- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Valid or not: testing the wording of an instrument
Run a five-gate check on the wording of a document to decide whether it is a valid promissory note, bill or cheque, and avoid the classic traps about conditions, amounts and acknowledgements.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The foundation course listed the essential features of a negotiable instrument. Exam questions test them through wording: a short document is quoted and you must say whether it is a valid promissory note, bill of exchange or cheque. The traps are in single words such as 'if', 'and', 'after deducting' or 'I.O.U.'. This lesson gives a fixed check and works through the typical traps. Names and amounts are invented.
The five-gate check
- Writing and signature. Is it written and signed by the person promising or ordering?
- Promise or order. Is there an actual promise to pay (note) or an order to pay (bill, cheque)? A bare statement of a debt is neither.
- Unconditional. Is payment free of any condition that may never happen?
- Certain sum of money only. Is the amount definite, and is it money and nothing else?
- Certain payee. Is the person to be paid certain (or, for a bill or cheque, the bearer)?
Stop at the first gate the document fails. Then, if it passes all five, name the instrument: a promise is a promissory note; an order is a bill of exchange; an order drawn on a banker and payable on demand is a cheque.
Trap 1: condition or certain event?
A promise to pay 'after my marriage with C' is conditional, because the marriage may never take place. But a promise to pay 'three months after the death of my father' is not conditional. Death is certain to happen, though its time is uncertain, and the Act treats payment on the lapse of a period after an event that is certain to happen as unconditional. The test is not 'is the date known?' but 'is the event certain to happen?'
Trap 2: acknowledgement is not a promise
'Mr Bose, I.O.U. ₹1,000' records a debt but contains no promise to pay, so it fails gate 2 and is not a promissory note. Look for the act of promising or ordering, not merely the mention of money owed.
Trap 3: an amount that can change
'I promise to pay ₹5,000 and all other sums which shall be due to you' and 'I promise to pay ₹5,000, first deducting any money you may owe me' both fail gate 4: the final amount cannot be known from the document. A promise to pay '₹5,000 and to deliver my scooter' fails because it is not money only.
Worked example 1: four documents
Which are valid promissory notes? (a) 'I promise to pay Nisha or order ₹8,000', signed. (b) 'I promise to pay Nisha ₹8,000 seven days after my marriage with Om', signed. (c) 'Nisha, I.O.U. ₹8,000', signed. (d) 'I promise to pay Nisha ₹8,000 one month after my uncle's death', signed. Working: (a) passes all five gates: valid. (b) marriage may never happen: conditional, fails gate 3. (c) no promise: fails gate 2. (d) death is certain to happen: unconditional; all gates passed: valid. Answer: (a) and (d).
Worked example 2: name the instrument
Classify each, if valid: (a) Ruchi signs, addressed to her bank: 'Pay Sameer or order ₹4,500.' (b) Ruchi signs, addressed to Tanvi: 'Pay Sameer or order ₹4,500 sixty days after date.' (c) Ruchi signs, addressed to her bank: 'Pay Sameer ₹4,500 if he passes his examination.' Working: (a) an order, on a banker, no time stated, so payable on demand: cheque. (b) an order to a person, payable at a stated time: bill of exchange. (c) the payment depends on passing an examination, which may not happen: conditional, so not a valid instrument at all. Answer: (a) cheque, (b) bill of exchange, (c) not valid.
Five gates: written and signed; a promise or an order; unconditional; a certain sum of money only; a certain payee. An event certain to happen, such as a death, does not make it conditional; one that may never happen, such as a marriage, does.
Key takeaways: test gates in order and stop at the first failure; 'I.O.U.' alone is not a promise; amounts that depend on other debts or deductions are uncertain; anything besides money breaks the money-only rule; and a death-linked date is valid while a marriage-linked one is conditional.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'I promise to pay Kunal ₹6,000 two months after the death of my grandfather', signed. Is this a valid promissory note?
- No, because the date of payment is unknown
- No, because it mentions a death
- Yes, because death is certain to happen even though its time is uncertain
- No, because it has no drawee
Show answer
Answer: C. Payment after an event certain to happen is not conditional, so the note is valid.
-
2. 'Mr Lal, I.O.U. ₹3,000', signed. Why is this not a promissory note?
- It is not signed
- The amount is uncertain
- It contains no promise to pay
- It is for something other than money
Show answer
Answer: C. An I.O.U. records a debt but does not promise payment, so it fails the promise test.
-
3. Which wording is a valid promissory note?
- 'I promise to pay Manju ₹9,000 after first deducting what she owes me', signed
- 'I promise to pay Manju ₹9,000 and my old radio', signed
- 'I promise to pay Manju or order ₹9,000', signed
- 'I promise to pay Manju ₹9,000 if my shop makes a profit', signed
Show answer
Answer: C. Only the plain promise to pay Manju or order ₹9,000 is unconditional, for a certain sum and for money only.
-
4. A signed order addressed to a bank reads 'Pay Pritam or order ₹2,000'. No date for payment is stated. What is it?
- A promissory note
- A cheque
- A bill of exchange that cannot be a cheque
- Not a negotiable instrument
Show answer
Answer: B. An order on a banker with no time stated is payable on demand, so it is a cheque.
-
5. 'I promise to pay Rekha ₹7,000 seven days after my marriage with Sohan', signed. Which gate does it fail?
- Writing and signature
- Unconditional
- Certain payee
- Money only
Show answer
Answer: B. The marriage may never take place, so the promise is conditional.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.