• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Kumaoni, Garhwali, Jaunsari and the Eighth Schedule: statement traps

Answer statement questions on the three hill languages, their regions, and the difference between state promotion and constitutional recognition.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Statement questions are the favourite form in this topic. A statement sounds sensible, and the question asks you to say which statement is true. To succeed, you need to be firm on three things: which language belongs to which region, what the Eighth Schedule is, and who can change it.

Region and language, once more

Languages and the traps against them
LanguageRegionCommon false statement
KumaoniKumaon, the eastern region'Kumaoni is the language of Garhwal'
GarhwaliGarhwal, the western region'Garhwali is spoken in Kumaon'
JaunsariJaunsar-Bawar, Dehradun district'Jaunsari is a Kumaon dialect'

Jaunsari is the speech of the Jaunsari people, one of the five Scheduled Tribes of the state. The region has its own songs, dances and fairs, and its chief deity is Mahasu Devta, whose central shrine is at Hanol in Chakrata.

What the Eighth Schedule is

The Eighth Schedule of the Constitution is a list of languages that are recognised by the Constitution. It is linked with Articles 344 and 351, which deal with the Official Language Commission and the development of Hindi. Hindi is in it. Neither Kumaoni nor Garhwali is in it.

Promotion and recognition

  • Promotion by the state
    • Programmes and cultural bodies
    • Books and festivals
    • Teaching in some schools may be encouraged
    • Does not change the Schedule
  • Constitutional recognition
    • Language added to the Eighth Schedule
    • Needs a constitutional amendment
    • Only Parliament can do it
Two different things

Trap 1: who can add a language

A statement says that the State Government or the Vidhan Sabha can add Garhwali to the Eighth Schedule. This is false. The Schedule is a part of the Constitution, and it can be changed only by a constitutional amendment passed by Parliament. The state can only ask for it and promote the language.

Trap 2: promotion and recognition

The state has promoted Kumaoni and Garhwali through local-language programmes and cultural bodies, and supporters have asked for them to be taught in school. A statement like 'because the state promotes Kumaoni, it is in the Eighth Schedule' is false. Promotion is not recognition.

Trap 3: language and tribe

A language is not the same as a tribe. The Jaunsari are a tribe, and Jaunsari is also the name of their speech. The Bhotia are a group of tribes, and the Bhotiya languages are the speeches of those groups. A statement that mixes them, such as 'the Tharu speak a Bhotiya language', should be checked against the region: the Tharu live in the Terai, not in the high valleys.

A method for statement questions

  1. Split the statement into parts.
  2. Check the region first. Kumaon is east, Garhwal is west.
  3. Check the verb. 'Added' or 'recognised' means Parliament; 'promoted' means the state.
  4. Look for words such as 'only', 'all' and 'never', which make a true statement false.
  5. Only then compare with the options.

Worked example 1: two statements

Question: (1) Garhwali is in the Eighth Schedule. (2) Garhwali is a Central Pahari language. Working: Garhwali is not in the Schedule, so 1 is false. It belongs to the Central Pahari group, so 2 is true. Answer: 2 only.

Worked example 2: who has the power

Question: Who can add Kumaoni to the Eighth Schedule? Working: The Schedule is part of the Constitution, which is amended by Parliament. The Chief Minister, the Governor and the High Court do not have this power. Answer: Parliament.

Worked example 3: region trap

Question: Which statement is true? (a) Kumaoni is spoken in Garhwal. (b) Jaunsari is spoken in Jaunsar-Bawar. (c) Garhwali is spoken in Kumaon. Working: Kumaoni belongs to Kumaon, so (a) is false. Garhwali belongs to Garhwal, so (c) is false. Answer: (b).

Kumaoni - Kumaon. Garhwali - Garhwal. Jaunsari - Jaunsar-Bawar. Hindi is in the Eighth Schedule; Kumaoni and Garhwali are not. Only Parliament can add a language.

Key takeaways: Check region before anything else. Promotion is a matter for the state; recognition is a matter for Parliament. Watch for absolute words in statements.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which language is in the Eighth Schedule?

    1. Hindi
    2. Kumaoni
    3. Garhwali
    4. Jaunsari
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Hindi is listed. Neither Kumaoni nor Garhwali is.

  2. 2. Who can add a language to the Eighth Schedule?

    1. The Vidhan Sabha of Uttarakhand
    2. The Governor
    3. The Chief Minister
    4. Parliament, by a constitutional amendment
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Schedule is part of the Constitution and is changed only by Parliament.

  3. 3. Mahasu Devta is linked with:

    1. The Terai
    2. Jaunsar-Bawar
    3. The Johar valley
    4. Rudraprayag
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Mahasu Devta is the chief deity of the Jaunsar-Bawar region.

  4. 4. Which statement is true?

    1. Kumaoni is the speech of Garhwal
    2. Kumaoni is the speech of Kumaon, the eastern region
    3. Kumaoni is a Tibeto-Burman language
    4. Kumaoni is the only official language
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Kumaoni is a Central Pahari language of Kumaon.

  5. 5. The state's promotion of a language means that it is:

    1. Automatically in the Eighth Schedule
    2. Banned in schools
    3. An official language of the Union
    4. Supported by the state but not necessarily in the Eighth Schedule
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Promotion is by the state. Recognition in the Eighth Schedule needs Parliament.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery