• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Skinner or Chomsky? Matching evidence and practice to theory

Decide which theory an observation or classroom practice supports, use the labels behaviourist and nativist correctly, and handle assertion-reason items on the two views.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

You know the two classic theories: Skinner's behaviourist view and Chomsky's view of an inborn language acquisition device. In exams they are rarely asked about directly. Instead, a question gives an observation, a classroom practice or a pair of statements and asks which theory it supports. This lesson builds a reliable way to decide.

Labels to know

Skinner's view is called behaviourist or learning-theory, because it treats language as learned behaviour. Chomsky's view is called nativist, because it treats the ability for grammar as native, that is, inborn. Piaget's view is often called constructivist, because the child constructs understanding, and Vygotsky's is called sociocultural, because language grows out of social life. Questions often test these labels with one swapped.

The discriminating evidence

Which theory does the observation support?
ObservationSupportsWhy
Children use the accent and local words of their homeSkinnerCopied directly from models
Praise makes a shy child speak moreSkinnerReinforcement increases behaviour
Children make new sentences never heardChomskyCannot be imitated
Errors like 'goed' and 'mouses'ChomskyRules applied, not copies
Similar stages in all language communitiesChomskyPoints to a shared inborn programme
Grammar learned with little correctionChomskyReinforcement cannot be the cause

Beware of observations that both theories accept. 'A child learns the language spoken around her' is true for Skinner and for Chomsky, since Chomsky also needs exposure to start the device. Such a statement cannot decide between them, and a well-made question will not use it as the deciding clue.

Copying and reward explain WHAT is learned (accent, words). New sentences, rule errors, universal stages and learning without correction point to an inborn ability: nativist (Chomsky).

Worked example 1: which theory?

Observation: 'A two-and-a-half-year-old says "Me no want sleep", a sentence no one in her family ever says.' Step 1: was it heard? No, so imitation fails. Step 2: was it rewarded before? It is new, so reinforcement fails. Step 3: it follows a simple rule system of the child's own. Answer: it supports Chomsky's nativist view.

Classroom practices from each theory

Behaviourist practice: clear models, repetition, drill of patterns and immediate praise or tokens for correct use. Nativist practice: a rich language environment of stories, songs and conversation; patience with errors, which are signs of rule learning; and recasting, in which the teacher repeats a child's idea in correct form without pointing out the error ('I goed' answered with 'Oh, you went? Where?'). Recasting gives a correct model while keeping the child talking.

Worked example 2: an assertion-reason item

A: Children learn the grammar of their language without formal teaching. R: Chomsky proposed an inborn language acquisition device. Step 1: A is true; young children learn grammar long before any grammar lesson. Step 2: R is true; this is Chomsky's proposal. Step 3: does R explain A? Yes: an inborn device for discovering grammar is exactly Chomsky's explanation of why no formal teaching is needed. Answer: both are true, and R explains A.

Worked example 3: a practice to classify

A teacher says, 'I never mark young children's spoken errors. I just answer with the right form and keep the conversation going, and I read them lots of stories.' Step 1: no reward or drill is involved, so this is not behaviourist practice. Step 2: rich input and recasting trust the child's own rule learning. Answer: it fits the nativist (Chomsky) view.

Key takeaways: behaviourist is Skinner, nativist is Chomsky, constructivist is Piaget, sociocultural is Vygotsky; accent, local words and the effect of praise support Skinner; new sentences, rule errors, universal stages and learning without correction support Chomsky; a fact both accept cannot decide between them; recasting gives a correct model without scolding.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Chomsky's view of language development is usually called:

    1. Nativist
    2. Behaviourist
    3. Constructivist
    4. Sociocultural
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Chomsky held that the ability for grammar is inborn (native), so his view is called nativist. Behaviourist is Skinner; constructivist is usually Piaget; sociocultural is Vygotsky.

  2. 2. 'Children whose parents rarely praise or correct their grammar still learn grammar fully.' This observation supports:

    1. Skinner
    2. Chomsky
    3. Neither theory
    4. Only the idea of shaping
    Show answer

    Answer: B. If grammar is learned without reward or correction, reinforcement cannot be the main cause; an inborn ability, as Chomsky argued, explains it.

  3. 3. A teacher drills sentence patterns, and gives a star each time a child uses the pattern correctly. This method is based on:

    1. Chomsky's universal grammar
    2. Vygotsky's inner speech
    3. Piaget's egocentric speech
    4. Skinner's behaviourist theory
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Repetition and reward for correct responses are imitation and reinforcement, the core of behaviourist learning.

  4. 4. A child says, 'I sawed a bird.' The teacher replies, 'Oh, you saw a bird! What colour was it?' This technique is:

    1. Recasting: repeating the child's idea in the correct form
    2. Punishing the error by telling the child that it was wrong
    3. Overextension: using a word for too wide a range of objects
    4. Shaping by withholding a reward until the child says it correctly
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The teacher repeats the meaning with the correct form and keeps the conversation going, without telling the child off. This is recasting.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Many children say 'goed' for a time. Reason (R): Adults often say 'goed' to children. Choose the correct option.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R explains A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
    3. A is true but R is false
    4. A is false but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A is true: 'goed' is a common overgeneralisation. R is false: adults do not say 'goed', which is exactly why the error cannot come from imitation.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery