• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

A Question of Trust: the plot, the trick and new words

Retell Victor Canning's story of Horace Danby, the careful burglar who is himself tricked, explain why he steals and how he is caught, and use the chapter's key words and sayings.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Name the author and describe Horace Danby's double life.
  • Retell the robbery and the trick in the right order.
  • Explain how Horace is caught and who the real culprit is.
  • Use words and sayings such as hay fever, respectable, honour among thieves.

A Question of Trust is by Victor Canning, a British writer of thrillers and crime stories. It is a story with a clever reversal: a thief who prides himself on careful planning is fooled by a smarter thief. It is told in the third person, mostly from Horace Danby's point of view, so we are fooled along with him.

The story in short

In my own words: Horace Danby, about fifty, is a respected locksmith who robs one safe every year to buy rare books he loves. After studying Shotover Grange for two weeks, he enters while the servants are at the cinema, wearing gloves. Flowers in the room make his hay fever worse and he sneezes. A charming young woman in red appears, seems to be the lady of the house, and says she will not call the police if he opens the safe for her, since she has forgotten its numbers and needs her jewels for a party. He takes off his gloves to help her, opens the safe and leaves. Two days later he is arrested: his fingerprints are everywhere. The real owner's wife is a sharp-tongued woman of sixty. The young woman was a thief.

From careful plan to prison

  1. The plan Horace studies Shotover Grange for two weeks and waits for the servants to leave.
  2. Entry He uses the kitchen key from its hook, wears gloves and quietens the dog Sherry.
  3. Trouble Flowers set off his hay fever; he sneezes loudly.
  4. The 'lady' A young woman in red catches him and seems to own the house.
  5. The bargain She will let him go if he opens the safe; he removes his gloves.
  6. The arrest His fingerprints lead the police to him; nobody believes his story.
  7. The irony The real lady is sixty; the young woman was a cleverer thief.
Events in my own words.

Horace's double life

To the world Horace is a good citizen: he makes locks, employs two helpers, lives with a housekeeper and is generally healthy except for hay fever in summer. In secret he robs one safe a year, takes just enough to live and buy books for twelve months, and buys rare books through an agent so nobody knows. He once served a prison sentence fifteen years earlier, working in the prison library. The story ends with him back in prison, as assistant librarian.

New words and sayings

Word or sayingMeaningExample sentence (written for this lesson)
respectableregarded by society as good and properHe wore a respectable suit to the interview.
hay feveran allergy to pollen or dust that causes sneezingSpring flowers give my cousin hay fever.
hinderto make something difficult to doHeavy traffic hindered the ambulance.
inconveniencetrouble or difficultySorry for the inconvenience caused by the repairs.
desperateready to do anything because the situation is very badThe desperate climber shouted for help.
culpritthe person who did something wrongThe broken window's culprit was a cricket ball.
meticulousextremely careful about detailsShe is meticulous about checking her answers.
honour among thievesa saying: dishonest people are loyal to each otherThe story shows there is no honour among thieves.
set a thief to catch a thiefa saying: a dishonest person best understands anotherThe bank hired a former hacker: set a thief to catch a thief.

Worked example 1: why he steals

Question: What is Horace's passion, and how is it linked to his yearly robbery? Working: the text names rare, expensive books, which his honest income cannot pay for. Answer: he collects rare, expensive books and steals once a year to get enough money to buy them for the next twelve months.

Worked example 2: the real culprit

Question: Who is the real culprit in the jewel robbery? Working: Horace opened the safe, but he handed the jewels to the young woman, who took them away; she was not the owner's wife. Answer: the young woman in red, a skilled thief who used Horace to open the safe and then let him take the blame.

The planner is out-planned: the careful thief forgets to be careful at the one moment that matters.

Key takeaways: Victor Canning's Horace is a respectable locksmith with a secret yearly crime. A clever young woman tricks him into opening the safe without gloves; he is arrested and she escapes with the jewels.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What did Horace Danby love to collect?

    1. Paintings
    2. Jewels
    3. Rare, expensive books
    4. Antique locks
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The story says he loved rare, expensive books and bought them through an agent with stolen money.

  2. 2. Why were the servants absent from Shotover Grange that afternoon?

    1. They had gone to the movies.
    2. They were in London with the family.
    3. Horace had paid them to leave.
    4. They were ill.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The two servants who stayed who looked after the house during the family's stay in London had gone out to the cinema, the chance Horace had been waiting for.

  3. 3. What made Horace sneeze inside the house?

    1. Dust from the safe
    2. Smoke from the fireplace
    3. The dog Sherry
    4. A great bowl of flowers, which triggered his hay fever
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The smell of the flowers set off his hay fever, and the woman says she heard him from the top of the house.

  4. 4. How was Horace caught?

    1. The dog barked and woke the neighbours.
    2. His fingerprints were found because he opened the safe without gloves.
    3. The young lady called the police.
    4. The servants saw him leave.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. He took off his gloves to give the woman his lighter and opened the safe bare-handed, leaving fingerprints all over the room.

  5. 5. Who was the real culprit in the jewel robbery?

    1. The servants
    2. The real lady of the house
    3. The young woman in red, who was a thief
    4. The magazine writer
    Show answer

    Answer: C. She took the jewels and disappeared; the owner's wife was a woman of sixty, so the young woman had only pretended to be her.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery