• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

How democracy evolved, its types and its merits and demerits

Trace democracy from ancient Greece and early India, compare direct and indirect democracy, parliamentary and presidential forms, and weigh democracy's merits and demerits.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the early history of democracy in Greece, India and Tamil Nadu.
  • Distinguish direct from indirect (representative) democracy, and parliamentary from presidential forms.
  • List the merits and demerits of democracy given in the textbook.

Democracy did not appear suddenly. The textbook traces it back about 2,500 years and reminds us that India had its own early democratic institutions. Knowing its types helps us see why India runs its democracy the way it does.

Evolution of democracy

  • Ancient Greece: democracy began about 2,500 years ago in some Greek city-states.
  • Ancient India: democratic institutions existed as early as the Vedic period. Chanakya's Arthashastra shows that an autonomous village community was the basic unit of local government.
  • Tamil Nadu: during the later Chola period, the Kudavolai system of choosing village representatives was a notable feature of village administration.
  • Values: the textbook says the journey towards democracy is marked by freedom, equality, fraternity, accountability, transparency and trust.

Two types of democracy

Direct and indirect democracy

  • Direct (pure) democracy
    • People themselves decide public affairs
    • Works in small communities
    • Examples in the textbook: ancient Greek city-states, Switzerland
  • Indirect (representative) democracy
    • People decide through elected representatives
    • Suits large populations
    • Examples in the textbook: India, USA, UK

Two forms of democratic government

In a parliamentary form, the voters (the electorate) elect the legislature, and the executive (the Prime Minister and ministers) comes from and answers to the legislature. The textbook's examples are India and England. In a presidential form, the voters elect the legislature and the executive head separately, so the executive does not depend on the legislature. The textbook's examples are the USA and France. Unit 4 returns to these in detail.

Parliamentary form: the chain of responsibility

  1. Electorate (voters)
  2. Legislature (elected)
  3. Executive formed from the majority, answerable to the legislature
In a presidential form, the electorate chooses the executive separately instead.

Merits and demerits

As listed in the Tamil Nadu textbook
MeritsDemerits
Responsible and accountable governmentIndirect, representative nature: people do not decide directly
Equality and fraternityLack of interest, leading to lower turnout in elections
Sense of responsibility among common peopleInstability when no party wins a clear majority (fractured mandate)
Local self-governmentDelay in decision-making
Development and prosperity for all; popular sovereignty-
Sense of cooperation and fraternal feeling-

Direct = people decide themselves (Switzerland). Indirect = people decide through representatives (India). Parliamentary = executive answers to legislature (India). Presidential = executive elected separately (USA).

Worked example 1: which type?

Case (made up): In a hill village of 300 adults, everyone gathers each month to vote on how to spend the village fund. In a state of 7 crore people, citizens elect members who then pass the budget. Reasoning: In the village, the people themselves decide - direct democracy. In the large state, decisions are made through representatives - indirect democracy. Answer: village = direct; state = indirect. Size is the reason large countries use representatives.

Worked example 2: assertion and reason

Assertion: Direct democracy is practised in Switzerland. Reason: People directly take part in decision-making. Reasoning: The textbook gives Switzerland as its present-day example of direct democracy, and direct participation is what defines direct democracy. Answer: both true, and the reason explains the assertion.

Key takeaways: Democracy began about 2,500 years ago in Greek city-states; India had early democratic institutions, including village communities in the Arthashastra and the Chola Kudavolai system. Democracy is direct or indirect; democratic government is parliamentary or presidential. Its merits include accountability and popular sovereignty; its demerits include low turnout, instability from fractured mandates and delay.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The Kudavolai system was followed by the:

    1. Cheras
    2. Pandyas
    3. Cholas
    4. Kalabhras
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook describes Kudavolai as a notable feature of village administration in the later Chola period.

  2. 2. Where did direct democracy exist in olden times?

    1. In the city-states of ancient Greece
    2. In the USA
    3. In the UK
    4. In the Mughal empire
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Democracy began about 2,500 years ago in Greek city-states, where citizens decided public matters directly.

  3. 3. Which country does the textbook give as an example of the presidential form of government?

    1. India
    2. England
    3. USA
    4. Bhutan
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook lists the USA and France as presidential; India and England are parliamentary; Bhutan is a monarchy.

  4. 4. Which of these is a demerit of democracy listed in the textbook?

    1. Popular sovereignty
    2. Delay in decision-making
    3. Accountable government
    4. Local self-government
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Delay in decision-making is a listed demerit. The other three are listed merits.

  5. 5. Which ancient work tells us that an autonomous village community was the basic unit of local government in India?

    1. Chanakya's Arthashastra
    2. The Rig Veda
    3. Tirukkural
    4. Indica
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook cites Chanakya's Arthashastra for the autonomous village community as the basic unit of local government.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery