• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Belgium: accommodating diversity through power sharing

Describe the ethnic and linguistic make-up of Belgium, explain the tensions between its communities, and explain the four main features of the Belgian model of power sharing and why it worked.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe Belgium's language communities and the special problem of Brussels.
  • Explain the four main elements of the Belgian model of power sharing.
  • Explain how these arrangements helped keep Belgium united.

In a democracy, power does not rest with any one organ of government; it is shared wisely. This chapter carries that idea further by asking how democracies respond when different communities demand a share in power. We begin with two countries that made very different choices: Belgium and Sri Lanka.

A small country with a complex society

Belgium is a small country in Europe, smaller in area than the Indian state of Haryana, bordering France, the Netherlands, Germany and Luxembourg. Its population is a little over one crore. According to the textbook, about 59 per cent live in the Flemish region and speak Dutch, about 40 per cent live in the Wallonia region and speak French, and about 1 per cent speak German. In the capital, Brussels, about 80 per cent speak French and 20 per cent Dutch.

Belgium's language communities (figures as given in the textbook)
CommunityRegionShare of population
Dutch-speakingFlemish region (north)About 59%
French-speakingWallonia (south)About 40%
German-speakingSmall area in the eastAbout 1%
Brussels (capital)80% French-speaking, 20% Dutch-speaking-

The French-speaking minority was relatively rich and powerful. The Dutch-speaking majority resented this, since it gained the benefits of economic development and education much later. This caused tension between the two communities in the 1950s and 1960s, sharpest in Brussels, which posed a special problem: the Dutch speakers were a majority in the country but a minority in the capital.

The Belgian model

Belgium's leaders recognised regional differences and cultural diversity. Between 1970 and 1993 they amended the constitution four times to create an arrangement that let everyone live together in one country. Its main elements are:

  1. Equal ministers: the constitution requires an equal number of Dutch- and French-speaking ministers in the central government, and some special laws need the support of a majority of members from each language group. So no single community can decide alone.
  2. Powerful state governments: many powers of the central government were given to the state governments of the two regions, and these governments are not subordinate to the central government.
  3. Brussels: has a separate government with equal representation for both communities. French speakers accepted equality in Brussels because Dutch speakers accepted equality in the central government.
  4. Community government: a third kind of government, elected by people of one language community - Dutch, French or German - wherever they live, with powers over cultural, educational and language matters.

Levels of government in the Belgian model

  • Central government Equal Dutch- and French-speaking ministers.
  • State (regional) governments Many powers; not subordinate to the centre.
  • Brussels government Equal representation of both communities.
  • Community government Elected by each language group; culture, education, language.

Accommodation: instead of letting the majority rule alone, Belgium gave every community a guaranteed share of power, so that no group could impose its will on the others.

The Belgian model is complicated, even for Belgians. But it has worked: it helped avoid civic strife and a possible division of the country along language lines. When European countries came together to form the European Union, Brussels was chosen as its headquarters.

Worked example 1: explaining a cause and effect

Question: Why did the French speakers accept equal representation in Brussels, where they were a majority? Reasoning: Step 1 - in the country as a whole, the Dutch speakers are the majority. Step 2 - the Dutch speakers accepted equal representation in the central government, giving up the advantage of their numbers there. Step 3 - in return, the French speakers gave up their advantage in Brussels. Answer: it was a mutual compromise: each community gave up the advantage of its majority in one place to gain security in another.

Worked example 2: identifying the right level

Question: A group of German-speaking Belgians wants changes in the language used in its schools. Which government would deal with this? Reasoning: Matters of culture, education and language belong to the community government, elected by members of each language community wherever they live. Answer: the German-speaking community government.

Key takeaways: Belgium has Dutch, French and German speakers, with Dutch speakers a majority nationally but a minority in Brussels. Between 1970 and 1993, four constitutional amendments created a model of equal ministers at the centre, powerful state governments, an equal Brussels government and community governments for cultural and educational matters. This accommodation kept the country united.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which language is spoken by the majority of Belgium's population, according to the textbook?

    1. French
    2. German
    3. Dutch
    4. English
    Show answer

    Answer: C. About 59 per cent of Belgians live in the Flemish region and speak Dutch; about 40 per cent speak French and about 1 per cent German.

  2. 2. What was the 'special problem' of Brussels?

    1. Dutch speakers were a majority in the country but a minority in the capital
    2. German speakers were a majority there
    3. No one lived in Brussels
    4. Brussels was outside Belgium
    Show answer

    Answer: A. In Brussels about 80 per cent speak French, so the Dutch-speaking national majority was a minority in the capital.

  3. 3. Which is a feature of the Belgian model?

    1. The central government has only Dutch-speaking ministers
    2. State governments are subordinate to the central government
    3. Only French speakers can vote in Brussels
    4. The numbers of Dutch- and French-speaking ministers in the central government are equal
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The constitution prescribes equal numbers of Dutch- and French-speaking ministers, and state governments are not subordinate to the centre.

  4. 4. The 'community government' in Belgium has powers over:

    1. defence and foreign affairs
    2. cultural, educational and language-related issues
    3. currency and banking
    4. railways and airports
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The community government is elected by members of one language group wherever they live and deals with culture, education and language.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Belgium avoided a division of the country along linguistic lines. Reason (R): Its constitution was amended to create arrangements that gave each community a fair share of power.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The power-sharing arrangements made between 1970 and 1993 respected both communities, which helped avoid civic strife and division. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery