- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Creativity and thinking: divergent thinking, Torrance's measures and Wallas's stages
Separate convergent from divergent thinking, score fluency and flexibility on a task, name the four stages of creative thought, and choose classroom practices that support creativity.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Creativity is the ability to produce ideas or products that are both new and useful. Schools often reward the right answer, but creativity needs room for many answers. This lesson sets out the standard terms and the kinds of exam problems that go with them.
Convergent and divergent thinking
Convergent thinking moves towards a single correct answer ('What is 7 × 8?'). Divergent thinking produces many possible answers ('List as many uses as you can for an old newspaper'). J. P. Guilford stressed divergent production as central to creativity. Both kinds of thinking are important, and good problem solving moves between them.
Torrance's measures of divergent thinking
| Measure | Meaning | How to count |
|---|---|---|
| Fluency | Number of ideas | Count the relevant responses |
| Flexibility | Variety of kinds of ideas | Count the different categories |
| Originality | Rarity of ideas | Count responses given by very few people |
| Elaboration | Detail added to an idea | Judge how fully an idea is developed |
E. Paul Torrance developed widely used tests of creative thinking built on these measures. Creativity is not the same as intelligence: very low intelligence limits creativity, but above a moderate level, high intelligence does not guarantee a high level of creativity.
Wallas's four stages
| Stage | What happens |
|---|---|
| Preparation | The person collects information and works on the problem |
| Incubation | The person sets the problem aside, and the mind works on it without effort |
| Illumination | A sudden idea or solution appears |
| Verification | The idea is tested and refined |
Teachers can encourage creativity by asking open-ended questions, accepting unusual answers, allowing time for ideas to develop, praising effort and originality, using brainstorming and projects, and creating a classroom where mistakes are safe. Creativity is reduced by fear of ridicule, rigid routines, an emphasis on rote learning and pressure to conform.
Worked example 1: score a response
A pupil lists uses of a brick: build a wall, build a house, paperweight, doorstop, bookends, crush spices, a step to reach a shelf and a hammer to crack nuts. Step 1: fluency = number of ideas = 8. Step 2: group the ideas into categories: building (wall, house), holding or weight (paperweight, doorstop, bookends), tools (crush spices, hammer), and furniture (step). Step 3: flexibility = 4 categories. Answer: fluency 8 and flexibility 4. The pupil gave many ideas, in four different kinds of use. If only the building ideas had been listed, the list could be long but flexibility would be 1.
Worked example 2: place the stage
A pupil struggles for days with a design problem for a science project, leaves it aside for a weekend, wakes on Monday with the solution, and then builds a model to check it. Answer: The days of struggle are preparation. The weekend rest is incubation. The sudden idea is illumination. Building the model to test the idea is verification.
Worked example 3: convergent or divergent?
Classify: (a) 'Find the area of a rectangle with sides 8 cm and 5 cm.' (b) 'Suggest different ways to reduce waste in your school.' Answer: (a) convergent, since there is one correct answer, 8 × 5 = 40 square centimetres. (b) divergent, since many valid answers are possible and the pupil is asked to produce as many as possible.
Fluency counts ideas, flexibility counts kinds, originality counts rarity, elaboration counts detail. Wallas: preparation, incubation, illumination, verification.
Key takeaways
- Convergent thinking seeks one answer; divergent thinking seeks many.
- Fluency, flexibility, originality and elaboration are Torrance's measures.
- Wallas's order is preparation, incubation, illumination and verification.
- Creativity needs a classroom where unusual answers are welcomed.
- Creativity and intelligence are related but not identical.
Check your understanding
-
1. A task asking 'How many different ways can you use a plastic bottle?' tests mainly:
- Convergent thinking
- Rote memory
- Reaction time
- Divergent thinking
Show answer
Answer: D. The task invites many different answers, which is divergent thinking.
-
2. A pupil lists 10 uses of a spoon, all of which belong to 3 categories. The fluency and flexibility scores are:
- 3 and 10
- 10 and 3
- 13 and 10
- 10 and 10
Show answer
Answer: B. Fluency is the number of ideas, 10. Flexibility is the number of categories, 3.
-
3. In Wallas's model, the sudden appearance of an idea is called:
- Incubation
- Preparation
- Illumination
- Verification
Show answer
Answer: C. Illumination is the stage in which the idea suddenly emerges.
-
4. Which classroom practice is most likely to reduce creativity?
- Punishing every unusual answer
- Using open-ended questions
- Allowing time for projects
- Using brainstorming sessions
Show answer
Answer: A. Fear of ridicule and punishment discourages pupils from offering new ideas.
-
5. Resting from a problem and later finding the solution comes to mind shows the stage of:
- Preparation
- Illumination
- Incubation
- Verification
Show answer
Answer: C. Setting the problem aside while the mind continues to work on it is incubation.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.