• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Reinforcement, punishment and extinction: classification problems

Classify classroom examples as positive or negative reinforcement, positive or negative punishment, or extinction, and work out schedules, tokens and the Premack principle.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Operant conditioning, from B. F. Skinner, gives teachers a precise vocabulary for what happens after a behaviour. Exams love it because two words, positive and negative, are easily mixed up. This lesson gives a two-question test that settles every case.

The two-question test

Question 1: did the behaviour become more likely or less likely afterwards? More likely means reinforcement; less likely means punishment. Question 2: was something added or removed? Added is positive; removed is negative. Here positive and negative mean added and removed, not good and bad.

ItemSomething addedSomething removed
Behaviour increasesPositive reinforcement (praise after a good answer)Negative reinforcement (pupils who finish class work early are excused from homework, so they finish faster)
Behaviour decreasesPositive punishment (extra work added after misbehaviour)Negative punishment (a privilege such as break time is taken away after misbehaviour)

Negative reinforcement is not punishment. It strengthens behaviour by removing something unpleasant. Extinction is different again: a behaviour that is no longer reinforced gradually decreases, such as ignoring calling out when it used to get attention. Behaviour may briefly get worse before it improves, so the teacher must stay consistent. Punishment, especially harsh or public punishment, tends to suppress behaviour only for a time, may cause fear and does not teach the right behaviour, so reinforcing good behaviour is generally a better strategy.

Schedules and other ideas

IdeaMeaning
Continuous reinforcementEvery correct response is reinforced; best for learning a new behaviour quickly
Fixed ratioReinforcement after a set number of responses (a star after every fifth correct answer)
Variable ratioAfter an unpredictable number of responses
Fixed intervalAfter a set period of time
Variable intervalAfter unpredictable periods of time
Token economyPupils earn tokens for target behaviour and exchange them for rewards
Premack principleA preferred activity can reinforce a less preferred one: 'first finish the exercise, then you may draw'

Behaviour reinforced intermittently (not every time) is usually more resistant to extinction than behaviour reinforced every time.

Worked example 1: classify

(a) A pupil receives a sticker after reading aloud, and reads aloud more often. (b) A teacher stops giving homework to pupils who have finished all class work, and pupils finish class work faster. (c) A pupil who throws paper loses five minutes of free play, and throws paper less. (d) A pupil is given extra sums for talking, and talks less. Answer: (a) positive reinforcement; behaviour increases and something is added. (b) negative reinforcement; behaviour increases and something unwanted is removed. (c) negative punishment; behaviour decreases and something wanted is removed. (d) positive punishment; behaviour decreases and something is added.

Worked example 2: a token economy

A teacher awards one token for each completed task. Ten tokens can be exchanged for a choice of activity. A pupil completes 4 tasks a day. Step 1: tokens needed = 10. Step 2: days needed = 10 ÷ 4 = 2.5, so the pupil reaches 10 tokens on the third day, since 3 days give 12 tokens. Answer: 3 days. If the reward is too far away for weaker pupils, the teacher can lower the number of tokens needed, so that success comes sooner.

Worked example 3: name the schedule

(i) A teacher gives a star after every fifth correct answer. (ii) A teacher praises a pupil at random moments while the pupil is working. (iii) The teacher gives a point at the end of each ten-minute block if the pupil stays on task. Answer: (i) fixed ratio, since it depends on a set number of responses; (ii) variable interval, since the timing of the praise is unpredictable; (iii) fixed interval, since reinforcement follows a set time period.

Ask two questions: more or less likely? Added or removed? Reinforcement strengthens; punishment weakens; extinction is withdrawing reinforcement.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Positive means added and negative means removed.
  • Negative reinforcement strengthens behaviour; it is not punishment.
  • Extinction means no longer reinforcing a behaviour.
  • Intermittent reinforcement makes behaviour harder to extinguish.
  • Premack: a preferred activity follows a less preferred one.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A pupil's tidy handwriting increases after the teacher writes 'Excellent' on it. This is:

    1. Negative reinforcement
    2. Positive punishment
    3. Positive reinforcement
    4. Negative punishment
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A pleasant consequence is added and the behaviour increases.

  2. 2. A pupil loses the right to use the computer for a day after shouting, and shouting decreases. This is:

    1. Negative punishment
    2. Positive punishment
    3. Negative reinforcement
    4. Extinction
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Something wanted is removed and the behaviour decreases.

  3. 3. The teacher stops responding to a pupil's calling out, which used to get attention, and the calling out slowly decreases. This is:

    1. Positive reinforcement
    2. Negative punishment
    3. A fixed ratio
    4. Extinction
    Show answer

    Answer: D. When a reinforcer is no longer given, the behaviour gradually decreases. That is extinction.

  4. 4. 'First finish the exercise, then you may go to the library corner' is an application of:

    1. Negative reinforcement
    2. The Premack principle
    3. Extinction
    4. A variable interval schedule
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A preferred activity is used to reinforce a less preferred one.

  5. 5. A pupil needs 12 tokens to earn a reward and earns 3 tokens a day. How many days does it take?

    1. 4
    2. 3
    3. 5
    4. 6
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 12 ÷ 3 = 4 days.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery