- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Beyond income: public facilities and human development
Use indicators such as infant mortality rate, literacy rate, attendance ratio and life expectancy, understand public facilities, and see how the Human Development Index compares countries.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define infant mortality rate, literacy rate, net attendance ratio and life expectancy.
- Explain why money in your pocket cannot buy everything and why some things are best provided collectively.
- Describe what the Human Development Report measures and how it differs from the World Bank's method.
Is a state with higher income always better off? The chapter compares states and countries using other measures as well and finds that income alone can give a misleading picture. This lesson introduces those measures and the idea of human development.
Comparing states on more than income
The textbook compares three states, Haryana, Kerala and Bihar. On per capita income (for 2023-24, according to the textbook), Haryana is highest, Kerala second and Bihar lowest. If income were the only measure, Haryana would be the most developed. But on other measures the order changes. According to the textbook's data, Kerala has a much lower infant mortality rate than Haryana, and Kerala is ahead in literacy and in the share of 15-17 year olds attending school. In Bihar, roughly one-third of children aged 15-17 are not attending secondary school.
| Indicator | What it measures |
|---|---|
| Infant Mortality Rate (IMR) | Number of children who die before the age of one year, per 1,000 live births in that year |
| Literacy Rate | Proportion of literate people in the population aged 7 years and above |
| Net Attendance Ratio | Children of a given age group (in the chapter, 15-17 years) attending school, as a percentage of all children of that age group |
| Life expectancy at birth | The average expected length of life of a person at the time of birth |
A lower infant mortality rate is better; a higher literacy rate, attendance ratio and life expectancy are better.
Why money in your pocket cannot buy everything
How can a state with higher average income lag behind in health and education? Because income in your pocket cannot buy all the goods and services you need to live well. Normally your money cannot buy a pollution-free environment or make sure the medicines you buy are not adulterated, unless you move to a place that already has these. It cannot protect you from infectious diseases unless the whole community takes preventive steps.
For many important things the best, and also the cheapest, way is collective provision. Think of security for a whole locality compared with every house hiring its own guard. You can go to school because many other children also want to study and because people believe the government should open schools so that all children get a chance. Where such facilities are missing, children, especially girls, often cannot continue to high school.
Public facilities that support development
-
Health
- Basic healthcare for babies and mothers
- Prevention of infectious disease
-
Education
- Schools within reach
- Facilities so that girls continue to high school
-
Food security
- A well-run Public Distribution System (ration shops)
-
Safe environment
- Clean water and air
- Collective security
According to the textbook, Kerala has a low infant mortality rate because it has adequate provision of basic health and educational facilities. Similarly, in states where the Public Distribution System (PDS) works well, the health and nutrition of people are likely to be better.
Worked example 1: using a table
Data (made up): State M: per capita income Rs 2,00,000, IMR 30. State N: per capita income Rs 1,50,000, IMR 8. Question: Which state is better off in the health of infants? Reasoning: IMR counts infant deaths per 1,000 live births, so lower is better. State N loses 8 babies in every 1,000 born; State M loses 30, nearly four times as many. Answer: State N, even though its income is lower. This is exactly the pattern the textbook finds when it compares Kerala and Haryana.
The Human Development Report
Once we accept that income is important but not enough, we need a small set of other measures. Health and education indicators are now widely used along with income. The Human Development Report, published by the UNDP (United Nations Development Programme), compares countries on the educational levels of people, their health status and their per capita income, and ranks them by the Human Development Index (HDI).
Two ways of measuring development
-
World Bank
- Uses per capita income
- Groups countries as low, middle or high income
- Simple to compare
-
UNDP (Human Development Report)
- Uses income, health and education together
- Ranks countries by HDI
- Puts people's well-being at the centre
For the HDR, per capita income is calculated in US dollars for all countries, and in a way that each dollar buys the same amount of goods and services in every country (this is called purchasing power parity, PPP). Life expectancy and mean years of schooling of adults are among the measures. According to the textbook's table (from the Human Development Report 2025), Sri Lanka is well ahead of India on these measures, and Nepal and Bangladesh, despite having a lower per capita income than India, have a higher life expectancy.
Worked example 2: reading a comparison
Statement: A country has a higher per capita income than its neighbour but a lower life expectancy. Question: What does this tell us? Reasoning: Income measures what people earn; life expectancy reflects health care, nutrition and living conditions. A country can earn more but spend less effectively on public health. Conclusion: Income and human development do not always move together, which is why the HDI combines both.
By putting the word human in front of development, the report makes clear that what matters most is what happens to the people of a country: their health and well-being.
Key takeaways: Indicators such as IMR, literacy rate, net attendance ratio and life expectancy show aspects of life that income misses. Many important goods are best provided collectively through public facilities. The UNDP's Human Development Report ranks countries using income, health and education together, unlike the World Bank, which uses income alone.
Check your understanding
-
1. Infant Mortality Rate tells us:
- The number of babies born per 1,000 people
- The number of children who die before age one per 1,000 live births
- The percentage of children in school
- The average age of a population
Show answer
Answer: B. IMR counts infant deaths before the first birthday as a proportion of every 1,000 live births in that year. A lower IMR means better health care for infants.
-
2. According to the textbook, why does Kerala have a low infant mortality rate?
- It has the highest per capita income in India
- It has no rural areas
- It has adequate provision of basic health and educational facilities
- It imports all its medicines
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter explains Kerala's low IMR by its adequate basic health and educational facilities, not by income; in fact Haryana has a higher per capita income according to the textbook.
-
3. Which three areas does the UNDP's Human Development Report use to compare countries?
- Industry, agriculture and services
- Income, army size and exports
- Population, area and income
- Income, health and education
Show answer
Answer: D. The HDR compares countries on per capita income, health status (for example life expectancy) and educational levels, combined in the Human Development Index.
-
4. Assertion (A): Income alone is not an adequate indicator of the goods and services people can use. Reason (R): Money cannot normally buy a pollution-free environment or protection from infectious disease for one family alone.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- A is true but R is false
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Some essential things can only be provided for a whole community. Because money in your pocket cannot buy them (R), income alone is an inadequate indicator (A).
-
5. Why is security for a whole locality usually cheaper than each house hiring its own guard?
- Because guards work for free
- Because houses do not need security
- Because one shared arrangement serves many houses, so the cost per house is lower
- Because the government bans private guards
Show answer
Answer: C. Collective provision spreads one cost over many users. A few guards for the whole locality cost each house far less than one guard per house; the chapter uses this to show why many goods are best provided collectively.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.