• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Challenges to Indian democracy and conditions for its success

Identify the major challenges facing Indian democracy and explain the conditions and citizen values that help democracy succeed.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • List the major challenges to Indian democracy named in the textbook.
  • Explain how each challenge weakens democracy.
  • State the conditions and citizen values needed for democracy to succeed.

The textbook notes that democracy is the dominant form of government in today's world and has spread widely over the last hundred years. But a democracy does not run well just because it holds elections. Its quality depends on whether people can use their rights fully and whether those in power act responsibly.

Major challenges

Challenges named in the textbook, with how each hurts democracy
ChallengeWhy it weakens democracy
IlliteracyVoters who cannot read may be misled and find it harder to judge policies
PovertyPeople struggling to survive may sell votes or have no time to take part
Gender discriminationHalf the population may not get an equal voice
RegionalismNarrow regional loyalty can override national interest
Casteism, communalism and religious fundamentalismVotes are cast on group identity rather than on issues, dividing society
CorruptionPublic money and power are misused, reducing trust
Criminalisation of politicsPeople with criminal records entering politics undermine the rule of law
Political violenceFear stops free voting and free expression

Conditions for success

  1. Empowering the poor and the illiterate so they share the benefits of democracy.
  2. Elected people not misusing their position or public wealth.
  3. Removing social evils that harm democracy.
  4. An impartial, efficient press to shape public opinion.
  5. Strong public opinion.
  6. Tolerance and communal harmony among people.
  7. Awareness of fundamental rights.
  8. Constant, conscious watch on how elected representatives work.
  9. A powerful and responsible opposition.

How active citizens keep democracy healthy

  1. Citizens know their rights
  2. They vote and take part
  3. Press, public opinion and opposition watch the government
  4. Government stays accountable
  5. People trust democracy and keep taking part

Then back to step 1: Citizens know their rights

Each step strengthens the next; when citizens stop taking part, the cycle weakens.

The textbook concludes that Indian democracy can be vibrant only when citizens practise democratic values - equality, freedom, social justice, accountability and respect for all - in their behaviour, take part, hold the system accountable and fulfil their own obligations.

Elections are the start of democracy, not the whole of it: rights, a free press, a strong opposition and watchful citizens keep it alive.

Worked example 1: name the challenge

Case (made up): In a ward election, a candidate distributes gifts the night before polling, and many voters in debt accept them. Reasoning: Payment for votes is corruption, and it works because poverty makes voters vulnerable. Answer: corruption, made worse by poverty. The matching condition for success is empowering the poor and keeping a watch on candidates' conduct.

Worked example 2: why does the opposition matter?

Question: Why does the textbook list a 'powerful and responsible opposition' as a condition for democracy's success? Reasoning: Without an opposition, no one inside the legislature questions the government's decisions or points out mistakes. A responsible opposition criticises on issues, not for its own sake. Answer: It keeps the government accountable and gives voice to people who did not vote for the ruling side.

Key takeaways: The textbook names illiteracy, poverty, gender discrimination, regionalism, casteism and communalism, corruption, criminalisation of politics and political violence as challenges. Democracy succeeds with empowered citizens, honest representatives, a free press, strong public opinion, tolerance, rights awareness, vigilance and a responsible opposition.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of these is listed in the textbook as a challenge to Indian democracy?

    1. Universal adult franchise
    2. Criminalisation of politics
    3. An impartial press
    4. Strong public opinion
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Criminalisation of politics is a listed challenge. The other three strengthen democracy.

  2. 2. Which condition helps democracy succeed?

    1. Political violence
    2. Regionalism
    3. A powerful and responsible opposition
    4. Lower voter turnout
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A responsible opposition keeps the government accountable. The other options weaken democracy.

  3. 3. Voters choosing a candidate only because he belongs to their caste, ignoring his record, is an example of:

    1. Casteism
    2. Popular sovereignty
    3. Direct democracy
    4. Fraternity
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Voting on caste identity rather than issues is casteism, one of the challenges the textbook lists.

  4. 4. Why is an impartial press important for democracy?

    1. It chooses the Prime Minister
    2. It replaces elections
    3. It makes laws
    4. It informs people and helps form public opinion
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook says an impartial, efficient press helps form public opinion, which lets citizens judge their government.

  5. 5. Which set of values does the textbook say citizens must practise for democracy to be vibrant?

    1. Equality, freedom, social justice, accountability and respect for all
    2. Obedience, silence and loyalty to one leader
    3. Wealth, privilege and inheritance
    4. Secrecy, speed and central control
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook names equality, freedom, social justice, accountability and respect for all as the democratic values citizens should reflect in their behaviour.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery