• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Several purchases, partial redemptions and switches: mixed problems

Find the units and average cost after purchases at different NAVs, work out which units a partial redemption uses first, apply an exit load to only those units, and convert a switch between funds.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Real investors buy a fund more than once and sell only part of the holding. Exam problems copy this: two or three purchases at different NAVs, then a partial redemption with an exit load. The method is always the same three steps: list the purchases, decide which units are sold, then apply the charge. All numbers are invented.

Step 1: units and average cost

Units from each purchase = amount ÷ NAV on that day. Total units is the sum, and the average cost per unit = total invested ÷ total units. As with a SIP, this is not the simple average of the NAVs unless the number of units bought each time is equal. The holding is in profit if the current NAV is above the average cost, and the percentage gain = (current NAV − average cost) ÷ average cost × 100.

Step 2: which units are sold first

When part of a holding is redeemed, mutual funds treat the oldest units as sold first. This is the first in, first out rule (FIFO). It matters for the exit load, which depends on how long each unit has been held: the oldest units have usually passed the exit-load period, so the load falls only on the units that are still too young.

Step 3: apply the charge to the young units only

Load = load rate × NAV × (number of units that are inside the period). Do not apply the load to the whole redemption, and do not apply it to all the young units if only some of them are redeemed.

Switches

A switch moves money from one scheme of a fund house to another. It is a redemption from the first scheme followed by a purchase in the second: units of B = (units of A redeemed × NAV of A) ÷ NAV of B, ignoring any load or tax.

Worked examples

Example 1. Suppose Anita invests ₹30,000 at a NAV of ₹25 and later ₹36,000 at a NAV of ₹30. Units = 30,000 ÷ 25 = 1,200 and 36,000 ÷ 30 = 1,200, so total units are 2,400 for ₹66,000. Average cost = 66,000 ÷ 2,400 = ₹27.50. At a NAV of ₹33 the holding is worth 2,400 × 33 = ₹79,200, a gain of 79,200 − 66,000 = ₹13,200, which is 13,200 ÷ 66,000 × 100 = 20%. Check: (33 − 27.50) ÷ 27.50 = 20%.

Example 2. Continue Example 1. The first purchase is two years old and the second only five months old. Suppose a 1% exit load applies to units redeemed within one year. Anita redeems 1,500 units at ₹33. By FIFO the first 1,200 units (the old purchase) are sold first, with no load, and the other 300 come from the young purchase. Redemption value = 1,500 × 33 = ₹49,500. Load = 1% × (300 × 33) = 1% × 9,900 = ₹99. She receives 49,500 − 99 = ₹49,401. Charging 1% on the whole ₹49,500 would give ₹495, which is wrong.

Example 3. Suppose Rohan switches ₹10,000 worth of units from scheme A (NAV ₹25) into scheme B (NAV ₹40), ignoring all charges. He redeems 10,000 ÷ 25 = 400 units of A and buys 10,000 ÷ 40 = 250 units of B. The rupee value stays ₹10,000; only the number of units changes, because the NAVs differ.

Quick map
QuestionFirst move
Total units after several purchasesAmount ÷ NAV for each, then add
Average costTotal invested ÷ total units
Which units are sold firstThe oldest (FIFO)
Exit load on a partial saleOnly on units still inside the period
SwitchRedeem at A's NAV, buy at B's NAV

Divide each purchase by its own NAV; total invested over total units gives the average cost; sell the oldest units first; charge the load only on units still inside the period.

Key takeaways. Never take the simple average of NAVs unless equal units were bought. FIFO means a partial redemption uses the oldest units first. The exit load falls only on units held for less than the stated period. A switch is a redemption plus a fresh purchase, so the number of units changes with the NAV even though the value does not.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Suppose Nisha buys ₹24,000 of units at a NAV of ₹24 and another ₹24,000 at a NAV of ₹48. What is her average cost per unit?

    1. ₹36
    2. ₹32
    3. ₹30
    4. ₹40
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Units = 24,000 ÷ 24 = 1,000 and 24,000 ÷ 48 = 500, a total of 1,500 units for ₹48,000. Average cost = 48,000 ÷ 1,500 = ₹32, not the simple average of ₹36.

  2. 2. Suppose Jayant holds 800 units bought two years ago and 600 units bought four months ago. A 1% exit load applies within one year. He redeems 1,000 units at a NAV of ₹40. What is the exit load, using FIFO?

    1. ₹80
    2. ₹240
    3. ₹400
    4. ₹120
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The first 800 units (the old ones) go without load. The other 200 units come from the young purchase: 1% × 200 × 40 = ₹80.

  3. 3. Suppose Kavita switches ₹15,000 from scheme A (NAV ₹30) into scheme B (NAV ₹25), ignoring charges. How many units of B does she receive?

    1. 500 units
    2. 450 units
    3. 600 units
    4. 360 units
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Units of B = 15,000 ÷ 25 = 600. The value stays ₹15,000, but B's lower NAV gives more units.

  4. 4. A holding has an average cost of ₹40 per unit and the NAV is ₹46. What is the percentage gain?

    1. 13%
    2. 6%
    3. 18%
    4. 15%
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Gain per unit = 46 − 40 = ₹6. Percentage gain = 6 ÷ 40 × 100 = 15%. Dividing by 46 would wrongly give about 13%.

  5. 5. When some units of a fund are redeemed, which units are treated as sold first?

    1. The newest units
    2. The units chosen at random
    3. The units with the highest cost
    4. The oldest units
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Funds use first in, first out (FIFO): the oldest units are redeemed first. That is why an exit load often falls on only part of a redemption.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery