- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Federal form of government and the federal features of India
Define a federal government, give examples, weigh its merits and demerits, list India's federal features, and compare unitary and federal systems.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define the federal form of government with examples.
- List its merits and demerits.
- Name the federal features of the Indian Constitution and compare unitary and federal forms.
Large countries with many regions, languages and cultures often find one centre cannot run everything well. They divide power between a national government and regional governments. This is the federal form.
What is a federal government?
A federal government is one in which powers are divided between the national government and the regional governments by the Constitution itself, and both work independently in their own areas. The national government is called the federal, central or Union government; regional ones are state or provincial governments. The textbook's examples are the USA, Switzerland, Australia, Canada, Russia, Brazil and Argentina.
Merits and demerits
| Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|
| Reconciles local autonomy with national unity | Weaker than a unitary government |
| Division of power improves administrative efficiency | More expensive |
| Makes it possible to form large states | Provincial (regional) tendencies are common; lack of uniformity in administration |
| Checks despotism of the centre | Disputes over division of powers between centre and states |
| More suitable for bigger countries | Rigid constitution is hard to amend for changing needs |
| Good for economic and cultural progress | States sometimes obstruct foreign policy; can threaten national unity; some federations have double citizenship |
Federal features of the Indian Constitution
- Dual government - Union and state governments.
- Written Constitution.
- Division of powers between centre and states (the three lists).
- Supremacy of the Constitution - laws made by the centre and the states must conform to it.
- Rigid Constitution - key federal provisions need a special procedure to amend.
- Independent judiciary to settle disputes.
- Bicameralism - two Houses of Parliament, with the Rajya Sabha representing the states.
Unitary and federal compared
Unitary and federal forms
-
Unitary
- One level of government (sub-units only administrative)
- Single citizenship, mostly
- Sub-units cannot act independently
- No constitutional division of power
- Power centralised
-
Federal
- Two levels of government
- Dual citizenship in some federations (e.g. USA); India has single citizenship
- Units act independently in their own sphere
- Power divided by the constitution
- Power decentralised
Federal = power divided by the Constitution itself; both levels independent in their own sphere.
Worked example 1: federal or unitary feature?
Question: Sort these Indian features: (a) independent judiciary; (b) single citizenship; (c) division of powers into lists; (d) emergency provisions. Reasoning: features that protect the division of power between two levels are federal; features that strengthen the centre are unitary. Answer: (a) and (c) federal; (b) and (d) unitary. This mix is why India is often described as federal with a strong centre.
Worked example 2: choosing a form (made up)
Case (made up): Country N is large, with many languages and regions that want to run their own schools and police. Reasoning: the textbook says federal government is more suitable for bigger countries and reconciles local autonomy with national unity. Answer: a federal form would suit N better than a unitary one, though N must manage higher costs and centre-state disputes.
Key takeaways: In a federation the Constitution divides power and both levels work independently. Examples in the textbook include the USA, Canada, Australia and Switzerland. Federations suit big countries and check central despotism, but are costlier and can see centre-state conflict. India's federal features include dual government, a written and supreme Constitution, division of powers, rigidity, an independent judiciary and bicameralism.
Check your understanding
-
1. In a federal government, powers are divided between the national and regional governments by:
- The Prime Minister's order
- An ordinary law of the centre
- The Constitution itself
- The regional governments alone
Show answer
Answer: C. The defining feature of federalism is that the Constitution itself divides powers.
-
2. Which of these is a federal feature of the Indian Constitution?
- Single citizenship
- All India Services
- Emergency provisions
- Independent judiciary
Show answer
Answer: D. An independent judiciary is a federal feature; the others are listed as unitary features.
-
3. Which is a merit of the federal form, according to the textbook?
- Reconciles local autonomy with national unity
- It is the least expensive form
- It never has disputes
- It is easy to amend
Show answer
Answer: A. Federalism lets regions govern themselves while keeping the country united. It is costlier and harder to amend.
-
4. Which country does the textbook give as an example of a federal government?
- Sri Lanka
- Canada
- Japan
- France
Show answer
Answer: B. Canada is listed as federal; Sri Lanka, Japan and France are listed as unitary.
-
5. 'Supremacy of the Constitution' means:
- Parliament can ignore the Constitution
- The states are above the Constitution
- Laws made by both centre and states must conform to the Constitution
- The President is above the Constitution
Show answer
Answer: C. The Constitution is the supreme law; any central or state law must follow its provisions.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.