- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Photosynthesis: experiments, pigments and limiting factors
Match the classic experiments to their findings, separate pigments by chromatography, apply Blackman's law and the compensation point to data, and calculate glucose and oxygen from the balanced equation.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Photosynthesis has a long history of experiments, and examiners like to ask who showed what. It also has quantitative questions: how much oxygen, how much glucose, and what limits the rate. Lesson 4 covered the photosystems and the counts; this lesson covers the evidence, the pigments and the factors.
Experiments in the right order
| Scientist or experiment | What it showed |
|---|---|
| Priestley | Plants restore the air that a burning candle or a breathing animal has made unfit |
| Ingenhousz | Sunlight is needed for this, and only the green parts of a plant do it |
| Sachs | Green parts make glucose, stored as starch (shown by an iodine test on leaves) |
| Engelmann | Using a prism, algae and oxygen-seeking bacteria, he found photosynthesis works best in the blue and red regions of light |
| van Niel | In bacteria that use hydrogen sulphide, the hydrogen donor is not water; so in green plants the oxygen released comes from water, not from carbon dioxide |
| Calvin | With radioactive carbon-14 and the alga Chlorella, he traced the path of carbon into sugar |
The overall equation, with water on both sides to show where the oxygen comes from, is 6CO2 + 12H2O → C6H12O6 + 6O2 + 6H2O. The simplified form is 6CO2 + 6H2O → C6H12O6 + 6O2.
Pigments and chromatography
Leaves contain chlorophyll a (blue-green), chlorophyll b (yellow-green), xanthophylls (yellow) and carotenoids (yellow to orange). Only chlorophyll a forms the reaction centre of the photosystem. The others are accessory pigments: they absorb light at other wavelengths and pass the energy to chlorophyll a, and they protect it from damage by strong light. An absorption spectrum shows which wavelengths a pigment takes in; an action spectrum shows how well each wavelength drives photosynthesis. The action spectrum follows the absorption of chlorophyll a closely, with peaks in the blue and red, and is broadened by the accessory pigments.
In paper chromatography of a leaf extract the pigments rise by different amounts. Order from the top: carotene (orange-yellow), xanthophyll (yellow), chlorophyll a (blue-green) and chlorophyll b (yellow-green) lowest. The ratio of the distance moved by a pigment to the distance moved by the solvent front is its Rf value.
Limiting factors
Blackman's law of limiting factors: when a process depends on several factors, its rate is limited by the factor that is nearest its minimum. If light is plentiful but carbon dioxide is scarce, adding light does nothing; adding CO2 raises the rate. The main factors are light, carbon dioxide, temperature and water. The light compensation point is the light intensity at which the amount of CO2 used in photosynthesis equals the amount released by respiration, so there is no net gas exchange.
Worked example 1: gross and net
A leaf in darkness takes in 4 units of oxygen per hour for respiration (illustrative). In weak light, its net release of oxygen is zero. In bright light it releases 6 units net. Step 1: gross = net + respiration. Step 2: in weak light gross = 0 + 4 = 4 units, so this is the compensation point. Step 3: in bright light gross = 6 + 4 = 10 units. Net values alone would have hidden that the leaf is making 10 units.
Worked example 2: amounts from the equation
How much glucose and oxygen form from 264 g of carbon dioxide? Step 1: 6CO2 has a mass of 6 × 44 = 264 g. Step 2: this gives one glucose, 180 g, and 6O2, 6 × 32 = 192 g. Step 3: check by mass: 264 + 108 (6 H2O) = 372, and 180 + 192 = 372. It balances.
Worked example 3: Rf value
The solvent front travels 12 cm and a yellow pigment travels 9 cm. Rf = 9 ÷ 12 = 0.75. A pigment that moved 4 cm would have Rf = 4 ÷ 12 = 0.33, so it sits lower on the paper.
Gross photosynthesis = net photosynthesis + respiration. At the compensation point net exchange is zero, not photosynthesis.
Key takeaways. Know who showed what, in order of the questions. Chlorophyll a is the only pigment in the reaction centre. Blackman's law says the scarcest factor sets the rate. The compensation point is a balance of photosynthesis and respiration. Check equation-based answers by conservation of mass.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which pigment is found at the top of a chromatogram of leaf extract?
- Chlorophyll b
- Carotene
- Chlorophyll a
- Xanthophyll
Show answer
Answer: B. Carotene moves farthest with the solvent, so it is highest on the paper. Chlorophyll b moves least and is at the bottom.
-
2. Engelmann's experiment with algae and bacteria helped to show:
- That carbon dioxide itself gives rise to oxygen
- That the oxygen released comes from water
- That blue and red light work best
- The path of carbon in the Calvin cycle
Show answer
Answer: C. Oxygen-seeking bacteria gathered where the alga released most oxygen, in the blue and red regions of the spectrum. This was an early action spectrum.
-
3. A leaf respires and uses 3 units of oxygen in the dark. In light its net release is 5 units. What is the gross release of oxygen?
- 2 units
- 5 units
- 8 units
- 15 units
Show answer
Answer: C. Gross = net + respiration = 5 + 3 = 8 units. Subtracting would give 2, which is wrong.
-
4. According to Blackman's law of limiting factors, if light is plentiful and the rate rises when CO2 is raised, then:
- CO2 was the factor limiting the rate
- Light is the limiting factor
- Temperature is the limiting factor
- Water is the limiting factor
Show answer
Answer: A. The rate is controlled by the factor nearest its minimum. Since raising CO2 raised the rate, CO2 had been limiting.
-
5. How much oxygen is released when 180 g of glucose is made in photosynthesis (6O2 per glucose)?
- 96 g
- 288 g
- 384 g
- 192 g
Show answer
Answer: D. One glucose (180 g) forms with 6O2, which is 6 × 32 = 192 g of oxygen.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.