- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
What development means: different people, different goals
Understand why different people want different things from development, and why one person's development can be another person's loss.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain what we mean by development or progress.
- Give examples of how the goals of different groups of people differ.
- Explain, with an example, how developmental goals can conflict.
Every one of us has hopes about the life we want to live: a good job, a safe home, respect, the freedom to choose. We also have ideas about what kind of country we would like India to be. Thinking about these hopes, and about how we can reach them, is what the study of development is about. This first lesson asks a simple question with no single answer: what does development mean, and to whom?
Development is about aspirations
Development, or progress, involves asking questions such as: What are the essential things people need? Can life be better for everyone? How should people live together? Can there be more equality? Economics gives part of the answer, but history and political science matter too. The way we live today is shaped by the past, and in a democracy the hopes of people can be turned into reality only through a democratic political process.
Development means the improvement people hope for in their lives and in their society, together with the ways of working towards those goals.
Different people, different goals
The goals people have depend on their life situation. A person who has no land of their own and works on other people's fields for daily wages is likely to want more days of work, better wages, a good local school for their children and an end to social discrimination. A prosperous farmer may want higher prices for crops and a secure future for their children. A young woman may want the same freedom as her brother to decide what she studies and where she works. An unemployed young person in a city wants a steady job.
| Person | Possible developmental goals |
|---|---|
| Landless rural labourer | More days of work, better wages, good schooling for children, no social discrimination |
| Farmer who depends only on rain | Reliable irrigation, fair crop prices, protection against crop failure |
| Urban unemployed youth | A regular job that uses their education, a fair wage |
| Girl from a well-off city family | The same freedom and chances as her brother, and the right to choose her own studies |
| Adivasi living near a forest or river valley | Keeping their land and way of life, a say in projects that affect them |
When goals conflict
Goals are not only different; sometimes they clash. A girl may expect her brother to share the housework, and the brother may not like that. Industrialists may want more big dams to get more electricity, but a large dam can flood land and uproot the people who live there, such as tribal communities. Those people may prefer small check dams or tanks that irrigate their fields without displacing anyone. The textbook shows a protest against raising the height of the Sardar Sarovar Dam on the Narmada river as an example of such a conflict.
One dam, two points of view
-
Those who gain
- More electricity for industry and cities
- Water for irrigation downstream
- See the dam as development
-
Those who are displaced
- Lose land, homes and livelihoods
- Communities broken up
- May prefer small check dams or tanks
Two things follow: different persons can have different developmental goals, and what is development for one may not be development for another; it may even be destructive for the other.
Worked example 1: explaining why goals differ
Question: A rain-fed farmer in a dry district and a software engineer in a big city are asked what development means to them. Why will their answers differ? Reasoning: Their life situations differ. The farmer's income depends on the monsoon, so irrigation and stable crop prices matter most. The engineer already has a regular salary, so they may care more about clean air, less traffic or safety at night. Answer: People have different notions of development mainly because their life situations are different, not simply because they are different people.
Worked example 2: different or conflicting?
Question: Is "people have different goals" the same as "people have conflicting goals"? Reasoning: Two people can want different things without hurting each other: one wants a library, another wants a playground; both can be built. Goals conflict only when meeting one goal works against the other, as when flooding land for a dam takes away someone's home. Answer: No. Every conflicting goal is different, but not every different goal conflicts.
From aspirations to development
- Life situation Where and how a person lives and earns
- Aspirations What they hope for
- Developmental goals What they want changed
- Ways of working Through the economy and the democratic process
Key takeaways: Development is about people's aspirations for a better life and the ways of achieving them. Because life situations differ, people seek different things. Goals can conflict, so what is progress for one group may be a loss for another; that is why development is debated, not simply decided.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which explanation best accounts for why a landless labourer and a prosperous farmer want different things from development?
- Their life situations are different
- One of them does not want development
- Development means the same for everyone
- Only income matters to both
Show answer
Answer: A. Each person seeks what fulfils their own needs, and those needs come from their situation: one has no land and needs work and wages, the other owns land and wants better crop prices.
-
2. Industrialists want a large dam for electricity, while villagers in the valley want small check dams. This is an example of:
- Goals that are identical
- Goals that conflict
- A goal nobody holds
- A goal that only concerns income
Show answer
Answer: B. Building the big dam may flood the villagers' land and displace them, so achieving one group's goal works against the other's. That is a conflict, not just a difference.
-
3. Assertion (A): What is development for one person may be destructive for another. Reason (R): Different people can have conflicting developmental goals.
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: C. Both statements are true. Because goals can conflict (R), a project that fulfils one group's goal can harm another group (A), so R explains A.
-
4. A girl wants her brother to share household work equally. Her brother is unhappy about this. Which idea from the lesson does this show?
- Development always means more income
- Brothers and sisters always have the same goals
- Only governments have developmental goals
- Goals within one family can conflict
Show answer
Answer: D. Even inside one household, the goal of equal freedom and shared work for the girl can clash with the brother's preference. Development goals can conflict at any level.
-
5. According to the lesson, how can the hopes people have for development be achieved in real life?
- Only by economic growth of big companies
- Through a democratic political process
- Only by studying the past
- By avoiding any discussion
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter links economics with political science: it is through a democratic political process that people's hopes and possibilities can be turned into reality.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.