• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Parliamentary and presidential forms of government

Describe the features, merits and demerits of parliamentary and presidential governments, name some national parliaments, and compare the two forms.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the features of the parliamentary form and its merits and demerits.
  • Explain the features of the presidential form and its merits and demerits.
  • Compare the two forms and match countries with their parliaments.

Modern democracies are also classified by how the executive relates to the legislature. If the executive is answerable to the legislature, the system is parliamentary; if the two are separate and independent, it is presidential.

Parliamentary form

In the parliamentary system, the executive is responsible to the legislature for its policies and acts. It is also called cabinet government, responsible government or the Westminster model (after the British Parliament at Westminster). The textbook's examples are Britain, Japan, Canada and India.

  • Nominal and real executives: the head of state (President in India, the monarch in Britain) is the nominal head; the Prime Minister and Cabinet hold real power.
  • Majority party rule: the party or coalition with a majority in the lower house forms the government.
  • Collective responsibility: ministers are together answerable to the legislature.
  • Dual membership: ministers are also members of the legislature.
  • Leadership of the Prime Minister.

Merits: harmony between legislature and executive; responsible government; prevents dictatorship; wide representation. Demerits: governments can be unstable; policies may not continue when governments change; the Cabinet may dominate; it goes against the separation of powers.

Presidential form

The presidential system, also called the non-parliamentary or fixed executive system, is built on the separation of powers. The textbook names the USA, Brazil, Russia and Sri Lanka among countries using it. Its key features:

  • The President is both head of state and head of government and holds real executive power (it is not a ceremonial post).
  • The President is elected for a fixed term - in the USA, four years, through an electoral college chosen by the voters - and is not removed by a vote of the legislature.
  • The President governs with a cabinet of chosen advisers, sometimes an informal smaller group called a 'kitchen cabinet'.
  • Legislative, executive and judicial powers are vested in three separate, independent organs.

Merits: democratic; effective control by the President; quick decision-making. Demerits: can degenerate into dictatorship; strained relations and lack of harmony between executive and legislature.

Parliamentary and presidential forms

  • Parliamentary (e.g. India, Britain)
    • Prime Minister is leader of the majority party
    • President/monarch is head of state; PM is head of government
    • Executive drawn from and overlapping with legislature
    • Collective leadership and responsibility to the legislature
  • Presidential (e.g. USA)
    • President elected separately for a fixed term
    • President is head of state AND head of government
    • Strict separation of powers; independent branches
    • Individual leadership; President not accountable to Congress
Names of national parliaments in the textbook
CountryParliament
IsraelKnesset
GermanyBundestag
DenmarkFolketing
NorwayStorting
USACongress
JapanDiet
BritainParliament

Parliamentary: executive answers to the legislature (PM leads). Presidential: separation of powers, President heads both state and government for a fixed term.

Worked example 1: which system? (made up)

Case (made up): In Country S, the head of government can be removed whenever a majority of the legislature passes a no-confidence vote, and all ministers sit in the legislature. Reasoning: an executive answerable to and drawn from the legislature is parliamentary. Answer: S is parliamentary.

Worked example 2: who leads?

Question: In India, who is the nominal executive and who is the real executive? Reasoning: in a parliamentary system the head of state is nominal and the Prime Minister with the Council of Ministers exercises real power. Answer: the President is the nominal executive; the Prime Minister and Council of Ministers are the real executive.

Key takeaways: In a parliamentary (Westminster) system the executive comes from and answers to the legislature, with a nominal head of state and a real executive led by the Prime Minister. In a presidential system powers are separated; the President is both head of state and head of government for a fixed term. Each has merits and demerits. Remember: USA - Congress, Japan - Diet, Israel - Knesset, Norway - Storting, Denmark - Folketing.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The parliamentary form of government is also known as:

    1. Fixed executive system
    2. Westminster model
    3. Kitchen cabinet
    4. Presidential system
    Show answer

    Answer: B. It is also called cabinet government or responsible government, after the British model at Westminster.

  2. 2. In the parliamentary form, the leader of the majority party is the:

    1. Prime Minister
    2. President
    3. Chief Justice
    4. Speaker
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The leader of the majority in the lower house becomes Prime Minister and leads the real executive.

  3. 3. The parliament of the USA is called:

    1. Diet
    2. Knesset
    3. Storting
    4. Congress
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The US legislature is Congress; Diet is Japan's, Knesset is Israel's and Storting is Norway's.

  4. 4. Which is a feature of the presidential form?

    1. Collective responsibility of ministers to the legislature
    2. Dual membership of ministers in the legislature
    3. Separation of powers between three independent organs
    4. A nominal head of state with a separate real executive
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The presidential system is built on separation of powers. The other three are parliamentary features.

  5. 5. Folketing is the name of the parliament of:

    1. Norway
    2. Denmark
    3. Germany
    4. Israel
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Folketing is Denmark's parliament; Norway's is the Storting.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery