- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Everyday and scientific concepts: two roads to understanding
Explain Vygotsky's distinction between everyday (spontaneous) concepts learnt from experience and scientific concepts learnt through teaching, and how the two develop and help each other.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A child may use the word 'animal' correctly from the age of three, yet may be unable to say what an animal is until much later. Vygotsky studied this gap between using a concept and understanding it, and described two kinds of concepts. The distinction explains the special job of the school, and it is a favourite of examiners because it is easy to state and easy to mix up.
Two kinds of concepts
| Item | Everyday (spontaneous) concepts | Scientific concepts |
|---|---|---|
| Where they come from | The child's own experience and daily life | Teaching in school, in a system of ideas |
| How they are learnt | From the concrete example upwards | From the definition and the system downwards |
| How they feel | Used correctly but without awareness of the rule | Defined, linked to other concepts and used on purpose |
| Example | 'brother', 'dog', 'rain' | 'mammal', 'fraction', 'evaporation' |
Everyday concepts develop from the bottom up: the child meets many dogs and then forms the idea of a dog. Scientific concepts develop from the top down: the child is given the definition and place in a system (a mammal is a warm-blooded animal that feeds its young on milk) and works downwards to examples.
Everyday concepts grow upwards from experience; scientific concepts come downwards through teaching. Each helps the other.
How the two help each other
Vygotsky did not rank one above the other. A scientific concept needs the child's everyday experience to give it meaning: the idea of 'evaporation' makes sense because the child has seen wet clothes dry. In return, learning a scientific concept makes the everyday concept more conscious and deliberate, because the child now knows how to define it and how it fits with others. The child moves from using a concept to understanding and controlling it.
Worked example 1: a child's dog
A five-year-old says 'dog' correctly for many breeds. When asked 'What is a dog?' he answers 'It's Moti!' (his own pet). Working: this is an everyday concept: correct in use, tied to experience, with no definition. Later, in school, he learns that dogs are mammals. That is a scientific concept, placing 'dog' in a system and making his understanding conscious.
Worked example 2: teaching fractions
A teacher begins Class 4 fractions by asking children to share one chapati among four people, then writes ¼ on the board and gives the rule for naming parts. Working: she links an everyday experience (sharing food) to a scientific concept (a fraction as equal parts of a whole). This follows Vygotsky: the school concept is built on the child's own experience, and the experience becomes clearer through the concept.
Worked example 3: classify the example
Which is a scientific concept: (a) 'hot', (b) 'photosynthesis', (c) 'mother'? Working: 'photosynthesis' is a concept learnt through teaching, defined within a system of ideas about plants. 'Hot' and 'mother' are learnt from daily life. The answer is (b).
Worked example 4: choosing the teacher's action
A teacher finds that pupils can recite the definition of 'perimeter' but cannot say what it is when given a field. Working: they have a definition without the everyday meaning behind it. A Vygotskian teacher would let pupils walk round the field's edge, measure the boundary, and then link the word to that experience.
Key takeaways: everyday concepts come from experience and grow upwards; scientific concepts come from teaching and come downwards within a system. They need and strengthen each other. Good teaching links school concepts to the child's experience, and uses school concepts to make everyday understanding conscious.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which concepts do children learn from their own daily experience?
- Scientific concepts
- Cultural symbols only
- Everyday (spontaneous) concepts
- Concepts learnt by teachers alone
Show answer
Answer: C. Everyday or spontaneous concepts come from the child's own experience, while scientific concepts are learnt through teaching.
-
2. Which direction of growth is typical of scientific concepts?
- From the definition downwards
- From the concrete example upwards
- From the child's play outwards
- From private speech inwards
Show answer
Answer: A. Scientific concepts are introduced as definitions within a system and worked downwards to examples.
-
3. A child says 'dog' correctly but cannot say what a dog is. What kind of concept is this?
- A scientific concept
- A mathematical rule
- A cultural tool
- An everyday concept
Show answer
Answer: D. The child uses the concept correctly from experience but without a conscious definition, which is typical of an everyday concept.
-
4. Which of these is a scientific concept?
- The idea of a close friend
- The idea of photosynthesis
- The idea of feeling hot
- The idea of a kind mother
Show answer
Answer: B. Photosynthesis is learnt through teaching and defined within a system of ideas. The other examples are learnt mainly from daily life.
-
5. How did Vygotsky view the relation between the two kinds of concepts?
- Each supports and strengthens the other
- Everyday concepts must be removed first
- Scientific concepts are useless without definitions
- They develop separately and never meet
Show answer
Answer: A. He saw them as developing together: experience gives scientific concepts meaning, and scientific concepts make everyday ones conscious.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.