• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Reading children's speech: stages, extensions and errors in practice

Identify a child's stage from a sample utterance, tell overextension, underextension and overgeneralisation apart, and avoid the usual traps in stage questions.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The foundation course described the stages of early language. Exam questions now give a child's actual words, 'ba-ba-ba', 'Milk!', 'Daddy go office', 'I goed', and ask what they show. A few more terms also appear, especially overextension and underextension. This lesson gives a quick method for reading a sample of speech and works through the traps that cost marks.

A four-question method

  1. Does the sound carry meaning? If not, and it is repeated syllables, it is babbling; soft vowel sounds are cooing.
  2. How many meaningful words? One word standing for a sentence is a holophrase; two words joined is the two-word stage.
  3. Are small words missing? Short strings of key words with 'is', 'the', 'to' left out are telegraphic speech.
  4. Is there an error no adult would make? If a grammar rule is stretched ('goed', 'mouses'), it is overgeneralisation; if a word's meaning is stretched or narrowed, it is overextension or underextension.

Two new terms: overextension and underextension

Young children often use a word for the wrong range of things. Overextension is using a word too widely: calling every man 'Papa', or every round thing 'ball'. Underextension is using a word too narrowly: 'cat' only for the family's own cat, or 'shoe' only for one's own shoes. Both are about the meaning of a word. Overgeneralisation, by contrast, is about a grammar rule applied too widely. This is the main trap in this topic: 'calling a cow doggy' is overextension, not overgeneralisation.

Overextension: a word's meaning too wide ('doggy' for all animals). Underextension: too narrow ('cat' only for my cat). Overgeneralisation: a grammar rule too wide ('goed', 'mouses').

Worked example 1: four samples

Name what each sample shows. (i) 'Moon!' said while pointing at a round lamp. (ii) 'Two foots.' (iii) 'Baby sleep.' (iv) 'aah-ooh' from a two-month-old. Step 1: (i) a word used for something it does not mean, because the lamp shares the moon's shape: overextension. Step 2: (ii) the plural '-s' rule applied to an irregular noun: overgeneralisation. Step 3: (iii) two meaningful words with small words missing: two-word, telegraphic speech. Step 4: (iv) vowel sounds without meaning: cooing. Answer: overextension, overgeneralisation, two-word or telegraphic, cooing.

Trap: understanding versus speaking

Questions sometimes describe a child who follows long instructions but says only a few words and ask whether something is wrong. Usually nothing is: receptive language normally runs ahead of productive language. The teacher's job is to keep talking with the child in full sentences and give plenty of chances to speak, not to treat the gap as a disorder.

Worked example 2: a teacher's note

A teacher of a pre-primary class writes: 'Aman calls all men "uncle", says "I runned fast", and understands every instruction I give.' What does each part show? Step 1: 'uncle' for all men stretches a word's meaning: overextension. Step 2: 'runned' stretches the past-tense rule: overgeneralisation. Step 3: understanding instructions shows good receptive language. Answer: these are normal signs of active language learning, and none of them calls for scolding.

Trap: ages

Stage ages are approximate. A question that asks you to choose the 'exact' age of a stage is testing a misunderstanding; the safe principle is that the order of stages is the same for all children, while the timing varies. When options give ages, pick the one with the right order and words like 'about'.

Why errors are good news

Overextensions show a child forming categories by noticing shared features, such as shape or four legs. Overgeneralisations show a child forming grammar rules. Both disappear as the child hears more language and refines the categories and rules. Correcting gently by modelling ('Yes, that's a cow!') helps; scolding does not.

Key takeaways: read a sample by asking about meaning, number of words, missing small words and adult-impossible errors; overextension and underextension concern word meaning, overgeneralisation concerns grammar rules; receptive language normally runs ahead of productive; the order of stages is fixed, the ages are only approximate; errors are signs of learning.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A toddler calls every four-legged animal she sees, cows, goats and cats, 'doggy'. This is called:

    1. Overextension
    2. Underextension
    3. Telegraphic speech
    4. Babbling
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Using a word for a wider group than it really covers is overextension. Underextension is the opposite: using a word too narrowly.

  2. 2. A child uses the word 'cat' only for her own pet cat and not for any other cat. This is:

    1. Underextension
    2. Overextension
    3. Overgeneralisation
    4. A holophrase
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Using a word for too narrow a set, here only one particular cat, is underextension.

  3. 3. A child says 'More juice' and 'Mummy sock'. Which stage is this?

    1. Babbling
    2. Cooing
    3. Inner speech
    4. Two-word stage
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Two meaningful words are joined to express an idea, which marks the two-word stage.

  4. 4. Which utterance shows overgeneralisation of a grammar rule?

    1. Doggy! (said while pointing at a cow)
    2. Mama go
    3. I eated it all
    4. Ba-ba-ba-ba
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 'Eated' applies the past-tense '-ed' rule to an irregular verb. Calling a cow 'doggy' is overextension of a word's meaning, not a grammar rule; 'Mama go' is telegraphic; 'ba-ba-ba' is babbling.

  5. 5. A child correctly follows 'Put the spoon in the cup', but herself says only single words. What does this show?

    1. She has a speech disorder, since she speaks only in single words at her age
    2. Her receptive language is ahead of her productive language, which is normal
    3. She is still only babbling, because she has not begun to use real words
    4. She is overgeneralising rules, as she applies one grammar pattern to every word
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Children understand more than they can say. Following a full instruction while speaking single words is a normal gap between receptive and productive language.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery