• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Forms of power sharing (1): among organs and levels of government

Explain why democracy rejects undivided power, and describe horizontal distribution of power with checks and balances and vertical division of power among central, state and local governments.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain how the idea of power sharing replaced the idea of undivided power.
  • Explain horizontal distribution of power and the system of checks and balances.
  • Explain vertical (federal) division of power, including local government.

For a long time it was believed that all the power of a government must lie with one person or group in one place, because dispersed power would make quick decisions impossible. Democracy changed this. Its basic principle is that people are the source of all political power and rule themselves through institutions of self-government. Respect for diverse groups and views, and a voice for everyone in shaping policies, mean that political power should be distributed among as many citizens as possible.

1. Horizontal distribution of power

Power is shared among different organs of government - the legislature, executive and judiciary. This is called horizontal distribution because organs at the same level exercise different powers. The separation ensures that no organ can exercise unlimited power; each checks the others, resulting in a balance of power. For example, ministers and officials exercise power but are responsible to Parliament or State Assemblies; judges are appointed by the executive but can check the functioning of the executive and the laws made by legislatures. This is the system of checks and balances.

Checks and balances among the organs

  1. Legislature makes laws and holds ministers responsible
  2. Executive carries out laws and appoints judges
  3. Judiciary checks the executive and reviews laws

Then back to step 1: Legislature makes laws and holds ministers responsible

2. Vertical division of power

Power can be shared among governments at different levels: a general government for the whole country and governments at the provincial or regional level. The general government is usually called the federal government; in India it is the Central or Union Government, and regional governments are called State Governments. Not every country has such levels. Where they exist, the constitution clearly lays down the powers of each level - this is federal division of power. Belgium did this; Sri Lanka refused it. The same principle extends below the state to municipalities and panchayats. Division of power involving higher and lower levels is called vertical division of power.

Horizontal and vertical sharing compared
BasisHorizontal distributionVertical division
Shared amongLegislature, executive and judiciaryCentral, state and local governments
LevelSame level of governmentHigher and lower levels
Key ideaSeparation of powers; checks and balancesFederal division; constitution fixes each level's powers
ExampleA court reviews a law made by ParliamentA panchayat runs village development work

Horizontal: power spread across organs at the same level, each checking the others. Vertical: power spread across levels of government, from the Union down to the panchayat.

Worked example 1: classifying an event

Event (from the textbook's exercise): a High Court orders a State Government to act at once to improve living conditions for children in children's homes. Question: Which form of power sharing is this, and who shares power with whom? Reasoning: a court (judiciary) is checking the executive (the State Government). Answer: horizontal distribution - the judiciary shares power with, and checks, the executive.

Worked example 2: another classification

Event (from the textbook's exercise): finance ministers of the states of Nigeria demand that the federal government disclose its sources of income and the formula for sharing revenue with the states. Reasoning: this concerns relations between the federal (higher) level and the state (lower) level. Answer: vertical division of power - state governments are asserting their share with the federal government.

Key takeaways: Democracy replaced the idea of undivided power with the principle that people are the source of power, so power should be widely shared. Horizontal distribution divides power among legislature, executive and judiciary, each checking the others (checks and balances). Vertical division shares power among central, state and local governments, with the constitution fixing each level's powers.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Horizontal distribution of power means power is shared among:

    1. central, state and local governments
    2. different organs of government at the same level
    3. religious groups only
    4. political parties only
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Horizontal distribution divides power among the legislature, executive and judiciary, which are at the same level.

  2. 2. Which example shows checks and balances?

    1. A panchayat builds a village road
    2. Two parties form an alliance
    3. Judges, though appointed by the executive, can check the executive's functioning
    4. A community government runs schools
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Judges can check the executive and review laws even though the executive appoints them - a clear check and balance among organs.

  3. 3. Division of powers between higher and lower levels of government is called:

    1. vertical division of power
    2. horizontal distribution of power
    3. coalition government
    4. community government
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Sharing power among central, state and local levels is vertical division of power; federal division is one form of it.

  4. 4. What basic principle of democracy supports sharing power widely?

    1. All power must lie with one person
    2. Quick decisions matter more than participation
    3. Only experts should rule
    4. People are the source of all political power
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Because people are the source of political power and rule themselves, power should be distributed among as many citizens as possible.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): In India, ministers are responsible to Parliament or State Assemblies. Reason (R): Horizontal distribution of power ensures that no organ of government can exercise unlimited power.

    1. A is false, but R is true.
    2. A is true, but R is false.
    3. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    4. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Making the executive answerable to the legislature is one way of ensuring that no organ has unlimited power. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery