• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Models of discipline: Dreikurs, Canter, Glasser, Gordon and Skinner

Match classroom scenarios to five well-known approaches to discipline, and recognise each approach's central idea and typical teacher response.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Beyond Kounin, exams name several other thinkers on discipline and ask you to match them to ideas or to the teacher response that fits. Each has one central idea. If you attach that idea to the name, most questions become simple matching exercises.

Five approaches at a glance

ThinkerCentral ideaTypical teacher response
Rudolf DreikursMisbehaviour is a mistaken attempt to belong, with four goals: attention, power, revenge and display of inadequacyIdentify the goal, then respond so the goal is not rewarded; encourage
Lee and Marlene Canter (assertive discipline)The teacher has a right to teach and the pupils a right to learn; clear rules, positive recognition and a planned series of consequencesBe assertive, not hostile or passive; follow rules consistently
William Glasser (choice theory)Behaviour is chosen to meet basic needs: survival, love and belonging, power, freedom and funMeet needs through meaningful work; hold class meetings; help pupils make better choices
Thomas Gordon (teacher effectiveness training)Decide who owns the problem; use active listening and I-messages; solve conflicts so that no one losesDescribe the behaviour, its effect and your feeling without blame
B. F. Skinner (behaviour modification)Behaviour is shaped by its consequences; reinforced behaviour increasesReinforce desired behaviour; ignore minor unwanted behaviour

Dreikurs's four goals and how to respond

GoalWhat it looks likeBetter response
AttentionClowning, calling out, repeated small nuisancesIgnore when safe; give attention when the pupil behaves well
PowerArguing, defying, refusingAvoid a power struggle; give choices and responsibility
RevengeHurting others after feeling hurtDo not retaliate; rebuild the relationship
Display of inadequacyGiving up, saying 'I can't', withdrawingEncourage, break tasks into small steps, show progress

A quick way to find the goal is to notice how the teacher feels: annoyed suggests attention, angry or challenged suggests power, hurt suggests revenge, and helpless suggests inadequacy.

I-messages

Gordon contrasted a you-message ('You are lazy and careless') with an I-message, which has three parts: the behaviour, its effect on the teacher or others, and the teacher's feeling. For example: 'When homework is not handed in, I cannot see how well you understand, and I feel worried.' The I-message states a problem without blaming the person.

Worked example 1: find the goal

Arjun makes funny noises whenever the teacher turns to help another pupil, and he stops when she looks at him. The teacher feels irritated. Step 1: the behaviour appears when the teacher is attending to others and stops when she attends to him, so he wants her notice. Step 2: the teacher's irritation fits. Answer: attention seeking, in Dreikurs's scheme. A good response is to give him a brief task or a word of recognition when he is working well, and to ignore the noises when it is safe.

Worked example 2: choose the I-message

A pupil often arrives late. Which statement is an I-message? (a) 'You are always late and irresponsible.' (b) 'When you arrive after the bell, the class has to pause and I feel concerned that you miss the start.' (c) 'Why can you never be on time?' (d) 'Late again, go to the principal.' Step 1: check for behaviour, effect and feeling. Answer: (b). The others blame or threaten.

Worked example 3: which thinker?

(i) A teacher holds a class meeting to ask what pupils need in order to enjoy learning, and links work to their interests. (ii) A teacher posts four rules and a stepwise list of consequences and praises the pupils who follow them. (iii) A teacher gives a token for each completed task and ignores minor calling out. Answer: (i) Glasser, since it focuses on basic needs and choice; (ii) Canter, since it uses clear rules and planned consequences; (iii) Skinner, since it reinforces behaviour.

Dreikurs: attention, power, revenge, inadequacy. Canter: assertive rules. Glasser: needs and choice. Gordon: I-messages. Skinner: reinforcement.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Identify the goal behind misbehaviour before choosing a response.
  • Avoid power struggles; offer choices.
  • I-messages describe behaviour, effect and feeling, without blame.
  • Assertive discipline differs from hostile and from passive discipline.
  • Glasser links discipline to meeting basic needs through meaningful work.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A pupil argues with every instruction to show that the teacher cannot control her. Dreikurs would call the goal:

    1. Attention
    2. Power
    3. Revenge
    4. Inadequacy
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Defiance that challenges the teacher's authority is the power goal. The best response avoids a power struggle.

  2. 2. A pupil gives up quickly, saying 'I can't do anything', and stops trying. The goal is:

    1. Attention seeking
    2. A bid for power
    3. Revenge for a past insult
    4. Display of inadequacy
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Withdrawal to avoid failure is display of inadequacy, which calls for encouragement and small steps.

  3. 3. Which of these contains the three parts of an I-message?

    1. When work is late I cannot plan, and I feel worried
    2. You are always late and never think of others
    3. Why do you keep failing to submit on time?
    4. Late work will be marked zero without exception
    Show answer

    Answer: A. An I-message states the behaviour, its effect and the speaker's feeling. The other statements blame, question or threaten.

  4. 4. The idea that behaviour is chosen to meet needs such as belonging, power, freedom and fun comes from:

    1. Canter
    2. Skinner
    3. Glasser
    4. Gordon
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Glasser's choice theory lists these basic needs and urges teachers to help pupils meet them in useful ways.

  5. 5. A teacher who shows firm, positive and consistent expectations, without hostility, shows which approach?

    1. Passive discipline
    2. Hostile discipline
    3. Laissez-faire management
    4. Assertive discipline
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Canters distinguished assertive teachers from hostile and non-assertive ones.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery