• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Play, speech and imitation: scenario questions

Practise telling practice play, symbolic play and games with rules apart, separating egocentric from socialised speech, and deciding whether a scene shows assimilation or accommodation.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

After the foundation lessons on play and language, the exam skill is to read a scene and label it correctly. Wrong options are built from near-matches: pretending that looks like a game with rules, or repetition that looks like practice play but is imitation. This lesson gives tests to separate them.

Tests for kinds of play

Test questionIf yes
Is the child repeating an action for pleasure with no pretending?Practice play
Does one object or action stand for another, in pretend?Symbolic play
Are there agreed rules that players follow and argue about?Game with rules
Is the child copying a model as exactly as possible?Imitation (accommodation)

Tests for speech

  • Is the child's remark addressed to a listener, and does it adapt to that listener? If yes, socialised speech.
  • Does the child talk about her own action, aloud, with no concern whether anyone listens or answers? Egocentric speech.
  • Do two children each speak about their own activity, without replies? A collective monologue.

Traps

  • Pretend rules. Children playing 'school' with roles are in symbolic play; fixed, agreed, argued-over rules mean a game with rules.
  • Practice play after infancy. Older children may still repeat actions for fun, such as skipping or bouncing a ball, which are practice play.
  • Egocentric is not selfish. A child who speaks egocentrically is not unkind; the term describes thinking.
  • Play versus imitation. In play the child changes the world to fit her wishes (assimilation); in imitation she changes herself to match the model (accommodation).

Worked example 1: five scenes

(a) A baby shakes a rattle again and again. (b) A four-year-old mixes mud and leaves and says it is soup. (c) Seven-year-olds play kabaddi and debate whether a raider's touch counts. (d) A three-year-old, after a day with a doctor, copies the doctor's way of tapping and listening as exactly as she can the next day. (e) A five-year-old drawing alone says aloud, 'I am making a big house with a red door.' Answers: (a) practice play; (b) symbolic play; (c) a game with rules; (d) deferred imitation, accommodation to a remembered model, and a sign of mental images; (e) egocentric speech, because it is not addressed to a listener and expects no reply.

Worked example 2: assimilation or accommodation?

Two children have a stick. Child A uses it as a horse and gallops round the room. Child B watches a teacher bend and straighten a stick to show a bow and arrow, and tries to copy exactly. Working: A changes the stick's meaning to suit his idea: assimilation is dominant, so this is play. B adjusts his own actions to the teacher's example: accommodation is dominant, so this is imitation. Note that in both cases the actual stick is the same; what differs is which way the adjustment goes.

A quick count

A teacher records 24 speech remarks by five-year-olds during free play: 15 are addressed to a listener and get a reply, and 9 are spoken to nobody in particular. The share of socialised speech is 15 / 24 = 62.5 percent, and of egocentric speech 9 / 24 = 37.5 percent. (These numbers are made up for practice.) Piaget would expect the second share to fall in older children.

Pretend: symbolic play. Repeat for pleasure: practice play. Agreed rules: game with rules. Copying exactly: imitation. Talk addressed to a listener: socialised speech.

Key takeaways

  • Use short tests to separate the kinds of play and speech.
  • Roles in pretend play are not rules; rules must be agreed and followed.
  • Play leans on assimilation, imitation on accommodation.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Children play 'shop' with leaves as money. Which kind of play is this?

    1. Practice play
    2. Game with rules
    3. Symbolic play
    4. Deferred imitation only
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Leaves stand for money, which is pretend.

  2. 2. Two eight-year-olds play carrom and settle an argument by checking the rules. This is:

    1. A game with rules
    2. Symbolic play
    3. Practice play
    4. Egocentric speech
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The play is governed by agreed rules.

  3. 3. A child talks aloud to herself about her drawing and does not expect an answer. This is:

    1. Socialised speech
    2. A game with rules
    3. Accommodation
    4. Egocentric speech
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Speech is not addressed to a listener.

  4. 4. A teacher records 20 remarks, of which 14 are addressed to a listener. What share is socialised speech?

    1. 14 percent
    2. 70 percent
    3. 30 percent
    4. 60 percent
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 14 / 20 = 0.7, which is 70 percent.

  5. 5. A child copies a gesture exactly as shown the day before. Piaget would call this mainly:

    1. Deferred imitation, with accommodation dominant
    2. Symbolic play, with assimilation dominant
    3. Practice play for pleasure
    4. Egocentric speech
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Copying a remembered model changes the child to fit the model.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery