- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Crossings in practice: kinds, who may cross, and traps
Distinguish general, special, account payee and not negotiable crossings by their effect, state who may add or change a crossing, and avoid the common statement traps.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The foundation course introduced the crossing of cheques. Exam questions go further: they ask who may cross a cheque, whether a crossing can be changed, and what exactly 'not negotiable' and 'account payee' do. This lesson collects the rules and the traps.
Kinds of crossing and their effect
| Crossing | Form | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| General | Two parallel transverse lines, with or without '& Co.' or 'not negotiable' | Paid only to a banker, not over the counter |
| Special | The name of a banker added, with or without lines | Paid only to the banker named |
| Account payee | 'A/c Payee' added within the crossing | By banking practice, credited only to the payee's own account |
| Not negotiable | 'Not negotiable' added to a crossing | Can still be transferred, but the transferee gets no better title than the transferor had |
Two points carry most marks. First, special crossing does not need lines: the banker's name is enough. Second, 'not negotiable' does not mean 'not transferable'. The cheque can still be passed on; what is lost is the special protection of a holder in due course, so if an earlier title was defective, the later holder's title is equally defective.
Who may cross, and how a crossing may change
- The drawer may cross a cheque generally or specially.
- Where a cheque is uncrossed, the holder may cross it generally or specially.
- Where it is crossed generally, the holder may cross it specially.
- Where it is crossed generally or specially, the holder may add the words 'not negotiable'.
- A banker to whom a cheque is crossed specially may cross it specially again to another banker, as its agent for collection.
Notice the direction. A crossing can be made stronger: open to general, general to special, adding 'not negotiable'. A holder cannot make it weaker, for example by turning a special crossing back into a general one or an open cheque.
Worked example 1: what may the holder do?
Vinita holds a cheque crossed generally. Which of these may she do: (a) write her bank's name across it; (b) add 'not negotiable'; (c) strike out the lines to cash it at the counter? Working: (a) turns a general crossing into a special one: allowed. (b) adding 'not negotiable' to a crossed cheque: allowed. (c) removing a crossing weakens it: not allowed for a holder. Answer: (a) and (b) only.
Worked example 2: the not negotiable trap
Waqar draws a cheque crossed 'not negotiable' in favour of Yamini. It is stolen from Yamini, and the thief passes it to Zubin, who pays full value in good faith. Does Zubin get a good title? Working: without the words 'not negotiable', Zubin might have been a holder in due course with a good title. But a 'not negotiable' crossing means he gets no better title than the thief, who had none. Answer: no; Zubin's title is as defective as the thief's, and Yamini's claim prevails.
Worked example 3: an account payee cheque
Anand draws a cheque in favour of Bharti, crossed generally with 'A/c Payee' written between the lines. Bharti endorses it to her friend Chhavi, who deposits it in her own account. What should the collecting bank do? Working: the cheque is crossed, so it cannot be paid in cash over the counter. 'A/c Payee' directs, by banking practice, that the money be credited only to the payee's account. The payee is Bharti, not Chhavi. Answer: the bank should credit the money only to Bharti's account; it should not collect it for Chhavi's account. The endorsement does not change this.
Compare the three crossings in this way. A general crossing answers the question 'through whom?' with 'through any banker'. A special crossing answers it with 'through this banker'. An account payee crossing answers a different question, 'into whose account?', with 'the payee's'. A 'not negotiable' crossing answers yet another question, 'what title does a transferee get?', with 'no better than the transferor's'. Asking which question a crossing answers is the quickest way to keep them apart in a statement question.
Statement traps
- 'A not negotiable cheque cannot be transferred.' Wrong: it can; only the protection is lost.
- 'Special crossing must have two parallel lines.' Wrong: the banker's name is enough.
- 'Account payee crossing is defined in the Negotiable Instruments Act.' Wrong: it is a banking practice.
- 'A holder may convert a special crossing into a general one.' Wrong: a holder may only make a crossing stronger.
- 'Crossing changes the payee.' Wrong: it changes only how payment is made.
General: through a banker. Special: through the named banker, lines optional. Account payee: into the payee's account, by practice. Not negotiable: transferable, but no better title. A holder may strengthen a crossing, never weaken it.
Key takeaways: learn each crossing by its effect; 'not negotiable' removes the protection of a holder in due course without stopping transfer; the drawer and the holder may cross, and a holder may only strengthen a crossing; and account payee rests on banking practice.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is the effect of a 'not negotiable' crossing?
- The cheque cannot be transferred at all
- The cheque can be cashed at the counter
- The cheque becomes payable to bearer
- The cheque can be transferred, but the transferee gets no better title than the transferor
Show answer
Answer: D. 'Not negotiable' removes the protection of a holder in due course; transfer is still possible.
-
2. A cheque has only the name of a bank written across its face, without lines. What is it?
- A specially crossed cheque
- An open cheque
- A generally crossed cheque
- An invalid cheque
Show answer
Answer: A. For a special crossing the banker's name is enough; lines are not required.
-
3. Which change may a holder make to a generally crossed cheque?
- Remove the crossing
- Cross it specially to a bank
- Change the payee's name
- Remove the drawer's signature
Show answer
Answer: B. A holder may strengthen a crossing, for example from general to special, but may not remove it.
-
4. Which statement is correct?
- A not negotiable cheque cannot be transferred
- A holder may convert a special crossing into a general one
- Crossing a cheque changes its payee
- Account payee crossing is a banking practice that sends money to the payee's own account
Show answer
Answer: D. Account payee rests on practice; the other statements reverse the rules.
-
5. A cheque crossed 'not negotiable' is stolen and passed to an honest buyer who pays full value. What is the buyer's title?
- No better than the thief's, so it is defective
- A good title as a holder in due course
- A good title because he paid full value
- A title better than the original payee's
Show answer
Answer: A. A 'not negotiable' crossing means a transferee gets no better title than the person who passed it.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.