- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Choosing the right method for the learning goal
Match EVS learning goals to suitable methods - observation, simple activities, surveys, field trips, projects and discussion - and avoid mismatches.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The foundation course introduced the main EVS methods one by one. Exam-style questions usually ask a harder thing: given a learning goal and a situation, which method fits best? Several options may be good methods in general; only one fits this goal. The skill is to match purpose to method.
Matching goals to methods
| If the goal is to... | A well-matched method |
|---|---|
| notice changes over time in a living thing | Regular observation with a record (drawing, table) |
| see a cause and its effect clearly | A simple activity comparing two set-ups, changing one thing |
| find out what is common among many people or homes | A survey |
| understand a place, process or kind of work that cannot be brought to class | A field trip |
| investigate a question in depth over time and produce something | Project work |
| share experiences, compare views and build ideas together | Discussion |
The key word in the goal usually points to the method. 'Changes over days' suggests observation over time. 'What happens if' suggests a comparison activity. 'How many families' suggests a survey. 'How bread is made in a bakery' suggests a visit. 'Find out, plan and present' suggests a project. 'Different experiences' suggests discussion.
Fair comparison in simple activities
When children compare two set-ups to find a cause, only one thing should differ. To find out whether a plant needs sunlight, both plants should get the same water and the same soil and pot; only the light differs. If one plant is also given less water, children cannot tell which change caused the result. Even young children can understand the idea of 'keeping everything else the same' if the teacher asks, 'Is this a fair test?'
Methods are also combined. A project on 'water in our area' may begin with a survey of where families get water, include a field trip to a nearby tank or well, use a simple comparison activity to see which cloth filters muddy water best, and end with a discussion and a class display. Choosing well means picking the right method for each part of the question, not using one method for everything.
Common mismatches
- Using a survey to see how a seed grows (growth needs observation over time, not counting answers).
- Using a lecture where children could easily see the real thing nearby.
- Planning a field trip to learn something better found by asking families at home (a survey would do).
- Comparing two set-ups that differ in more than one way.
Worked example 1
Goal: Class 5 pupils should find out whether salt dissolves faster in warm water than in cold water. Key words: 'whether', 'faster', which point to cause and effect. Method: a simple comparison activity. Fair-test check: use the same amount of water in identical glasses, the same spoonful of salt, and stir the same way; only the temperature differs. Working the result: if the salt in the warm glass disappears first, pupils conclude that warm water dissolved it faster, because temperature was the only difference. A survey or a field trip would not answer this question.
Worked example 2
Goal: Class 4 pupils should learn which cooking fuels are used in homes in their area. Key words: 'which ... in homes in their area', many households. Method: a survey. Each pupil asks five neighbouring families. Working with data: suppose 30 pupils each ask 5 families, so 30 × 5 = 150 families are surveyed, and 90 of them use gas. Then 90 out of 150 is 3/5, which is 60 percent. Pupils can show the results as a picture graph and discuss why different fuels are used. A field trip to one home would not show the pattern across many.
Let the goal choose the method: change over time, observe; cause and effect, compare fairly; many people, survey; a place you cannot bring in, visit; a question to investigate in depth, project; different experiences, discuss.
Key takeaways
Read the learning goal for its key words and choose the method that serves it. In comparison activities, change only one thing so the test is fair. Avoid mismatches such as surveys for growth, lectures for what children can see, or trips for what a survey can find. Data from surveys also give practice in counting, fractions and graphs.
Check your understanding
-
1. Goal: pupils should notice how a caterpillar changes over two weeks. Which method fits best?
- A one-day survey of the pupils' families
- A lecture on the life of insects by a guest
- A debate on whether insects are harmful
- Regular observation with a drawing record
Show answer
Answer: D. Changes over time are best seen through repeated observation and recording.
-
2. To test whether plants need sunlight, pupils keep one plant in light and one in a dark cupboard. What else must be kept the same?
- Nothing else matters
- The colour of the label only
- The number of pupils watching
- Water, soil and pot size
Show answer
Answer: D. In a fair test only the light should differ, so other conditions must be equal.
-
3. Goal: find out which festivals are celebrated by the families of children in the class. Which method fits best?
- A field trip to a temple
- A comparison activity
- Regular observation of a plant
- A survey
Show answer
Answer: D. Collecting the same information from many families is a survey.
-
4. In a survey, 25 pupils each ask 4 families. 60 families say they grow vegetables at home. What percentage is this?
- 40 percent
- 25 percent
- 15 percent
- 60 percent
Show answer
Answer: D. 25 × 4 = 100 families; 60 out of 100 is 60 percent.
-
5. Which is a mismatch between goal and method?
- Using a field trip to see how a bakery makes bread
- Using a survey to find out how a seed grows into a plant
- Using discussion to share how families celebrate harvest
- Using a fair comparison to test which cloth dries fastest
Show answer
Answer: B. Seed growth must be observed over time; a survey of opinions cannot show it.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.