime Minister as chairman and all Chief Ministers; the Planning Commission itself had no state representatives.
-
3. Who was the de facto executive head of the Planning Commission, responsible for placing draft plans before the Cabinet?
- The Cabinet Secretary
- The President
- The Chief Justice
- The Deputy Chairman
Show answer
Answer: D. The Prime Minister was chairman, but the textbook calls the Deputy Chairman the de facto executive head who formulated drafts for the Union Cabinet.
-
4. In the MPI, a made-up household is deprived in nutrition (1/6) and child mortality (1/6). Is it multidimensionally poor?
- No, because its total is less than one-third
- No, because only income counts
- Yes, because 1/6 + 1/6 = 1/3, which reaches the one-third cut-off
- Yes, because any single deprivation is enough
Show answer
Answer: C. 1/6 + 1/6 = 2/6 = 1/3. A person deprived in at least one-third of the weighted indicators is counted as multidimensionally poor, so the household is counted.
-
5. What did Nehru's 'democratic socialism' combine, according to the textbook?
- Monarchy and planning
- Ideas of the Soviet model of planning with liberal principles
- Military rule and free markets
- Only private enterprise
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says Nehru was inspired by the Soviet model of planning and by liberal principles of capitalism, and brought them together as democratic socialism in a mixed economy.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.