- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Language, private speech and cultural tools
Explain how Vygotsky linked language and thought, what private speech and inner speech are, and what he meant by cultural tools.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Watch a young child building with blocks and you may hear a running commentary: "This one goes here... no, the big one first." Vygotsky took this talk very seriously. For him, language is the most important tool a child uses to think, and this self-talk is a window into how thinking develops.
Language as a tool for thought
Vygotsky argued that thought and language begin with separate roots. A baby can think in simple ways before having words, and can babble before the babbling carries thought. In early childhood the two lines come together: speech becomes a way of thinking, and thinking becomes verbal. From then on, language does not just express ideas; it shapes and organises them. His best-known book on this is usually translated as Thought and Language.
Social speech, private speech and inner speech
| Kind of speech | Who it is for | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| Social speech | Other people | Communicating with others |
| Private speech | The child itself, spoken aloud | Guiding and controlling one's own actions |
| Inner speech | The self, silent | Thinking in words inside the head |
Private speech is talk a child directs at himself or herself, out loud, while doing something. Vygotsky saw it as self-regulating: the child is using words to plan and steer actions, in the same way an adult once guided the child. Over time private speech becomes quieter, turns into mutters and whispers, and finally goes "underground" as inner speech, the silent verbal thinking that adults use.
Vygotsky also observed that children use more private speech when a task is hard. When the task is easy they need less of it; when they struggle, the talk increases because they need more self-guidance.
Cultural tools
Vygotsky stressed that people think with tools their culture provides. Some are physical, like an abacus, a ruler or a calendar. Others are psychological or symbolic tools, such as language, number systems, writing, maps and diagrams. Children are not born with these; they learn them from others, and the tools change how they think. A child who has learnt place value can do sums that would be very hard with fingers alone.
What this means for a teacher
Because private speech helps children control their own actions, a teacher who insists on total silence during difficult work may remove a useful aid. Allowing quiet self-talk, and encouraging children to say the steps of a method aloud while learning it, follows Vygotsky. Teachers can also model thinking aloud themselves, showing pupils how an expert talks through a problem.
Worked example 1: what does this talk show?
Pooja, aged five, is doing a jigsaw puzzle alone. She says, "Corners first. Where's the corner? This one has a straight side... yes." Working: she is speaking aloud, to herself, to guide her own actions. This is private speech, and in Vygotsky's view it is useful self-guidance, not a sign of a problem. A teacher should not stop it.
Worked example 2: easy task versus hard task
In one session, a child sorts coloured beads by colour and works silently. In another, the same child tries a tricky maze and talks to herself throughout. Working: Vygotsky's view predicts more private speech on harder tasks, because the child needs more self-regulation. The maze is harder, so the increase in self-talk is exactly what the theory expects.
Private speech is thinking aloud to guide oneself. It increases when tasks are hard and gradually turns into silent inner speech.
Key takeaways
For Vygotsky, thought and language start separately and then join, after which language organises thinking. Private speech is self-talk that guides actions; it grows into inner speech. Children use more private speech on difficult tasks. Language, number systems, writing and maps are cultural tools that shape thinking. The final teaching lesson puts all of this into the classroom and compares Vygotsky with Piaget.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is private speech in Vygotsky's theory?
- Speech a child directs at himself or herself to guide actions
- Speech used only to tell secrets to friends
- A speech disorder that needs treatment
- Silent reading of a book
Show answer
Answer: A. Private speech is self-directed talk, spoken aloud, that the child uses to plan and control actions.
-
2. What does private speech gradually become?
- Social speech
- Sign language
- Silence with no thinking
- Inner speech
Show answer
Answer: D. Private speech becomes quieter and finally goes underground as inner speech, silent verbal thinking.
-
3. According to Vygotsky, when do children use more private speech?
- When the task is difficult
- When the task is very easy
- Only when other people are listening
- Only when they are tired
Show answer
Answer: A. Harder tasks call for more self-guidance, so private speech increases.
-
4. Which of these is a cultural tool in Vygotsky's sense?
- A sneeze
- Eye colour
- A number system
- Height
Show answer
Answer: C. A number system is a symbolic tool handed down by culture that shapes thinking. The others are biological traits or reflexes.
-
5. How did Vygotsky see the relationship between thought and language?
- They are identical from birth
- They start separately and later join, after which language shapes thought
- Language has no effect on thought
- Thought appears only after a child learns to read
Show answer
Answer: B. Vygotsky held that thought and language have separate roots that merge in early childhood; language then becomes a tool of thinking.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.