- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Writing and speaking: a debate on ends and means, and a diary entry from prison
Prepare a debate speech on whether good intentions can justify wrong actions, write Horace's diary entry from the prison library, and answer a long question on where the planner went wrong.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Write a debate speech for or against a motion.
- Write a diary entry in a character's voice that shows reflection.
- Write a long answer with point, evidence and message.
The chapter asks: do intentions justify actions? Horace believed stealing for books was acceptable because he took only from the rich. This lesson turns that question into a debate, a diary and a long answer. All models are original.
Debate format
- Greeting: address the chairperson, judges and audience.
- State the motion and your stand (for or against).
- Give two or three arguments, each with an example or reason.
- Rebut (answer) the likely argument of the other side.
- Conclude strongly and thank the audience.
Worked example 1: debate speech against the motion 'Good intentions justify wrong actions' (about 150 words)
Respected chairperson, honourable judges and dear friends, I speak against the motion that good intentions justify wrong actions. First, almost every wrongdoer believes he has a good reason. Horace Danby, in A Question of Trust, told himself he stole only from the rich and only for books he loved, yet he broke into a home and planned to sell another family's jewels. Second, if each person decides for himself which wrongs are justified, nobody's property or safety is secure. My opponents may say that a starving person who takes bread deserves sympathy. Sympathy, yes, and help from society, but that is a reason to fix hunger, not to praise stealing. Good ends must be reached by good means; otherwise the end itself is spoiled. Thank you.
Arguments on ends and means
-
For the motion
- Intentions show a person's character
- Desperate need may excuse small wrongs
- Rigid rules can be unjust
-
Against the motion
- Every wrongdoer claims a good reason
- Wrong means harm innocent people
- Society needs common rules
- Good ends deserve good means
Diary entry in a character's voice
Worked example 2: Horace's diary, from the prison library (original model)
Monday, evening. Another day of stamping library cards. The books here are dull, and I think often of the three rare volumes I will never own now. Most of all I think of her: the calm voice, the dog that ran to her, the jewels she 'needed' for a party. I, who studied that house for two weeks, never checked one word she said. I took off my gloves to light her cigarette! People here joke about honour among thieves. I do not laugh. Perhaps the lesson is not only about trusting the wrong person; perhaps it is that a man who lives by deceiving others should not be surprised to be deceived. - H.D.
Notice the features: first person, feelings (regret, anger, self-reflection), references to the story and a final insight.
Long answer: where did the planner go wrong?
Plan: point (his weakness was trust and pride, not planning) - evidence (hay fever ignored, gloves removed, story unchecked) - explanation (fear of prison and her charm stopped him thinking) - message (overconfidence and dishonesty bring their own downfall).
A debate needs a clear stand, reasons with examples, a rebuttal and a strong close.
Key takeaways: a debate argues one side and answers the other; a diary reflects in the first person; a long answer follows point, evidence, explanation and message.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is a 'rebuttal' in a debate?
- The greeting at the start
- An answer to the opposing side's argument
- The title of the motion
- The thank-you at the end
Show answer
Answer: B. A rebuttal responds to and weakens the other side's likely argument.
-
2. Which statement best supports the side against the motion 'Good intentions justify wrong actions'?
- Horace loved books.
- Horace had hay fever.
- Almost every wrongdoer believes he has a good reason, so intentions cannot excuse harm.
- Rare books are expensive.
Show answer
Answer: C. It is an argument, not a fact about the story: if any reason excused wrongdoing, nobody would be safe.
-
3. Which feature makes the model diary entry effective?
- It has a formal subject line.
- It is written in the third person.
- It contains a list of prices.
- It shows Horace's regret and a final insight in the first person.
Show answer
Answer: D. A diary shows personal feelings and reflection in the first person; the model ends with a realisation about deception.
-
4. In a long answer on Horace's mistakes, which is the strongest piece of evidence?
- He removed his gloves and opened the safe with bare hands.
- He lived with a housekeeper.
- He was about fifty.
- He had two helpers.
Show answer
Answer: A. Removing his gloves left the fingerprints that led to his arrest; the others are background details.
-
5. How should a debate speech end?
- Yours sincerely,
- With a strong concluding line and thanks to the audience
- With the date and time
- With a new argument never explained
Show answer
Answer: B. A speech closes with a strong summary line and thanks; 'Yours sincerely' ends a letter.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.