- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Play, speech and imitation: scenario questions
Practise telling practice play, symbolic play and games with rules apart, separating egocentric from socialised speech, and deciding whether a scene shows assimilation or accommodation.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
After the foundation lessons on play and language, the exam skill is to read a scene and label it correctly. Wrong options are built from near-matches: pretending that looks like a game with rules, or repetition that looks like practice play but is imitation. This lesson gives tests to separate them.
Tests for kinds of play
| Test question | If yes |
|---|---|
| Is the child repeating an action for pleasure with no pretending? | Practice play |
| Does one object or action stand for another, in pretend? | Symbolic play |
| Are there agreed rules that players follow and argue about? | Game with rules |
| Is the child copying a model as exactly as possible? | Imitation (accommodation) |
Tests for speech
- Is the child's remark addressed to a listener, and does it adapt to that listener? If yes, socialised speech.
- Does the child talk about her own action, aloud, with no concern whether anyone listens or answers? Egocentric speech.
- Do two children each speak about their own activity, without replies? A collective monologue.
Traps
- Pretend rules. Children playing 'school' with roles are in symbolic play; fixed, agreed, argued-over rules mean a game with rules.
- Practice play after infancy. Older children may still repeat actions for fun, such as skipping or bouncing a ball, which are practice play.
- Egocentric is not selfish. A child who speaks egocentrically is not unkind; the term describes thinking.
- Play versus imitation. In play the child changes the world to fit her wishes (assimilation); in imitation she changes herself to match the model (accommodation).
Worked example 1: five scenes
(a) A baby shakes a rattle again and again. (b) A four-year-old mixes mud and leaves and says it is soup. (c) Seven-year-olds play kabaddi and debate whether a raider's touch counts. (d) A three-year-old, after a day with a doctor, copies the doctor's way of tapping and listening as exactly as she can the next day. (e) A five-year-old drawing alone says aloud, 'I am making a big house with a red door.' Answers: (a) practice play; (b) symbolic play; (c) a game with rules; (d) deferred imitation, accommodation to a remembered model, and a sign of mental images; (e) egocentric speech, because it is not addressed to a listener and expects no reply.
Worked example 2: assimilation or accommodation?
Two children have a stick. Child A uses it as a horse and gallops round the room. Child B watches a teacher bend and straighten a stick to show a bow and arrow, and tries to copy exactly. Working: A changes the stick's meaning to suit his idea: assimilation is dominant, so this is play. B adjusts his own actions to the teacher's example: accommodation is dominant, so this is imitation. Note that in both cases the actual stick is the same; what differs is which way the adjustment goes.
A quick count
A teacher records 24 speech remarks by five-year-olds during free play: 15 are addressed to a listener and get a reply, and 9 are spoken to nobody in particular. The share of socialised speech is 15 / 24 = 62.5 percent, and of egocentric speech 9 / 24 = 37.5 percent. (These numbers are made up for practice.) Piaget would expect the second share to fall in older children.
Pretend: symbolic play. Repeat for pleasure: practice play. Agreed rules: game with rules. Copying exactly: imitation. Talk addressed to a listener: socialised speech.
Key takeaways
- Use short tests to separate the kinds of play and speech.
- Roles in pretend play are not rules; rules must be agreed and followed.
- Play leans on assimilation, imitation on accommodation.
Check your understanding
-
1. Children play 'shop' with leaves as money. Which kind of play is this?
- Practice play
- Game with rules
- Symbolic play
- Deferred imitation only
Show answer
Answer: C. Leaves stand for money, which is pretend.
-
2. Two eight-year-olds play carrom and settle an argument by checking the rules. This is:
- A game with rules
- Symbolic play
- Practice play
- Egocentric speech
Show answer
Answer: A. The play is governed by agreed rules.
-
3. A child talks aloud to herself about her drawing and does not expect an answer. This is:
- Socialised speech
- A game with rules
- Accommodation
- Egocentric speech
Show answer
Answer: D. Speech is not addressed to a listener.
-
4. A teacher records 20 remarks, of which 14 are addressed to a listener. What share is socialised speech?
- 14 percent
- 70 percent
- 30 percent
- 60 percent
Show answer
Answer: B. 14 / 20 = 0.7, which is 70 percent.
-
5. A child copies a gesture exactly as shown the day before. Piaget would call this mainly:
- Deferred imitation, with accommodation dominant
- Symbolic play, with assimilation dominant
- Practice play for pleasure
- Egocentric speech
Show answer
Answer: A. Copying a remembered model changes the child to fit the model.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.