• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Water potential problems: solving osmosis questions quickly

Use the relation water potential = solute potential + pressure potential to predict the direction of water flow between cells and solutions, and avoid the sign traps.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Competitive exams test water relations in two ways: with definitions that sound alike (osmosis, imbibition, plasmolysis, turgor) and with short calculations on water potential. The calculations are easy once you are fluent with one equation and with negative numbers. This lesson gives you that fluency, a three-step method for every question, and a list of the traps that catch hurried candidates.

The one equation

Water potential (ψw) = solute potential (ψs) + pressure potential (ψp). Pure water at normal pressure has ψw = 0. Solute potential is always zero or negative, because dissolving something lowers the free energy of water; the more concentrated the solution, the more negative ψs. Pressure potential in a living plant cell is usually positive, because the swollen protoplast presses on the wall (turgor pressure). In a xylem vessel under tension, ψp can be negative. All values are usually given in megapascals (MPa).

Three states to remember
State of the cellψpψw
Flaccid / at incipient plasmolysis0Equal to ψs
Partly turgidPositive, less than |ψs|Negative
Fully turgid (in pure water)Equal to −ψs0

The three-step method

  1. Step 1: find ψw of each cell or solution. For an open solution in a beaker, ψp = 0, so ψw = ψs.
  2. Step 2: compare. The less negative value is the higher water potential.
  3. Step 3: water moves from higher to lower ψw, and keeps moving until the two are equal.

Worked example 1: a cell in a solution

A cell has ψs = −1.2 MPa and ψp = +0.4 MPa. It is placed in a sucrose solution of ψs = −0.6 MPa. Step 1: ψw(cell) = −1.2 + 0.4 = −0.8 MPa; ψw(solution) = −0.6 MPa, since the open solution has no pressure. Step 2: −0.6 is higher than −0.8. Step 3: water moves from the solution into the cell. The cell gains water, its turgor rises, and ψp increases until ψw(cell) reaches −0.6 MPa. Trap: many candidates compare −1.2 with −0.6 and forget to add the pressure potential; here the answer would not change, but in the next example it does.

Worked example 2: a three-cell chain

Cells A, B and C lie in a row. A: ψs = −0.9, ψp = +0.5. B: ψs = −0.7, ψp = +0.2. C: ψs = −1.0, ψp = +0.7 (all MPa). Step 1: ψw(A) = −0.4, ψw(B) = −0.5, ψw(C) = −0.3. Step 2: order from highest to lowest: C (−0.3) > A (−0.4) > B (−0.5). Step 3: water moves C → A, C → B and A → B; B gains water from both neighbours. Notice that C has the most negative solute potential yet the highest water potential, because of its large turgor pressure. Judging by ψs alone would give exactly the wrong answer.

Worked example 3: when does plasmolysis begin?

A cell with ψs = −0.8 MPa is placed in solutions of ψ = −0.5, −0.8 and −1.1 MPa. In −0.5 the cell gains water; ψw(cell) can rise up to −0.5. In −0.8, a cell already at ψp = 0 is in balance: this is incipient plasmolysis, the point at which the membrane just starts to leave the wall. In −1.1 water leaves and the cell is clearly plasmolysed. Solutions with the same ψ as the cell sap are called isotonic; weaker ones are hypotonic; stronger ones hypertonic.

Definition traps

  • Osmosis needs a selectively permeable membrane; imbibition does not (dry seeds, wood).
  • Diffusion and osmosis are passive; neither needs ATP.
  • Plasmolysis is reversible if the cell is returned to water soon enough (deplasmolysis).
  • Wilting of a whole plant is loss of turgor, not necessarily plasmolysis of every cell.
  • The cell wall is freely permeable; the cell membrane and the vacuole membrane (tonoplast) are the selectively permeable barriers.

ψw = ψs + ψp. Compare ψw, never ψs alone. Water flows to the more negative ψw until the values are equal.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

Always compute ψw first. An open solution has ψp = 0. A flaccid cell has ψw = ψs; a fully turgid cell has ψw = 0. At incipient plasmolysis ψp = 0 and the outside solution is isotonic with the sap. The commonest exam trap is ranking cells by solute potential instead of water potential.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A cell has ψs = −1.0 MPa and ψp = +0.3 MPa. Its water potential is:

    1. −1.3 MPa
    2. −0.7 MPa
    3. +0.7 MPa
    4. −0.3 MPa
    Show answer

    Answer: B. ψw = ψs + ψp = −1.0 + 0.3 = −0.7 MPa.

  2. 2. A fully turgid cell kept in pure water has ψs = −0.6 MPa. Its pressure potential is:

    1. 0
    2. −0.6 MPa
    3. +1.2 MPa
    4. +0.6 MPa
    Show answer

    Answer: D. In pure water at equilibrium ψw = 0, so ψp = −ψs = +0.6 MPa.

  3. 3. Cell X: ψs = −0.8, ψp = +0.5. Cell Y: ψs = −0.5, ψp = +0.1 (MPa). Water moves:

    1. From X to Y
    2. From Y to X
    3. Not at all
    4. Both ways equally
    Show answer

    Answer: A. ψw(X) = −0.3 and ψw(Y) = −0.4. X is higher, so water moves from X to Y, even though X has the more negative solute potential.

  4. 4. At incipient plasmolysis, the pressure potential of the cell is:

    1. Equal to its solute potential
    2. Equal to the water potential of pure water plus 1 MPa
    3. Zero
    4. Maximum
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Incipient plasmolysis is the point where the protoplast just stops pressing on the wall, so ψp = 0 and ψw = ψs.

  5. 5. A flaccid cell with ψs = −0.7 MPa is placed in a solution of ψ = −0.4 MPa. What happens?

    1. It loses water and plasmolyses
    2. Its water potential falls to −1.1 MPa
    3. It gains water until its water potential becomes −0.4 MPa
    4. Nothing, because it is flaccid
    Show answer

    Answer: C. ψw(cell) = −0.7 (ψp = 0). The solution at −0.4 is higher, so water enters, turgor rises, and ψw rises to −0.4 at equilibrium.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery