• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Writing and speaking: a debate on ends and means, and a diary entry from prison

Prepare a debate speech on whether good intentions can justify wrong actions, write Horace's diary entry from the prison library, and answer a long question on where the planner went wrong.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Write a debate speech for or against a motion.
  • Write a diary entry in a character's voice that shows reflection.
  • Write a long answer with point, evidence and message.

The chapter asks: do intentions justify actions? Horace believed stealing for books was acceptable because he took only from the rich. This lesson turns that question into a debate, a diary and a long answer. All models are original.

Debate format

  1. Greeting: address the chairperson, judges and audience.
  2. State the motion and your stand (for or against).
  3. Give two or three arguments, each with an example or reason.
  4. Rebut (answer) the likely argument of the other side.
  5. Conclude strongly and thank the audience.

Worked example 1: debate speech against the motion 'Good intentions justify wrong actions' (about 150 words)

Respected chairperson, honourable judges and dear friends, I speak against the motion that good intentions justify wrong actions. First, almost every wrongdoer believes he has a good reason. Horace Danby, in A Question of Trust, told himself he stole only from the rich and only for books he loved, yet he broke into a home and planned to sell another family's jewels. Second, if each person decides for himself which wrongs are justified, nobody's property or safety is secure. My opponents may say that a starving person who takes bread deserves sympathy. Sympathy, yes, and help from society, but that is a reason to fix hunger, not to praise stealing. Good ends must be reached by good means; otherwise the end itself is spoiled. Thank you.

Arguments on ends and means

  • For the motion
    • Intentions show a person's character
    • Desperate need may excuse small wrongs
    • Rigid rules can be unjust
  • Against the motion
    • Every wrongdoer claims a good reason
    • Wrong means harm innocent people
    • Society needs common rules
    • Good ends deserve good means

Diary entry in a character's voice

Worked example 2: Horace's diary, from the prison library (original model)

Monday, evening. Another day of stamping library cards. The books here are dull, and I think often of the three rare volumes I will never own now. Most of all I think of her: the calm voice, the dog that ran to her, the jewels she 'needed' for a party. I, who studied that house for two weeks, never checked one word she said. I took off my gloves to light her cigarette! People here joke about honour among thieves. I do not laugh. Perhaps the lesson is not only about trusting the wrong person; perhaps it is that a man who lives by deceiving others should not be surprised to be deceived. - H.D.

Notice the features: first person, feelings (regret, anger, self-reflection), references to the story and a final insight.

Long answer: where did the planner go wrong?

Plan: point (his weakness was trust and pride, not planning) - evidence (hay fever ignored, gloves removed, story unchecked) - explanation (fear of prison and her charm stopped him thinking) - message (overconfidence and dishonesty bring their own downfall).

A debate needs a clear stand, reasons with examples, a rebuttal and a strong close.

Key takeaways: a debate argues one side and answers the other; a diary reflects in the first person; a long answer follows point, evidence, explanation and message.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is a 'rebuttal' in a debate?

    1. The greeting at the start
    2. An answer to the opposing side's argument
    3. The title of the motion
    4. The thank-you at the end
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A rebuttal responds to and weakens the other side's likely argument.

  2. 2. Which statement best supports the side against the motion 'Good intentions justify wrong actions'?

    1. Horace loved books.
    2. Horace had hay fever.
    3. Almost every wrongdoer believes he has a good reason, so intentions cannot excuse harm.
    4. Rare books are expensive.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. It is an argument, not a fact about the story: if any reason excused wrongdoing, nobody would be safe.

  3. 3. Which feature makes the model diary entry effective?

    1. It has a formal subject line.
    2. It is written in the third person.
    3. It contains a list of prices.
    4. It shows Horace's regret and a final insight in the first person.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A diary shows personal feelings and reflection in the first person; the model ends with a realisation about deception.

  4. 4. In a long answer on Horace's mistakes, which is the strongest piece of evidence?

    1. He removed his gloves and opened the safe with bare hands.
    2. He lived with a housekeeper.
    3. He was about fifty.
    4. He had two helpers.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Removing his gloves left the fingerprints that led to his arrest; the others are background details.

  5. 5. How should a debate speech end?

    1. Yours sincerely,
    2. With a strong concluding line and thanks to the audience
    3. With the date and time
    4. With a new argument never explained
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A speech closes with a strong summary line and thanks; 'Yours sincerely' ends a letter.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery