- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Income and other goals of development
See why people want more income but also security, equality, freedom and respect, and how this shapes ideas of national development.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why income is a common goal of almost everyone.
- Give examples of non-material goals that matter as much as income.
- Explain why ideas of national development differ and how they can be judged.
If you look at the goals of the different people in the last lesson, one thing is common: almost everyone wants regular work, better wages or a fair price for what they produce. In other words, people want more income. But is income all that matters? This lesson looks at the other goals people have and what they mean for the development of a whole nation.
Income: the common goal
Money, and the things it can buy, is one important factor our lives depend on. With more income a family can eat better, live in a better house and pay for education. That is why higher income appears in nearly everyone's list of hopes.
Goals beyond income
People also seek equal treatment, freedom, security and the respect of others. They resent discrimination. In some cases these goals matter even more than extra income or consumption, because material goods are not all that a person needs. Think of the place of friendship in your own life: you cannot buy it, you cannot easily measure it, yet it means a great deal. Things that are hard to measure are often ignored, but it would be wrong to conclude that what cannot be measured is not important.
What people seek from development
-
Material goals
- Regular work
- Better wages
- Fair prices for crops and products
- More things to consume
-
Non-material goals
- Equal treatment
- Freedom
- Security
- Respect and dignity
- A safe environment
The quality of our life depends not only on income and the material things it buys but also on non-material things such as equality, freedom, security and respect.
A mix of goals
Choosing a job shows how people weigh a mix of goals. One job may pay less but be permanent, which gives a sense of security. Another may pay more but have no security and leave no time for the family. Facilities for your family, the working atmosphere and the chance to learn also count. The same is true of development in general.
Goals also support one another. When women do paid work, their dignity in the household and in society tends to rise. In turn, when women are respected, housework is shared more and women working outside the home is more widely accepted. A safe and secure environment allows more women to take up different jobs or run a business.
Worked example 1: comparing two job offers
Situation (made up for practice): Asha gets two offers. Job X pays Rs 30,000 a month on a one-year contract with long, irregular hours. Job Y pays Rs 24,000 a month, is permanent and has fixed hours near her home. Reasoning: Job X gives more income. Job Y gives security, time for family and less travel. Conclusion: Many people would choose Job Y, showing that income is only one of several goals. There is no single right choice; the point is that people weigh several goals together.
National development
If individuals seek different goals, their ideas of what the nation should achieve will also differ. Ask a class what India should do to develop and you will hear many answers: more jobs, better schools, cleaner rivers, faster trains, less inequality. These ideas can conflict too. So we need to ask: Which ideas should come first? If there is a conflict, how do we decide? What would be a fair and just path for all? Is there a better way of doing things? Would an idea benefit a large number of people or only a small group? Thinking through such questions is what national development involves.
Judging an idea for national development
- Propose a goal For example, a new highway
- Who benefits? Many people or a small group?
- Who loses? Is anyone displaced or harmed?
- Is it fair and just? Could there be a better way?
- Decide democratically Through discussion and public choice
Worked example 2: reading a source
Source (summarised from the chapter): A ship's owners paid a local firm in Abidjan, Ivory Coast, to get rid of hundreds of tonnes of toxic liquid waste. It was dumped in the open and in the sea; people fell ill and some died. Questions: Who benefited and who did not? Reasoning: The company saved money by getting the waste removed cheaply; the city's residents paid with their health. Conclusion: An activity that brings income to some can harm many others, so development has to ask who gains and who pays.
Key takeaways: Higher income is a goal shared by almost everyone, but people also want equality, freedom, security and respect. Goals come as a mix and often support each other. National development raises hard questions about priorities, fairness and who benefits, and these are settled through debate.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of the following is a non-material goal of development?
- Higher wages
- A better price for crops
- A bigger house
- Freedom from discrimination
Show answer
Answer: D. Freedom from discrimination cannot be bought with money; it concerns equal treatment and respect. The other options are material goals linked to income.
-
2. Rakesh turns down a high-paying contract job and accepts a lower-paying permanent job. Which goal is he giving more weight to?
- Security
- Consumption
- Discrimination
- Profit
Show answer
Answer: A. A permanent job gives a steady future, which adds to a person's sense of security. He accepts less income for more security, showing that people weigh a mix of goals.
-
3. Assertion (A): Things that cannot be measured easily are unimportant for development. Reason (R): Friendship and respect are hard to measure.
- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
- A is false but R is true
- A is true but R is false
- Both A and R are false
Show answer
Answer: B. R is true: friendship and respect are hard to measure. But A is false: the chapter says it would be wrong to conclude that what cannot be measured is not important.
-
4. According to the chapter, what tends to happen when there is more respect for women in society?
- Women stop working outside the home
- Women's incomes fall
- Housework is shared more and women working outside is accepted more
- Only men's goals are met
Show answer
Answer: C. Respect for women and paid work for women support each other: with more respect, housework is shared more and women working outside the home becomes more accepted.
-
5. Which question is most useful when judging whether an idea for national development is fair?
- Will it benefit a large number of people or only a small group?
- Does it look modern?
- Is it the most expensive option?
- Has any other country done it?
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter asks whether an idea benefits many people or only a few, and whether there is a fair and just path for all. Cost or appearance alone does not decide fairness.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.