• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Other named methods: Total Physical Response, Silent Way, Suggestopedia and Community Language Learning

Recognise four named methods from their key features, and the Natural Approach, and decide when each idea is useful in a primary classroom.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The first look at methods covered grammar-translation, direct, audio-lingual, communicative, task-based and bilingual teaching. Examination papers also list a few named methods that came from the 1970s onwards, each with a memorable feature. The aim is to recognise them from a description and to see which ideas are useful in an ordinary classroom. This lesson covers four named methods and the Natural Approach.

Total Physical Response (TPR)

James Asher developed Total Physical Response. The teacher gives commands in the new language ('Stand up', 'Touch the door', 'Pick up the book'), and learners respond with actions, without having to speak at first. Understanding comes first, and speaking comes later when the learners are ready. TPR suits beginners and young children but is hard to use for abstract ideas.

The Silent Way

Caleb Gattegno proposed the Silent Way. The teacher speaks as little as possible, models a word or sentence once, and lets learners discover and practise the language themselves, helped by coloured rods and wall charts of sounds and words. Learners must take responsibility and work out the language.

Suggestopedia

Georgi Lozanov's Suggestopedia aims to remove learners' mental blocks and fear of failure. Classrooms are comfortable and attractive, learners sit in relaxed positions, soft music is played, and the teacher reads texts in a calm way; learners often take new names and roles.

Community Language Learning (CLL)

Charles Curran's Community Language Learning treats learners as a community with the teacher as a counsellor. A learner says something in her mother tongue, the teacher (the knower) quietly says it in the target language, and the learner repeats it. The group chooses what to talk about, so the content comes from learners' own wishes. CLL needs a teacher who knows the learners' mother tongue.

The Natural Approach

Tracy Terrell, with Krashen, described the Natural Approach. It follows the input hypothesis: the teacher speaks the target language, uses pictures and actions to make it understood, and does not force learners to speak until they are ready; errors are not corrected at once.

MethodFounderKey clue
Total Physical ResponseAsherCommands and physical action; listening before speaking
Silent WayGattegnoTeacher mostly silent; rods and charts; learners discover
SuggestopediaLozanovRelaxed, comfortable setting, music, positive suggestion
Community Language LearningCurranTeacher as counsellor; learners decide what to say; mother tongue then target
Natural ApproachTerrell and KrashenComprehensible input; no forced early speech

TPR = commands and action. Silent Way = silent teacher and rods. Suggestopedia = relaxation and music. CLL = teacher as counsellor. Natural Approach = comprehensible input without forced speech.

Worked example 1: name the method

Name the method from each description. (a) The teacher says 'Walk to the window', 'Open the window', and the children do the actions. (b) The classroom has soft chairs and low music, and the teacher reads a dialogue in a calm voice. (c) The teacher models the word 'red', then points to coloured rods and says nothing while the pupils try to name them. (d) A pupil whispers a sentence in Hindi; the teacher quietly says it in English; the pupil repeats it. Step 1: (a) commands and action, so TPR. Step 2: (b) relaxation and music, so Suggestopedia. Step 3: (c) silence and rods, so the Silent Way. Step 4: (d) the teacher as knower in the mother tongue and target language, so CLL. Answer: TPR, Suggestopedia, Silent Way, CLL.

Worked example 2: use the idea in a real class

A teacher of Class 1 children, who know almost no English, wants to use one of these ideas for the first month. Which is most suitable? Working: TPR suits the age and level: children enjoy moving, they can show understanding without speaking, and the teacher needs only objects around the room. She might begin with 'Stand up', 'Sit down', 'Touch your nose', and add sequences later: 'Pick up the pencil and put it on the table.' The Silent Way demands more independence than such beginners can show. Answer: TPR, as part of a Natural Approach to early English.

Using the ideas without the labels

  • From TPR: let beginners show understanding through action before they are asked to speak.
  • From Suggestopedia: a pleasant room, songs and a relaxed teacher lower anxiety.
  • From the Natural Approach: give a lot of understandable input and do not force early speech.

Key takeaways: TPR (Asher) uses commands and action; the Silent Way (Gattegno) uses a mostly silent teacher and rods; Suggestopedia (Lozanov) uses relaxation and suggestion; Community Language Learning (Curran) makes the teacher a counsellor; the Natural Approach (Terrell and Krashen) gives understandable input without forced speech; their ideas can be borrowed for an ordinary class.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The teacher says 'Stand up', 'Touch your ear' and children do the actions. This is:

    1. The Silent Way
    2. Suggestopedia
    3. Community Language Learning
    4. Total Physical Response
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Commands answered by physical action are the main feature of Total Physical Response.

  2. 2. Which method is associated with soft music, a relaxed setting and positive suggestion?

    1. Audio-lingual method
    2. Suggestopedia
    3. Grammar-translation method
    4. Total Physical Response
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Georgi Lozanov's Suggestopedia stresses relaxation and positive suggestion to reduce mental blocks.

  3. 3. In Community Language Learning, the teacher acts mainly as a:

    1. Strict leader of long repetition drills
    2. Silent observer who never speaks to pupils
    3. Counsellor who supplies the language they ask for
    4. Translator of whole passages for homework
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The teacher is a counsellor and a knower of the target language, who helps learners say what they want.

  4. 4. The Silent Way is associated with:

    1. Gattegno
    2. Asher
    3. Lozanov
    4. Curran
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Caleb Gattegno proposed the Silent Way. Asher proposed TPR, Lozanov Suggestopedia, and Curran CLL.

  5. 5. Which method is best for Class 1 children who have met almost no English?

    1. Community Language Learning, because it needs no teacher knowledge
    2. Formal grammar-translation of long passages
    3. Total Physical Response, because actions show understanding
    4. A test of grammar rules before any listening
    Show answer

    Answer: C. TPR lets young beginners show understanding by action without speaking. The other options are unsuitable for them.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery