- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Moral and emotional growth: Kohlberg and Erikson
Describe Kohlberg's three levels and six stages of moral reasoning and Erikson's psychosocial stages, and place children's reasoning and needs in the right stage.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Children do not only learn to think; they also learn what is right and wrong and who they are. Two theories describe these changes and appear constantly in teaching-aptitude courses: Lawrence Kohlberg's stages of moral development and Erik Erikson's psychosocial stages. This lesson explains both in simple terms.
Kohlberg: how children reason about right and wrong
Kohlberg, an American psychologist, built on Piaget's work. He told children and adults stories with a moral problem, the best known being the Heinz dilemma: a man named Heinz steals a costly medicine that he cannot afford, to save his dying wife. Kohlberg was less interested in whether people said Heinz was right or wrong than in why they said so. From their reasons he described three levels, each with two stages.
| Level | Stage | How the person reasons |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-conventional | 1. Obedience and punishment orientation | Right is what avoids punishment |
| Pre-conventional | 2. Individualism and exchange (self-interest) | Right is what serves my interest; 'you help me, I help you' |
| Conventional | 3. Good interpersonal relationships ('good boy, good girl') | Right is what pleases others and earns approval |
| Conventional | 4. Maintaining social order (law and order) | Right is obeying laws and doing one's duty to keep society working |
| Post-conventional | 5. Social contract and individual rights | Laws are agreements that should serve people's welfare and rights and can be changed |
| Post-conventional | 6. Universal ethical principles | Right follows self-chosen principles such as justice and human dignity, even against law |
Kohlberg held that people move through these stages in order, without skipping, though many adults do not reach the post-conventional level. 'Conventional' means following the conventions of one's group or society; 'pre' and 'post' mean before and beyond them.
Worked example 1: place the reasoning
Asked whether Heinz should steal the medicine, a child replies, 'No, because he will be caught and put in jail.' Step 1: the reason given is the punishment, not the law, other people's approval or a principle. Step 2: right and wrong are judged by avoiding punishment. Step 3: that is Stage 1, obedience and punishment orientation, at the pre-conventional level. If another child said, 'No, because stealing is against the law, and if everyone broke laws society would fall apart', that would be Stage 4, at the conventional level. Note that both children gave the same answer, 'no'; only the reasoning places them.
Erikson: a challenge at every stage of life
Erik Erikson described eight psychosocial stages across the whole life span. At each stage the person faces a central conflict between two outcomes. Meeting it well builds a healthy personality; meeting it badly leaves a difficulty that can affect later stages. The first five cover childhood and adolescence; the ages below are approximate.
| Stage | Approximate age | Central conflict |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Infancy (birth to about 1½ years) | Trust vs mistrust |
| 2 | Early childhood (about 1½ to 3 years) | Autonomy vs shame and doubt |
| 3 | Preschool (about 3 to 5 years) | Initiative vs guilt |
| 4 | School age (about 6 to 12 years) | Industry vs inferiority |
| 5 | Adolescence (about 12 to 18 years) | Identity vs role confusion |
| 6 | Young adulthood | Intimacy vs isolation |
| 7 | Middle adulthood | Generativity vs stagnation |
| 8 | Late adulthood | Integrity vs despair |
Worked example 2: a school-age child
Sahil, aged nine, keeps saying 'I am useless at everything' after repeated failures in class and stops trying. Which of Erikson's conflicts is he facing? Step 1: his age, nine, falls in the school-age period. Step 2: the conflict there is between a sense of competence from doing tasks well and a feeling of being less able than others. Step 3: so Sahil is struggling with industry versus inferiority, and is leaning towards inferiority. The teacher can help by giving tasks he can succeed at and recognising his effort, building his sense of industry.
Why teachers care
Kohlberg reminds teachers to discuss reasons, not just rules, and to use moral dilemmas so that children hear reasoning a little above their own. Erikson reminds teachers that school-age children need chances to succeed and be recognised, and that adolescents need room to explore who they are.
Kohlberg: pre-conventional (punishment, self-interest), conventional (approval, law and order), post-conventional (social contract, universal principles); judge by the REASON. Erikson at school age: industry vs inferiority; adolescence: identity vs role confusion.
Key takeaways
Kohlberg described three levels and six stages of moral reasoning, identified by the reasons people give, not their answers. Erikson described eight life stages, each with a central conflict; the school years are about industry versus inferiority and adolescence about identity versus role confusion.
Check your understanding
-
1. In the Heinz dilemma, Kohlberg was mainly interested in:
- Whether people said Heinz was right or wrong
- The reasons people gave for their answers
- How quickly people answered
- Whether people knew the law
Show answer
Answer: B. Kohlberg placed people in stages by their reasoning, not by their yes-or-no answer.
-
2. 'I helped him because he promised to share his lunch with me.' This reasoning belongs to Kohlberg's:
- Stage 1, obedience and punishment
- Stage 4, law and order
- Stage 6, universal ethical principles
- Stage 2, individualism and exchange
Show answer
Answer: D. Doing something for a return ('you help me, I help you') is Stage 2 at the pre-conventional level.
-
3. Which of Kohlberg's levels includes the 'good boy, good girl' stage and the law-and-order stage?
- Conventional
- Pre-conventional
- Post-conventional
- Formal operational
Show answer
Answer: A. Stages 3 and 4 make up the conventional level. Formal operational is a Piaget stage, not a Kohlberg level.
-
4. According to Erikson, the central conflict of adolescence is:
- Trust vs mistrust
- Industry vs inferiority
- Identity vs role confusion
- Integrity vs despair
Show answer
Answer: C. Adolescents work out who they are, which Erikson called identity versus role confusion.
-
5. A three-year-old insists on dressing herself and gets upset when an adult takes over. In Erikson's terms she is working through:
- Initiative vs guilt
- Identity vs role confusion
- Autonomy vs shame and doubt
- Generativity vs stagnation
Show answer
Answer: C. In early childhood, about 1½ to 3 years, children seek to do things for themselves: autonomy versus shame and doubt.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.