Revision notes

Unit 8 Planning and Development Politics: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Planning: meaning, evolution and objectives

Police state and welfare state
Police state (older idea)Welfare state (modern idea)
Concerned only with security, law and orderAlso responsible for the social and economic well-being of citizens
Limited role in the economyPlans and carries out socio-economic reforms
Does not aim at social justiceAims at socio-economic justice and good governance
Pre-independence planning ideas
YearPlan or bodyKey idea (as in the textbook)
1936'Planned Economy for India' by M. VisvesvarayaProposed a ten-year plan; he is called a pioneer of planning in India
1938National Planning Committee of the Congress, initiated under Subhas Chandra Bose's presidencyTo prepare an economic plan; work halted by the Second World War and leaders' imprisonment
1944Bombay PlanPrepared by leading Indian industrialists
1945People's Plan of M. N. RoyGave more importance to agriculture and small-scale industries
1944Gandhian Plan of Shriman Narayan AgarwalBased on Gandhian ideas of development
1950Sarvodaya Plan of Jayaprakash NarayanDevelopment for the welfare of all

From ideas to a planning institution

  1. Ideas (1930s-1940s) Visvesvaraya, National Planning Committee, Bombay, People's, Gandhian plans
  2. Constitution (1950) Directive Principles in Part IV call for socio-economic justice
  3. Planning Commission (March 1950) Set up by a government resolution to plan the use of resources
  4. Five-Year Plans Targets for growth, employment and justice

Planning = systematic use of a nation's resources for long-term growth and welfare. In India it grew from the Directive Principles' promise of socio-economic justice.

Key takeaways: planning is the systematic, government-directed use of resources for long-term progress and welfare. A welfare state, unlike a police state, takes responsibility for socio-economic justice. Planning ideas in India came from Visvesvaraya (1936), the National Planning Committee (1938) and several plans in the 1940s. After 1950, guided by the Directive Principles, planning aimed at higher income, employment, less inequality and an egalitarian society.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

The Planning Commission, social justice and the mixed economy

Bodies that worked with the Planning Commission
BodyMembersRole
National Planning CouncilExperts in science, engineering and economicsStudied sectors such as agriculture, irrigation, education, industry and transport and supplied data to the Commission
National Development Council (NDC)The Prime Minister (chairman), all Chief Ministers, Union ministers, administrators of Union Territories and members of the Planning CommissionReviewed the working of plans, considered major social and economic policy questions, and gave the states a voice; an extra-constitutional, non-statutory body whose first meeting was held in November 1952

Planning Commission and National Development Council

  • Planning Commission
    • Set up by resolution, March 1950
    • Chairman: Prime Minister
    • Experts and ministers; no state representatives
    • Prepared the plans; advisory
  • National Development Council
    • First met November 1952
    • Chairman: Prime Minister
    • All Chief Ministers included
    • Reviewed and approved plans; gave states a voice

Article 38(2): the State shall strive to minimise inequalities in income and to eliminate inequalities in status, facilities and opportunities, among individuals and among groups.

Key takeaways: the Planning Commission (15 March 1950, by government resolution) was an advisory central body chaired by the Prime Minister, with a Deputy Chairman, expert members and divisions. The NDC brought in the Chief Ministers. Planning tried to cut poverty (garibi hatao), create jobs and fulfil Article 38(2), within Nehru's democratic socialism and a mixed economy based on the 1956 Industrial Policy Resolution.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

NITI Aayog: why it replaced the Planning Commission, its structure and objectives

Structure of NITI Aayog

  • Chairperson The Prime Minister
  • Vice-Chairperson Appointed by the Prime Minister
  • Members
    • Full-time members
    • Part-time members (up to two) from leading universities and research bodies
    • Ex-officio members (up to four) from the Union Council of Ministers
  • Chief Executive Officer Appointed by the Prime Minister
  • Governing Council Chief Ministers of all states and Lt. Governors of Union Territories
  • Regional Councils Formed for a fixed period to address issues of particular states or a region
  • Special invitees Experts, specialists and practitioners invited by the Prime Minister
Differences highlighted in the textbook
FeaturePlanning CommissionNITI Aayog
Set upGovernment resolution, 15 March 1950Union Cabinet resolution, 1 January 2015
ApproachTop-down; one plan for the whole countryBottom-up; states involved; need-specific plans
NaturePrepared Five-Year Plans and recommended allocationsThink tank and forum giving policy advice
States' roleIndirect, through the National Development CouncilDirect, through the Governing Council of all Chief Ministers
Second in commandDeputy ChairmanVice-Chairperson
Member secretaryAppointed through the usual processChief Executive Officer appointed by the Prime Minister
Part-time membersNo provision in the full CommissionPart-time members as needed

NITI Aayog (1 January 2015) replaced the Planning Commission: a think tank for cooperative federalism, with every Chief Minister in its Governing Council.

Key takeaways: NITI Aayog was created by a Union Cabinet resolution on 1 January 2015 to replace the Planning Commission. It is a think tank chaired by the Prime Minister, with a Vice-Chairperson, members, a CEO, a Governing Council of all Chief Ministers and Lt. Governors, Regional Councils and special invitees. It aims at cooperative federalism, village-level planning, inclusion and innovation, in contrast to the Commission's top-down, one-size-fits-all plans.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Land reforms and the Green Revolution

The four categories of land reform in the textbook
ReformWhat it did
Abolition of intermediariesRemoved zamindars and jagirdars who collected rent for the British, bringing cultivators into direct relation with the government; most states passed such laws before 1958; easier where records existed, as in Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh
Tenancy reformRegulated rents, gave security of tenure and conferred ownership on tenants, following Planning Commission guidelines
Land ceilingsFixed the maximum land a person could hold, taking surplus land for the landless; limits differed from state to state, so implementation became a political issue
Consolidation of holdingsJoined scattered plots into compact holdings, partly for efficiency

Spread of the Green Revolution (textbook's account)

  1. 1960 Intensive Area Development Programme in seven districts of seven states
  2. Extension One district from each remaining state selected
  3. 1965 Extended to 144 districts
  4. 1967-1978 Main Green Revolution period
  5. Result Coverage grew from about 2 million to about 70 million hectares
The Green Revolution: gains and problems
Impacts and achievementsShortfalls
Farm output rose two to three times compared with the 1950s; India no longer depended on food grain importsBenefits varied by region and crop; Punjab, Haryana and Uttar Pradesh gained most, with wheat
More farm jobs and demand for agricultural expertsGap between rich and poor farmers widened
Industry produced farm machinery; markets and inter-state trade in grain grewSmall farmers lacked money for the initial investment
Encouraged new seed varieties and inspired change in dairy, fishing and poultryHeavy use of harmful fertilisers and pesticides

Land reforms changed who controls land (intermediaries abolished, tenants protected, ceilings fixed). The Green Revolution changed how much land yields (HYV seeds, fertilisers, irrigation).

Key takeaways: land reforms tried to end exploitation through abolition of intermediaries, tenancy reform, ceilings and consolidation; Bhoodan, Sarvodaya and Tamil Nadu's 1952 and 1961 laws were part of this effort. The Green Revolution, from the 1960s, used HYV seeds, fertilisers and irrigation to end food shortages, but widened regional and farmer inequality and increased chemical use.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

The White Revolution and industrialisation in India

Three phases of Operation Flood
PhaseMain work (textbook's account)
Phase I (1970-1979)18 major milk sheds linked to consumers in Mumbai, Delhi, Calcutta and Madras
Phase II (1981-1985)Milk sheds increased from 18 to 136 and urban market points to 290; over 43,000 village co-operatives by 1985
Phase III (1985-1996)Co-operatives strengthened; veterinary care, cattle feed and artificial insemination expanded; about 30,000 new co-operatives added; more women members
Industrial policies of India
PolicyMain features (as in the textbook)
Industrial Policy Resolution, 1948Mixed economy: arms and ammunition, atomic energy and railways a Union monopoly; the state also responsible for coal, iron and steel, aircraft and shipbuilding; the rest left to private and co-operative enterprise
Industrial Policy Resolution, 1956Three categories: industries wholly of the state; state-owned industries where private enterprise could supplement; industries left to the private sector; small-scale and cottage industries encouraged; aim of a socialistic pattern of society
Industrial Policy, 1980Pragmatic approach; nucleus plants in backward regions; liberalised licensing; 'broad banding' so firms could change products with demand
New Industrial Policy, July 1991Liberalisation: licensing abolished for most industries (18 kept under compulsory licensing at first, three more removed in 1993); limits on foreign investment eased; MRTP restrictions removed; public sector reviewed; poorly performing units referred to BIFR

Direction of industrial policy

  1. 1948 Mixed economy with key industries under the state
  2. 1956 Socialistic pattern; three categories
  3. 1980 Pragmatic, some liberalised licensing
  4. 1991 Liberalisation and integration with the world economy
  5. 2002 Competition Act replaces MRTP Act

White Revolution: Operation Flood (from 1970) on the AMUL co-operative model, led by Verghese Kurien. Industrial policy moved from state-led 1948 and 1956 resolutions to the liberalising policy of July 1991.

Key takeaways: the White Revolution, through Operation Flood (1970) on the AMUL model led by Verghese Kurien, made India self-sufficient and the largest milk producer; in Tamil Nadu, Aavin (1981) follows this model. Industrialisation built heavy industry and infrastructure under the 1948 and 1956 Resolutions; the 1980 policy began liberalising and the 1991 policy opened the economy, with the Competition Act, 2002 replacing the MRTP Act.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery