• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Which learning theory? Classifying scenarios quickly

Use a short sequence of questions to place any learning scenario under classical conditioning, operant conditioning, Thorndike's trial and error, insight or observational learning.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Most questions on learning theories give a short story and ask which theory explains it. The theories are well known, yet candidates lose marks by choosing too quickly. A simple sequence of questions, asked in order, settles almost every case.

The decision sequence

  1. Is the response automatic, such as fear, salivation or blinking, and tied to a stimulus that has been paired with another? Then it is classical conditioning (Pavlov; Watson for emotional responses).
  2. Is a voluntary behaviour changing because of what follows it? Then it is operant conditioning (Skinner). Reinforcement raises the behaviour and punishment lowers it.
  3. Does the learner improve gradually, trying many responses until one works? Then it is trial and error (Thorndike).
  4. Is the solution sudden, after the learner 'sees' how the parts fit? Then it is insight (Köhler and the Gestalt psychologists).
  5. Did the learner copy what someone else did, without being rewarded personally? Then it is observational learning (Bandura).
TheoryKey words in the storyTypical teacher use
Classical conditioningBell, fear, anxiety, stimulus paired, response spreads to similar thingsMake school a pleasant place so that positive feelings become attached to it
Operant conditioningReward, praise, marks, privilege lost, behaviour increases or decreasesReinforce desired behaviour quickly and consistently
Thorndike's trial and errorMany attempts, mistakes fall slowly, law of effect, exercise, readinessAllow practice with satisfying results
InsightSudden solution, 'aha', whole situation, transferPresent problems as wholes; allow time to think
Observational learningModel, imitates, watches, vicarious rewardBe a good model; praise visible good behaviour

Pavlov's terms: the unconditioned stimulus (UCS) naturally produces the unconditioned response (UCR). A neutral stimulus paired with it becomes the conditioned stimulus (CS) and then produces the conditioned response (CR). John Watson and Rosalie Rayner's study of a young child, 'Little Albert', showed that fear could be conditioned. It is also remembered for raising serious ethical concerns.

Worked example 1: classical conditioning in school

A pupil is scolded harshly every time he enters the mathematics room. After some weeks he feels his heart race when he sees the room, and even when he passes a similar room. Step 1: the racing heart is an automatic response. Step 2: the scolding (UCS) caused fear (UCR); the room (CS) became linked with it, so the fear on seeing the room is the CR. Step 3: fear of similar rooms is stimulus generalisation. Answer: classical conditioning with generalisation. A teacher can reverse it by making the room a place of success and warmth, so that the old link fades (extinction).

Worked example 2: choose the theory

(a) A pupil who is praised each time she tidies her desk begins to tidy it daily. (b) A boy tries several ways of opening a puzzle lock, and the time he takes falls slowly over ten attempts. (c) A girl who has struggled with a jigsaw suddenly places the key piece and quickly finishes it, and next time does so without trial. (d) A child who sees his elder sister helping with the washing starts to help in the same way. Answer: (a) operant conditioning (positive reinforcement); (b) Thorndike's trial and error; (c) insight; (d) observational learning.

Worked example 3: mixed signals

A teacher gives praise to a pupil who answers politely. Other pupils, who are watching, start to answer politely too. Which theories are involved? Step 1: the praised pupil is reinforced: operant conditioning. Step 2: the others were not praised, but they saw a model rewarded: observational learning with vicarious reinforcement. Answer: both. When a story involves several people, decide which person the question asks about.

Automatic response paired with a stimulus: Pavlov. Consequences change voluntary behaviour: Skinner. Slow trial and error: Thorndike. Sudden 'aha': Köhler. Watching a model: Bandura.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Ask what kind of response it is and what changed it.
  • Reinforcement increases behaviour; punishment decreases it.
  • Insight is sudden and transferable; trial and error is gradual.
  • Observational learning does not need personal reward.
  • If two people are in the story, check whom the question is about.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A child feels anxious on seeing a hospital after painful injections there. This is mainly:

    1. Operant conditioning
    2. Classical conditioning
    3. Insight learning
    4. Trial-and-error learning
    Show answer

    Answer: B. An automatic fear response became linked with the hospital through pairing, which is classical conditioning.

  2. 2. A pupil's score on a puzzle improves a little with each of fifteen attempts. This fits:

    1. Köhler's insight learning
    2. Bandura's observational learning
    3. Pavlov's classical conditioning
    4. Thorndike's trial-and-error learning
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Gradual improvement through repeated attempts is the pattern Thorndike described.

  3. 3. A pupil suddenly sees how to join two shapes to make a larger one, and can then do similar tasks easily. This is:

    1. Insight
    2. Extinction
    3. Trial and error
    4. Conditioning of a reflex
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A sudden solution that transfers easily is a mark of insight learning.

  4. 4. A boy begins to copy the walk of a cricketer he watches on television. This is:

    1. Classical conditioning
    2. Negative reinforcement
    3. Observational learning
    4. Trial-and-error learning
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Copying a model without personal reward is observational learning.

  5. 5. In Pavlov's experiment, the sound of a bell before conditioning is:

    1. The unconditioned stimulus
    2. The conditioned response
    3. The unconditioned response
    4. A neutral stimulus
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Before pairing with food, the bell had no effect on salivation. It was neutral and then became the conditioned stimulus.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery