- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Holder in due course, dishonour and mixed problems
Test a holder against the conditions for holder in due course, follow the consequences of dishonour through a chain, and solve mixed problems across the whole course.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The last teaching lesson brings together the two ideas that decide who finally bears a loss: whether a holder is a holder in due course, and what happens when an instrument is dishonoured. It ends with mixed problems in the style of exam statement questions.
The holder in due course test
A holder is a holder in due course only if all of these are true. Fail one and the protection is lost:
- He is a holder: entitled in his own name to the instrument, by delivery (bearer) or endorsement and delivery (order).
- He obtained it for consideration, that is, he gave value. A gift does not qualify.
- He obtained it before the amount became payable, so not after it was due.
- He had no sufficient cause to believe that there was any defect in the title of the person who passed it to him.
The protection matters when an earlier title was defective, for example where the instrument was obtained by fraud. Then a holder in due course has a good title, while a mere holder has only the title of the person before him. Remember too from lesson 4 that a 'not negotiable' crossing takes this protection away.
Worked example 1: four holders
Each receives a bill payable to bearer that had been obtained by fraud earlier in the chain. Who is a holder in due course? (a) Anil, who paid full value a week before it was due and suspected nothing. (b) Bindu, who received it as a birthday gift before it was due. (c) Chirag, who paid full value two days after it was due. (d) Divya, who paid full value before it was due but had been told it was obtained by fraud. Working: (a) value, in time, no suspicion: yes. (b) no consideration: no. (c) taken after it was payable: no. (d) had cause to believe there was a defect: no. Answer: only Anil.
Dishonour and its consequences
A bill may be dishonoured by non-acceptance (the drawee refuses to accept) or by non-payment; a note or cheque only by non-payment. On dishonour, the holder can look to the parties liable: the drawer, and every endorser who did not write 'sans recourse'. An endorser who pays the holder can in turn look to the parties before him. For cheques, the Act also treats dishonour for insufficiency of funds, where the conditions laid down in section 138 are met, as an offence. The conditions and consequences are outside this course.
Worked example 2: a dishonoured cheque in a chain
Esha draws a cheque on her bank in favour of Firoz. Firoz endorses it in full to Gauri; Gauri endorses it 'sans recourse' to Hemant; Hemant endorses it in full to Ira. The bank returns it for insufficient funds. Against whom can Ira proceed? Working: the drawer Esha is liable. Firoz endorsed without excluding liability: liable. Gauri wrote 'sans recourse': not liable to later holders. Hemant endorsed without exclusion: liable. Answer: Esha, Firoz and Hemant, but not Gauri. Ira's claim on the cheque runs against these parties; the bank simply had no funds of Esha's to pay from.
Worked example 3: a mixed statement question
Consider: (1) A bill can be dishonoured by non-acceptance. (2) A gift recipient of a cheque is a holder in due course if he took it in good faith. (3) Section 138 relates to the dishonour of cheques for insufficient funds. Which are correct? Working: (1) true. (2) false: a gift gives no consideration. (3) true. Answer: 1 and 3 only.
Holder in due course = holder + for value + before it was payable + no cause to suspect a defect. On dishonour the holder turns to the drawer and every endorser who did not write 'sans recourse'.
Key takeaways: apply the holder in due course test as a checklist; a gift, late taking or knowledge of a defect each removes the protection; non-acceptance applies only to bills; liability on dishonour runs back through the chain except for sans recourse endorsers; and section 138 is the cheque-dishonour section, to be named but not elaborated here.
Check your understanding
-
1. Pallavi receives a bill as a gift from her uncle before it is due, in good faith. Is she a holder in due course?
- Yes, because she acted in good faith
- No, because she gave no consideration
- Yes, because she took it before it was due
- No, because a bill can never have a holder in due course
Show answer
Answer: B. Consideration is one of the conditions; a gift gives none, so she is only a holder.
-
2. Which holder is a holder in due course?
- One who paid value before maturity with no reason to suspect a defect
- One who paid value after the bill was due
- One who knew the bill had been stolen
- One who found the bill on the road
Show answer
Answer: A. All conditions must hold: value, before it was payable and no cause to suspect a defect.
-
3. A cheque passes from the drawer to Rina, from Rina to Sunil 'sans recourse', from Sunil to Tanu in full. It is dishonoured for insufficient funds. Against whom can Tanu proceed?
- The drawer, Rina and Sunil
- The drawer only
- Rina and Sunil only
- The drawer and Sunil
Show answer
Answer: D. Rina's endorsement was 'sans recourse', so she is not liable to later holders; the drawer and Sunil are.
-
4. Which statement is correct?
- A cheque can be dishonoured by non-acceptance
- A bill can be dishonoured only by non-payment
- A promissory note needs acceptance by the payee
- A promissory note can be dishonoured only by non-payment
Show answer
Answer: D. Only bills need acceptance; notes and cheques are dishonoured by non-payment.
-
5. Consider: (1) A holder who took a bill after it was due is a holder in due course. (2) A 'not negotiable' crossing removes the protection of a holder in due course. (3) The drawer of a dishonoured cheque is liable to the holder. Which are correct?
- 1 and 2 only
- 2 and 3 only
- 1 and 3 only
- 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: B. Statement 1 is false: taking after the due date rules out holder in due course. Statements 2 and 3 are true.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.