- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Vygotsky: learning with others, the ZPD and scaffolding
Explain Lev Vygotsky's social view of learning, the zone of proximal development, scaffolding and the more knowledgeable other, and compare Vygotsky with Piaget.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Piaget pictured the child as a young scientist exploring the world largely on his or her own. The Russian psychologist Lev Vygotsky placed much more weight on other people. For Vygotsky, children learn first by doing things together with parents, teachers and friends, and only then on their own. His ideas, especially the zone of proximal development and scaffolding, are central to modern classroom teaching.
Learning is social and cultural
Vygotsky's approach is called social constructivism (or the sociocultural theory). Children still build their own understanding, but they do so through interaction with others and with the tools of their culture, above all language. A child first hears a parent count objects aloud, then counts along with the parent, then counts alone. What began between two people becomes the child's own way of thinking.
The zone of proximal development
The zone of proximal development (ZPD) is the gap between what a child can do alone and what the child can do with help from someone more skilled. Think of three bands of tasks: those the child can already do alone, those the child can do only with help, and those that are still too difficult even with help. The middle band is the ZPD. Vygotsky argued that teaching is most useful when it aims at this zone: tasks that are too easy teach nothing new, and tasks that are far too hard cannot be learnt even with help.
The more knowledgeable other
The more knowledgeable other (MKO) is anyone who has a better understanding or a higher skill than the learner for a particular task. It is often a teacher or parent, but it can just as well be a classmate, an older sibling, or even a younger child who happens to be better at that task. This is why peer learning and group work fit Vygotsky's ideas well.
Scaffolding
Scaffolding is the support given to a learner within the ZPD, which is gradually taken away as the learner becomes able to do the task alone, just as builders remove scaffolding when a building can stand by itself. The term was introduced by David Wood, Jerome Bruner and Gail Ross, building on Vygotsky's ideas. Examples include giving hints, breaking a task into steps, showing a model, asking guiding questions and giving partly solved examples.
Private speech
Young children often talk aloud to themselves while working. Vygotsky called this private speech and saw it as a tool for guiding one's own thinking; with age it turns into silent inner speech. Piaget had called similar talk 'egocentric speech' and saw it mainly as a sign of immature thinking.
| Point | Piaget | Vygotsky |
|---|---|---|
| Child's role | Active explorer, largely individual | Active learner through interaction |
| Main driver | Individual discovery and maturation | Social interaction and culture |
| Language | Reflects thinking that has developed | Shapes and drives thinking |
| Talking to oneself | Egocentric speech, fades | Private speech, guides thinking |
| Teacher's role | Provide materials and opportunities to explore | Guide within the ZPD through scaffolding |
Worked example 1: identify the ZPD
Meera can add two-digit numbers alone. With her teacher's hints she can add three-digit numbers with carrying. Even with help she cannot yet solve problems on fractions. Step 1: two-digit addition is what she can already do alone. Step 2: three-digit addition with carrying is what she can do only with help. Step 3: that middle task is her zone of proximal development, and it is where the teacher should aim. Fractions lie beyond her ZPD for now.
Worked example 2: is it scaffolding?
A teacher helps Kabir write a paragraph. On the first day she gives him a sentence starter for every line; on the second, only a list of key words; on the third, just one question to think about; on the fourth, he writes alone. Step 1: support is given within a task Kabir cannot yet do alone. Step 2: the support is reduced step by step. Step 3: gradual withdrawal of support as competence grows is the defining feature of scaffolding. If the teacher had simply written the paragraph for him, that would be doing the task, not scaffolding.
ZPD = what a child can do with help but not yet alone. Scaffolding = support within the ZPD, withdrawn gradually. MKO = anyone more skilled at the task, including a peer.
Key takeaways
Vygotsky saw learning as social and cultural, with language as the key tool. Teach in the zone of proximal development, support learners through scaffolding that fades as they improve, and use any more knowledgeable other, including classmates. Compared with Piaget, Vygotsky gives more weight to people and language.
Check your understanding
-
1. The zone of proximal development is the difference between:
- What a child can do alone and what the child can do with help
- What a child knows now and what the child knew last year
- A child's age and mental age
- What the teacher knows and what the child knows
Show answer
Answer: A. The ZPD lies between independent performance and performance with help from someone more skilled.
-
2. Which of these is the best example of scaffolding?
- Doing the learner's task for him
- Leaving the learner alone with a very hard task
- Giving hints at first and gradually reducing them as the learner improves
- Giving the same full help every time, permanently
Show answer
Answer: C. Scaffolding is support within the ZPD that is withdrawn step by step.
-
3. According to Vygotsky, a more knowledgeable other can be:
- Only a trained teacher
- Only a parent
- Only an adult
- Anyone more skilled at the task, including a classmate
Show answer
Answer: D. The MKO is anyone with better understanding of the particular task, which can be a peer.
-
4. Vygotsky saw children's talking aloud to themselves while working as:
- Private speech that helps guide their thinking
- A sign of disobedience
- Egocentric speech without any use
- A sign of a learning difficulty
Show answer
Answer: A. Vygotsky called it private speech, a tool for self-guidance that later becomes inner speech.
-
5. Compared with Piaget, Vygotsky placed more emphasis on:
- Individual discovery without help
- Social interaction and language
- Fixed stages tied to age
- Heredity alone
Show answer
Answer: B. Vygotsky's social constructivism stresses learning through interaction and language.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.