• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Horace and the lady in red: character, irony and 'honour among thieves'

Analyse Horace Danby's character and his mistakes, find the subtle ways the young woman deceives him, and explain the story's irony and the title A Question of Trust.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why Horace is 'respectable but not completely honest'.
  • List the clues and tricks the young woman uses.
  • Explain where the meticulous planner went wrong.
  • Discuss irony and the meaning of the title.

This story asks a question with its title: whom can you trust? Horace, a thief, expects others to trust him as a citizen, and then trusts a stranger himself. The irony is that a thief is undone by misplaced trust.

Horace Danby: not a typical thief

He is not a typical thief: he steals rarely, plans, avoids violence and loves books.
QualityEvidence (in my own words)
Respectable in publicA successful locksmith with two helpers; neighbours think him honest.
Not completely honestRobs one safe every year and has been to prison before.
Meticulous plannerStudies the house for two weeks, wears gloves, uses the dog's name, times the servants.
Gentle, non-violentAdmits he was only trying to frighten the woman; he would not really hurt her.
Self-justifyingClaims he steals only from the rich and for a good reason (his books).
Overconfident and trustingBelieves the charming woman without checking, and takes off his gloves.

How the young woman deceives him

The woman's subtle tricks

  • Behaves like the owner
    • Pets Sherry, who greets her warmly
    • Straightens ornaments on the fireplace
    • Takes a cigarette from the silver box
  • Seems amused and kind
    • Calm, kindly voice with firmness
    • Shows no fear
    • Admits she likes the wrong kind of people
  • Gives a believable story
    • Promised her husband to bank the jewels
    • Needs them for a party tonight
    • Forgot the numbers of the safe
  • Applies pressure
    • Threatens to phone the police
    • Offers freedom in return for help
Each detail makes her look like the lady of the house.

Why Horace does not suspect: he is frightened of prison and grateful for a way out; she seems to know the house and the dog; and his attention is on pleasing her, not on checking her. Readers may begin to suspect when she asks him to open her 'own' safe, since an owner could call a locksmith or the bank; another clue is how comfortable she is with a burglar.

Where the planner went wrong

  • He ignored his hay fever and let the flowers make him noisy.
  • He took off his gloves to light her cigarette, then opened the safe bare-handed.
  • He trusted a stranger because she was charming and offered him escape.
  • After his promise to stop, he quickly planned another robbery, showing he had not really changed.

Irony and the title

Situational irony is when the result is the opposite of what is expected. A careful thief is caught for a robbery he did not profit from; a locksmith is locked up; a man who stole for books ends up surrounded by books in a prison library. The title, A Question of Trust, points to the central irony: Horace, who betrays the trust of society, is destroyed by trusting someone. The book's opening sayings also apply: it takes a thief to catch a thief, and the ending shows there is no honour among thieves. That is why Horace gets angry whenever anyone mentions it.

Worked example 1: a 'Think about it' answer

Question: Explain why Horace can be called respectable in public yet dishonest in private. Model answer: Horace runs an honest locksmith business, employs helpers and is seen as a good citizen, so he is respectable. Yet every year he secretly robs a safe to buy rare books, so he is not honest. Unlike a typical thief, he steals only once a year, plans carefully, avoids violence and spends the money on books, not luxury.

Worked example 2: deserved or unfair?

Working: weigh both sides. He did not steal these jewels, so the charge is technically wrong; but he broke in intending to steal them and had robbed many other safes. Balanced answer: he was punished for the wrong robbery, but not unfairly overall, since he entered the house as a burglar and had committed similar crimes for years.

Situational irony: the outcome is the opposite of what the character, and often the reader, expects.

Key takeaways: Horace is respectable but dishonest, careful but trusting at the wrong moment. The woman deceives him through behaviour, calm and a plausible story. The ending is ironic: no honour among thieves.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why is Horace not a typical thief?

    1. He steals every day from the poor.
    2. He uses violence in every robbery.
    3. He steals rarely, plans carefully, avoids violence and spends on books.
    4. He has never been caught.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. He robs one safe a year, studies each job, does not hurt people and buys rare books; he was also caught once before.

  2. 2. Which action of the woman made her look like the lady of the house?

    1. She calmly straightened the ornaments and the dog greeted her warmly.
    2. She showed him her passport.
    3. She called her husband in London.
    4. She wore the jewels.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. She behaved as if at home: the dog Sherry rubbed against her and she tidied the fireplace ornaments.

  3. 3. What was Horace's fatal mistake?

    1. He came on a weekday.
    2. He cut the alarm wire.
    3. He used the kitchen key.
    4. He removed his gloves and opened the safe with bare hands.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. His fingerprints on the safe and around the room led to his arrest; everything else was part of a careful plan.

  4. 4. Why does Horace get angry when people talk about 'honour among thieves'?

    1. He thinks thieves should be honoured.
    2. A fellow thief tricked him and let him take the blame.
    3. He was never a thief.
    4. The phrase reminds him of hay fever.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The young woman, a thief like him, used him and left him to be jailed; there was no honour among thieves.

  5. 5. Which is an example of situational irony in the story?

    1. Horace loves books.
    2. The servants go to the movies.
    3. A careful locksmith ends up locked in prison for a robbery he did not profit from.
    4. The safe is behind a painting.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The result is the opposite of what Horace expected; that reversal is situational irony.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery