- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
SIP practice: average cost, break-even and speed methods
Work out SIP units and average cost quickly, use the harmonic-mean shortcut for equal instalments, find the break-even NAV and the gain or loss on a SIP holding.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The foundation course explained rupee-cost averaging. Practice questions on SIPs come in a few standard shapes: find total units, find the average cost, find the gain at a given NAV, or find the NAV below which the investor is in loss. This lesson gives a quick method for each and the traps to avoid. All NAVs are invented and labelled 'suppose'; nothing here is advice to use or avoid a SIP.
Method 1: a units table
Write the NAVs in a row and the units bought under each: units = instalment ÷ NAV. Choose to divide the instalment by each NAV directly; when the NAVs are factors of the instalment the units come out whole. Total units is the sum; total invested is instalment × number of instalments.
Method 2: the harmonic-mean shortcut
With equal instalments, the average cost per unit = number of instalments ÷ (1/NAV1 + 1/NAV2 + ...), which is the harmonic mean of the NAVs. For two NAVs a and b it becomes 2ab ÷ (a + b). The instalment amount cancels, so you do not even need it. The harmonic mean is always at most the simple average, which is the arithmetic behind rupee-cost averaging.
Method 3: break-even and gain
The SIP holding is in profit when the current NAV is above the average cost per unit and in loss when it is below. So the break-even NAV = average cost per unit. The gain = total units × current NAV − total invested, and as a percentage, (current NAV − average cost) ÷ average cost × 100.
Worked example 1: five instalments
Suppose Rekha invests ₹6,000 a month for five months at NAVs of ₹12, ₹15, ₹20, ₹30 and ₹60. Working: units = 500, 400, 300, 200 and 100, a total of 1,500 units for ₹30,000. Average cost = 30,000 ÷ 1,500 = ₹20. Shortcut check: 1/12 + 1/15 + 1/20 + 1/30 + 1/60 = (5 + 4 + 3 + 2 + 1) ÷ 60 = 15/60 = 1/4, and 5 ÷ (1/4) = 20. The simple average of the NAVs is 137 ÷ 5 = ₹27.40, the trap answer.
Worked example 2: value and break-even
Continue: suppose the NAV is now ₹30. Working: value = 1,500 × 30 = ₹45,000 against ₹30,000 invested, a gain of ₹15,000, or (30 − 20) ÷ 20 × 100 = 50%. Her break-even NAV is ₹20: at any NAV below ₹20 the holding would show a loss, even though the last NAV she bought at was ₹60.
Worked example 3: two NAVs
Suppose equal instalments are made at NAVs of ₹20 and ₹30. Average cost = 2 × 20 × 30 ÷ (20 + 30) = 1,200 ÷ 50 = ₹24, not the ₹25 simple average.
Average cost = total invested ÷ total units = harmonic mean of the NAVs for equal instalments (two NAVs: 2ab ÷ (a + b)). Break-even NAV = average cost.
Key takeaways: never average the NAVs; use a units table or the harmonic-mean shortcut; profit or loss depends on the current NAV against the average cost, not against the last purchase NAV; and when all NAVs are the same, average cost simply equals that NAV.
Check your understanding
-
1. Suppose Om invests ₹1,500 a month for four months at NAVs of ₹15, ₹25, ₹30 and ₹50. What is his average cost per unit?
- ₹30
- ₹24
- ₹27.50
- ₹25
Show answer
Answer: D. Units = 100 + 60 + 50 + 30 = 240 for ₹6,000. Average cost = 6,000 ÷ 240 = ₹25. ₹30 is the simple average of the NAVs.
-
2. Suppose equal SIP instalments are made at NAVs of ₹20 and ₹30. What is the average cost per unit?
- ₹25
- ₹26
- ₹24
- ₹20
Show answer
Answer: C. Average cost = 2 × 20 × 30 ÷ (20 + 30) = 1,200 ÷ 50 = ₹24.
-
3. Suppose a SIP holding has 1,200 units bought for ₹30,000 in total, and the NAV is now ₹22. What is the gain or loss?
- A gain of 12%
- A loss of 3%
- A gain of 10%
- A loss of 12%
Show answer
Answer: D. Average cost = 30,000 ÷ 1,200 = ₹25. Value = 1,200 × 22 = ₹26,400. Loss = 3,600 ÷ 30,000 = 12%.
-
4. Suppose Jaya invests ₹1,200 a month for three months at NAVs of ₹24, ₹40 and ₹60. Below what NAV would her holding show a loss?
- ₹41.33
- ₹40
- ₹36
- ₹24
Show answer
Answer: C. Units = 50 + 30 + 20 = 100 for ₹3,600, so average cost = ₹36, the break-even NAV. ₹41.33 is the simple average of the NAVs.
-
5. Which statement about a SIP's average cost is correct?
- It is always exactly the simple average of the NAVs
- It is below the simple average of the NAVs only when those NAVs differ
- It is always above the simple average of the NAVs
- It equals the NAV of the last instalment
Show answer
Answer: B. With equal instalments, average cost is the harmonic mean, which equals the simple average only when all NAVs are equal and is lower otherwise.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.