• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Questioning and discussion in practice

Turn closed EVS questions into open ones, sequence questions from observation to reasoning, and handle wrong answers and children's own questions well.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Questioning and discussion were introduced in the foundation course. This lesson sharpens them into practical skills. A teacher asks dozens of questions in each lesson; the kind of question decides whether children recall, observe, reason or imagine. How the teacher responds to answers, especially wrong ones, decides whether children keep talking.

Kinds of questions

A ladder of questions
KindExampleWhat it asks the child to do
RecallWhich bird did we see at the pond?Remember
ObservationWhat do you notice about the leaves of this plant?Look closely and describe
ComparisonHow is the hen's beak different from the parrot's?Find likenesses and differences
ReasoningWhy do you think the parrot's beak is curved?Explain a cause
PredictionWhat will happen to the wet cloth if we hang it in the shade?Use ideas to foresee
Imagination and valuesWhat would our street be like with no trees?Think beyond the present; reflect

Recall questions are not bad; they check facts quickly. But a lesson made only of recall questions does not make children think. A useful habit is to move up the ladder within a lesson: begin with observation, then compare, then ask why, then predict.

Turning closed questions into open ones

Most closed questions can be opened by adding 'why', 'how', 'what if' or 'how could we find out'. 'Is the pond water clean?' becomes 'How could we find out whether this water is clean enough to drink?' 'Name two animals that live in water' becomes 'What helps animals live in water? Give examples.'

Responding to answers

When a child gives a wrong or incomplete answer, the teacher's response matters more than the correction. Asking 'What made you think that?' shows the child's reasoning and often reveals a misconception worth discussing. Inviting others ('Does anyone see it differently?') turns an answer into a discussion. Probing a correct answer ('How do you know?') makes the reasoning visible to the whole class. Ridicule, sarcasm or simply saying 'Wrong, next' teaches children to stay silent.

Two more habits help. First, wait after asking: a pause of a few seconds lets slower thinkers form an answer, and answers become longer and better reasoned. Second, collect children's own questions, for example on a 'question wall', and use them to plan observations and activities. A child's question that the class then investigates teaches more than a dozen questions asked by the teacher.

Worked example 1

Task: build a sequence of questions for Class 3 about a bird's nest brought to class. Working up the ladder: observation: 'What is this nest made of?' comparison: 'How is it different from the nest in the picture?' reasoning: 'Why do you think the bird used soft feathers inside?' prediction: 'Where do you think the bird would build a nest in our school, and why?' values: 'Why should we not disturb nests?' The sequence moves from looking to thinking to caring, and each question builds on the last.

Worked example 2

Situation: the teacher asks, 'Why do we see lightning before we hear thunder?' A child answers, 'Because the eyes are in front of the ears.' Poor response: 'Wrong. Sit down.' Better response: 'Interesting, what made you think of that?' then 'Let us test it: if you face away from a friend who claps, do you hear it later?' and 'Has anyone noticed the same thing with a cricket ball being hit far away?' The child's idea is taken seriously and tested; the class reaches the idea that light reaches us faster than sound. The child keeps participating.

Climb the question ladder: observe, compare, reason, predict, reflect. Answer a wrong answer with 'What made you think that?', not with 'Wrong'.

Key takeaways

Questions can ask children to recall, observe, compare, reason, predict or reflect; good lessons move up this ladder. Closed questions can be opened with why, how, what if and how could we find out. Respond to wrong answers by asking for reasons and inviting other views, and probe correct answers too. Children's own questions are welcomed and used.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. 'Why do you think camels have long eyelashes?' is a question that asks children to:

    1. recall a fact only
    2. reason about a cause
    3. copy from the board
    4. count objects
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A why question asks for an explanation.

  2. 2. Which is the best open version of 'Is this soil wet?'

    1. Can you say whether this soil is dry or wet by looking at it?
    2. What colour is the soil in each of these two pots in the room?
    3. Say yes or no: is the soil in the pot wet at this moment?
    4. How could we find out which of these two soils holds more water?
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Adding 'how could we find out' turns a yes or no question into an investigation.

  3. 3. A child gives a wrong answer. Which teacher response best supports learning?

    1. What made you think that?
    2. Wrong. Next.
    3. That is a silly answer.
    4. Ignore it and ask someone else.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Asking for the child's reasoning reveals thinking and keeps the child participating.

  4. 4. Which order of questions best moves up the question ladder?

    1. Why do you think so, what do you see, what will happen, how is it different
    2. What do you see, how is it different, why do you think so, what will happen if
    3. What will happen if, what do you see, why do you think so, how is it different
    4. Only questions asking for the names of things seen by the children, one by one
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The ladder runs from observation to comparison to reasoning to prediction.

  5. 5. A child gives a correct answer. Why might the teacher still ask, 'How do you know?'

    1. To make the reasoning visible to the child and the class
    2. To make the child doubt a correct answer
    3. Because correct answers should not be accepted
    4. To fill time
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Probing correct answers shows the reasoning behind them and helps others learn.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery