- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Fund types and roles: traps, discounts and tracking
Spot the common traps about fund structure, categories and the roles of the AMC, trustees, custodian, SEBI and AMFI, and calculate a closed-ended fund's discount or premium and an index fund's tracking difference.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Definition questions on mutual funds are short, but they are built around a handful of predictable traps: calling AMFI the regulator, treating debt funds as risk-free, assuming a closed-ended fund can be redeemed any day, or thinking an index fund tries to beat its index. This lesson collects those traps and adds the two calculations that go with them. All figures are invented and labelled 'suppose'.
Trap list: roles
- SEBI registers and regulates mutual funds. AMFI is the industry association of AMCs; it is not the regulator.
- The AMC decides what to buy and sell; the custodian holds the securities; they are separate.
- The trustees oversee the AMC on behalf of unit holders; they do not pick investments.
- The sponsor sets up the fund; it does not guarantee returns.
Trap list: structure and category
- An open-ended fund can be bought and redeemed with the fund on any business day; a closed-ended fund generally cannot be redeemed with the fund before maturity, and its units are traded on an exchange.
- A debt fund earns mainly interest and is usually steadier than an equity fund, but its NAV can still fall, for example when interest rates rise or a borrower defaults.
- An index fund aims to match its index, not beat it; an actively managed fund tries to beat a benchmark with no guarantee.
- Structure (open or closed) and category (equity, debt, hybrid, index) are separate: one fund has one of each.
Discount and premium
A closed-ended fund's exchange price is set by buyers and sellers. Discount = (NAV − price) ÷ NAV × 100 when the price is below NAV; premium = (price − NAV) ÷ NAV × 100 when it is above. Divide by the NAV, not by the price.
Tracking difference
An index fund's return is usually a little different from its index's return, because of expenses and small differences in holdings and timing. The tracking difference = fund return − index return, usually a small negative number. A fund that trails its index by 0.5 percentage point has a tracking difference of −0.5.
Worked example 1: a premium
Suppose a closed-ended fund has a NAV of ₹40 and its units trade at ₹42. Working: premium = (42 − 40) ÷ 40 × 100 = 5%. A buyer pays 5% more than the value of the assets behind each unit.
Worked example 2: tracking difference
Suppose an index rises 12% in a year while an index fund that follows it moves from a NAV of ₹50 to ₹55.75. Working: fund return = 5.75 ÷ 50 × 100 = 11.5%. Tracking difference = 11.5 − 12 = −0.5 percentage point.
Worked example 3: who is responsible?
Suppose a fund's securities need to be held safely and settled after each trade: that is the custodian's job. Suppose unit holders' interests need to be protected by checking that the AMC follows the fund's stated objective and the rules: that is the trustees' job, under regulation by SEBI. Suppose an industry-wide investor awareness campaign is run on behalf of all AMCs: that fits AMFI.
How to attack a definition question
Read each option and ask two questions. First, has it given a job to the wrong party? The usual swaps are AMFI for SEBI, the custodian for the AMC, and the trustees for the fund manager. Second, does it promise something no fund promises, such as a guaranteed return, a NAV that cannot fall, or an index fund that will beat its index? An option with either fault is wrong. The option left standing is usually the one that describes a role or a risk modestly and precisely. The same check works for structure: any option that lets a closed-ended fund be redeemed with the fund on any business day, or that fixes the number of units in an open-ended fund, has swapped the two.
SEBI regulates, AMFI represents, AMC manages, custodian holds, trustees oversee. Discount or premium is measured against NAV. Tracking difference = fund return − index return.
Key takeaways: most definition traps swap two roles or make a promise that funds do not make; check every option for those two faults; divide by NAV for a discount or premium; and judge an index fund by how closely it follows its index, not by whether it beats it.
Check your understanding
-
1. Suppose a closed-ended fund has a NAV of ₹80 and its units trade at ₹72. At what discount do they trade?
- 11.1%
- 8%
- 10%
- 90%
Show answer
Answer: C. Discount = (80 − 72) ÷ 80 × 100 = 10%. 11.1% wrongly divides by the price.
-
2. Suppose an index rises 9% and an index fund that follows it moves from a NAV of ₹40 to ₹43.40. By how much did the fund trail the index?
- 0.5 percentage point
- 3.4 percentage points
- 1 percentage point
- It did not trail; it beat the index
Show answer
Answer: A. Fund return = 3.40 ÷ 40 × 100 = 8.5%. Trail = 9 − 8.5 = 0.5 percentage point.
-
3. Which statement correctly describes SEBI and AMFI?
- AMFI regulates mutual funds; SEBI is the industry association
- Both are industry associations with no regulatory role
- AMFI regulates the stock exchanges; SEBI regulates only banks
- SEBI regulates mutual funds; AMFI is the industry association of AMCs
Show answer
Answer: D. SEBI is the regulator of the securities market and of mutual funds; AMFI represents the industry and is not a regulator.
-
4. Which statement about debt funds is correct?
- Their NAV can never fall because they hold bonds
- They earn mainly interest and are usually steadier than equity funds, but their NAV can still fall
- They guarantee a fixed return like a deposit
- They invest mainly in company shares
Show answer
Answer: B. Debt funds hold bonds and similar instruments. They are usually steadier but carry risks such as interest-rate changes and defaults.
-
5. An investor in a closed-ended fund needs her money before the maturity date. What can she usually do?
- Redeem her units with the fund at NAV on any business day
- Ask AMFI to buy back her units
- Nothing at all until maturity, under any circumstances
- Sell her units on the stock exchange at the market price
Show answer
Answer: D. Closed-ended units are usually listed, so an investor can sell to another investor on the exchange, at a price that may differ from NAV.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.