• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Conservation, classification and seriation tasks

Know what each classic Piagetian task tests, predict how children at different stages respond, and work class-inclusion questions with numbers.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Many questions describe one of Piaget's classic tasks and ask either what it tests or how a child at a given stage would respond. If you know the procedure and the typical answers, you can solve these instantly. This lesson collects the tasks in one table, works through class inclusion with numbers, and explains the rough order in which kinds of conservation appear.

The classic tasks
TaskProcedure (short)TestsTypically passed in
Hidden toyToy covered by a cloth while the baby watchesObject permanenceSensorimotor
Three mountainsWhat does a doll on the other side see?EgocentrismUsually beyond preoperational
NumberTwo equal rows of coins; one row spread outConservation of numberConcrete operational
LiquidEqual water; one poured into a taller, thinner glassConservation of liquid quantityConcrete operational
SubstanceTwo equal clay balls; one rolled into a sausageConservation of substance (mass)Concrete operational
LengthTwo equal sticks; one moved alongConservation of lengthConcrete operational
Class inclusionMore roses or more flowers?Classification (part and whole)Concrete operational
Ordering sticksArrange sticks shortest to longestSeriationConcrete operational
PendulumWhat decides the speed of the swing?Hypothetico-deductive reasoningFormal operational

Conservation: a rough order

Children do not acquire all kinds of conservation at once. Roughly, conservation of number tends to appear earlier, substance and length a little later, then weight, and volume usually last. Piaget called this unevenness horizontal decalage: the same kind of logic is applied to different materials at different times. Use this order only as 'roughly'; a question that demands an exact age for each type is not a sound question.

Class inclusion

Class inclusion is the understanding that a subclass is part of a larger class and cannot be bigger than it. A preoperational child compares the two visible subgroups instead of the subgroup with the whole. To answer a class-inclusion question, add up the whole class and compare it with the subgroup named.

Worked example 1: class inclusion with numbers

A child is shown 8 brown wooden beads and 2 white wooden beads and asked, 'Are there more brown beads or more wooden beads?' Step 1: find the whole class. All beads are wooden, so wooden beads = 8 + 2 = 10. Step 2: compare with the subclass named. Brown beads = 8. Step 3: answer. Wooden beads are more, 10 against 8. A preoperational child usually says 'more brown beads', because she compares brown with white (8 against 2) instead of brown with all wooden beads. A concrete operational child gives the correct answer.

Worked example 2: predicting responses in the length task

Two equal pencils are laid side by side with their ends lined up. The child agrees they are the same length. Then one pencil is pushed forward a few centimetres. A preoperational child usually says the pushed pencil is longer, because she centres on where the front ends are. A concrete operational child says they are still the same, reasoning that nothing was cut or added (identity) and that it could be pushed back (reversibility). The task tests conservation of length.

Worked example 3: which task fits the question?

A question says: 'A student tests a swinging weight by changing the string length while keeping the weight and push the same, then repeats for weight and for push.' Which task and stage? This is the pendulum problem, which tests systematic, hypothetico-deductive reasoning, typical of the formal operational stage. A concrete operational student usually changes several factors at once and cannot isolate the cause.

Know each task by what it tests. For class inclusion, compare the subclass with the whole, not with the other subclass. Conservation appears roughly in the order number, substance and length, weight, volume.

— Task rule

Key takeaways

Match each task to its concept: hidden toy for object permanence, three mountains for egocentrism, rows, glasses, clay and sticks for conservation, roses and flowers for class inclusion, ordering sticks for seriation, and the pendulum for hypothetico-deductive reasoning. In class inclusion, always add up the whole class first.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A child sees 6 dogs and 3 cats and is asked, 'Are there more dogs or more animals?' A child who has mastered class inclusion says:

    1. more dogs, 6 against 3
    2. they are equal
    3. more cats
    4. more animals, 9 against 6
    Show answer

    Answer: D. All the dogs and cats are animals, so animals = 6 + 3 = 9, which is more than 6 dogs. Comparing dogs with cats is the preoperational error.

  2. 2. Piaget's pendulum problem is used to study:

    1. object permanence
    2. hypothetico-deductive reasoning
    3. egocentrism
    4. animism
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The pendulum task asks the student to find what affects the swing by testing factors one at a time, which is hypothetico-deductive reasoning.

  3. 3. Two equal clay balls are shown; one is flattened into a pancake, and the child is asked if both have the same amount of clay. The task tests:

    1. seriation
    2. object permanence
    3. class inclusion
    4. conservation of substance
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Asking whether the amount stays the same after a change of shape tests conservation of substance (mass).

  4. 4. A baby watches a toy being covered with a cloth. Whether she lifts the cloth to find it tests:

    1. object permanence
    2. conservation of number
    3. seriation
    4. egocentrism
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Searching for a hidden toy shows the baby knows it still exists, which is object permanence.

  5. 5. Roughly, which kind of conservation usually appears last?

    1. Number
    2. Length
    3. Volume
    4. Substance
    Show answer

    Answer: C. In the rough typical order, number comes earlier, then substance and length, then weight, and volume is usually last.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery