Revision notes

Chapter 4 A Question of Trust: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

A Question of Trust: the plot, the trick and new words

From careful plan to prison

  1. The plan Horace studies Shotover Grange for two weeks and waits for the servants to leave.
  2. Entry He uses the kitchen key from its hook, wears gloves and quietens the dog Sherry.
  3. Trouble Flowers set off his hay fever; he sneezes loudly.
  4. The 'lady' A young woman in red catches him and seems to own the house.
  5. The bargain She will let him go if he opens the safe; he removes his gloves.
  6. The arrest His fingerprints lead the police to him; nobody believes his story.
  7. The irony The real lady is sixty; the young woman was a cleverer thief.
Events in my own words.
Word or sayingMeaningExample sentence (written for this lesson)
respectableregarded by society as good and properHe wore a respectable suit to the interview.
hay feveran allergy to pollen or dust that causes sneezingSpring flowers give my cousin hay fever.
hinderto make something difficult to doHeavy traffic hindered the ambulance.
inconveniencetrouble or difficultySorry for the inconvenience caused by the repairs.
desperateready to do anything because the situation is very badThe desperate climber shouted for help.
culpritthe person who did something wrongThe broken window's culprit was a cricket ball.
meticulousextremely careful about detailsShe is meticulous about checking her answers.
honour among thievesa saying: dishonest people are loyal to each otherThe story shows there is no honour among thieves.
set a thief to catch a thiefa saying: a dishonest person best understands anotherThe bank hired a former hacker: set a thief to catch a thief.

The planner is out-planned: the careful thief forgets to be careful at the one moment that matters.

Key takeaways: Victor Canning's Horace is a respectable locksmith with a secret yearly crime. A clever young woman tricks him into opening the safe without gloves; he is arrested and she escapes with the jewels.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Horace and the lady in red: character, irony and 'honour among thieves'

He is not a typical thief: he steals rarely, plans, avoids violence and loves books.
QualityEvidence (in my own words)
Respectable in publicA successful locksmith with two helpers; neighbours think him honest.
Not completely honestRobs one safe every year and has been to prison before.
Meticulous plannerStudies the house for two weeks, wears gloves, uses the dog's name, times the servants.
Gentle, non-violentAdmits he was only trying to frighten the woman; he would not really hurt her.
Self-justifyingClaims he steals only from the rich and for a good reason (his books).
Overconfident and trustingBelieves the charming woman without checking, and takes off his gloves.

The woman's subtle tricks

  • Behaves like the owner
    • Pets Sherry, who greets her warmly
    • Straightens ornaments on the fireplace
    • Takes a cigarette from the silver box
  • Seems amused and kind
    • Calm, kindly voice with firmness
    • Shows no fear
    • Admits she likes the wrong kind of people
  • Gives a believable story
    • Promised her husband to bank the jewels
    • Needs them for a party tonight
    • Forgot the numbers of the safe
  • Applies pressure
    • Threatens to phone the police
    • Offers freedom in return for help
Each detail makes her look like the lady of the house.

Situational irony: the outcome is the opposite of what the character, and often the reader, expects.

Key takeaways: Horace is respectable but dishonest, careful but trusting at the wrong moment. The woman deceives him through behaviour, calm and a plausible story. The ending is ironic: no honour among thieves.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Unseen passage practice: confidence tricks and careful thinking

The pattern of a con, from paragraph 2

  1. Appear to belong Right look, right names, relaxed manner.
  2. Tell a story A small problem the victim can solve.
  3. Add pressure A deadline or a hint of trouble.
  4. Victim acts Without pausing to check.
The passage's pattern fits the story closely.
Stage of a conIn A Question of Trust
Appear to belongThe dog knows her; she tidies ornaments and takes a cigarette from the box.
A story with a small problemShe has forgotten the safe's numbers and needs her jewels for a party.
PressureShe can phone the police; he fears prison.
The victim's prideHorace thinks of himself as a meticulous planner.

Pause and check: the one question a trickster never wants you to ask is 'How can I check this?'

Key takeaways: identify the main idea of each paragraph; for inference, find the reason the writer gives; for a summary, keep the ideas and drop the examples.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Language from the story: question tags, conditionals and proverbs

StatementTagWhy
You have forgotten the numbers,haven't you?positive 'have' becomes negative 'haven't'
You are afraid of prison,aren't you?positive 'are' becomes 'aren't'
He wore gloves,didn't he?no auxiliary, so use did
She didn't call the police,did she?negative statement takes a positive tag
I am right,aren't I?special form: 'am I not' becomes 'aren't I'
Let's open the safe,shall we?suggestions with let's take shall we

Question tags: positive statement, negative tag; negative statement, positive tag; same auxiliary, matching pronoun.

Two kinds of if-sentence

  • First conditional (real, likely)
    • If + present simple, will + verb
    • If you run, I will phone the police.
    • Used for possible future results
  • Second conditional (imagined, unlikely)
    • If + past simple, would + verb
    • If I had the numbers, I would open it myself.
    • Used for unreal or unlikely situations
ProverbMeaning
Set a thief to catch a thief.A dishonest person can best understand or catch another.
There is honour among thieves.Criminals are loyal to each other (the story shows it is not always true).
Honesty is the best policy.Being honest is wisest in the end.
All that glitters is not gold.Attractive things or people are not always what they seem.
The end does not justify the means.A good goal does not make wrong actions right.

Key takeaways: tags reverse the polarity and repeat the auxiliary; first conditional = likely future, second = imagined; proverbs sum up the story's lessons briefly.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Writing and speaking: a debate on ends and means, and a diary entry from prison

Arguments on ends and means

  • For the motion
    • Intentions show a person's character
    • Desperate need may excuse small wrongs
    • Rigid rules can be unjust
  • Against the motion
    • Every wrongdoer claims a good reason
    • Wrong means harm innocent people
    • Society needs common rules
    • Good ends deserve good means

A debate needs a clear stand, reasons with examples, a rebuttal and a strong close.

Key takeaways: a debate argues one side and answers the other; a diary reflects in the first person; a long answer follows point, evidence, explanation and message.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery