• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Why power sharing is desirable: prudential and moral reasons

Explain the prudential and moral reasons for power sharing, show how both apply to real situations, and examine the dilemma of power sharing through the Lebanon example in the textbook.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the prudential reason for power sharing with an example.
  • Explain the moral reason for power sharing and why it is the spirit of democracy.
  • Discuss the trade-offs in a fixed power-sharing arrangement, using the Lebanon case.

Some people think sharing power means dividing it, and dividing it means weakening the country. The stories of Belgium and Sri Lanka suggest the opposite. This lesson sets out the two kinds of reasons in favour of power sharing.

Prudential reasons

A decision is prudential when it is based on careful calculation of gains and losses. The prudential case says power sharing is good because it reduces the possibility of conflict between social groups. Since social conflict often leads to violence and political instability, power sharing helps ensure the stability of the political order. Imposing the majority's will may look attractive in the short run, but in the long run it undermines the unity of the nation. The tyranny of the majority is oppressive for the minority and often harms the majority too, as Sri Lanka's civil war showed.

Moral reasons

The deeper, moral case says power sharing is the very spirit of democracy. Democratic rule means sharing power with those who are affected by its exercise and who have to live with its effects. People have a right to be consulted on how they are governed. A legitimate government is one in which citizens, through participation, acquire a stake in the system. Here power sharing is valuable in itself, not only for its results.

Two kinds of reasons for power sharing

  • Prudential
    • Based on gains and losses
    • Reduces conflict between groups
    • Ensures political stability
    • Stresses better outcomes
  • Moral
    • Based on values
    • Power sharing is the spirit of democracy
    • People have a right to be consulted
    • Values the act of sharing itself

Prudential reasons say power sharing brings better outcomes; moral reasons say power sharing is valuable in itself because people have a right to a say in how they are governed.

A dilemma: the Lebanon example

The textbook tells the story of Khalil, a young man in Beirut, Lebanon, whose country went through a bitter civil war among its communities. Afterwards, leaders agreed on fixed rules: the President must be a Maronite Catholic Christian, the Prime Minister a Sunni Muslim, the Deputy Prime Minister an Orthodox Christian and the Speaker a Shi'a Muslim. Under the pact, Christians agreed not to seek French protection and Muslims agreed not to seek unification with neighbouring Syria. When it was made the two groups were nearly equal in number; the textbook notes that both sides continued to respect it even after Muslims became a clear majority.

Khalil, who follows neither parent's religion and has political ambitions, feels shut out of the top post and asks why Lebanon cannot simply let the winner of an election become President. His elders, who saw the bloodshed, reply that the present system is the best guarantee of peace. The textbook leaves the question open for students to think about: it shows that power-sharing arrangements involve trade-offs between peace and stability on one side and open competition on the other.

Worked example 1: classifying a reason

Passage (made up): 'Giving more powers to panchayats will reduce corruption and make administration more efficient, because people who plan and run local schemes will watch them closely.' Question: Is this a prudential or a moral reason? Reasoning: it argues from results - less corruption, more efficiency - which is a calculation of gains. Answer: prudential. A moral argument would be: 'Power belongs to the people, so they should decide local matters.'

Worked example 2: weighing the Lebanon rules

Question: State one advantage and one drawback of Lebanon's fixed rules. Reasoning and answer: Advantage (prudential) - every major community is guaranteed a top post, which reassures groups that fought a civil war and helps keep peace. Drawback - a capable person like Khalil, who does not belong to the community assigned to a post, cannot hold it, which limits open competition. This is why the textbook treats it as a dilemma rather than a simple answer.

Key takeaways: Power sharing is desirable for prudential reasons (it reduces conflict and keeps the political order stable; majority tyranny harms everyone) and for moral reasons (it is the spirit of democracy; people have a right to be consulted, and legitimacy comes from participation). Fixed arrangements like Lebanon's can secure peace but involve trade-offs.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of these is a prudential reason for power sharing?

    1. People have a right to be consulted on how they are governed
    2. Power sharing is the very spirit of democracy
    3. Power sharing reduces the possibility of conflict between social groups
    4. Citizens acquire a stake in the system
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Prudential reasons stress outcomes, such as reducing conflict and ensuring stability. The other options are moral reasons.

  2. 2. According to the moral argument, a legitimate government is one where:

    1. citizens, through participation, acquire a stake in the system
    2. one person holds all power
    3. the majority ignores minorities
    4. decisions are taken quickly without consultation
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The moral case holds that legitimacy comes from people participating and having a stake in how they are governed.

  3. 3. Under the arrangement described in the textbook, Lebanon's Prime Minister must belong to which community?

    1. Maronite Catholic Christian
    2. Orthodox Christian
    3. Shi'a Muslim
    4. Sunni Muslim
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Prime Minister must be a Sunni Muslim; the President is a Maronite Catholic, the Deputy Prime Minister an Orthodox Christian and the Speaker a Shi'a Muslim.

  4. 4. 'Tyranny of the majority' harms:

    1. only the minority
    2. not just the minority but often the majority as well
    3. nobody, as it brings stability
    4. only foreign countries
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook notes that majority tyranny is oppressive for the minority and often affects the majority adversely too, for example through conflict and instability.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Imposing the will of the majority may look attractive in the short run. Reason (R): In the long run, it can undermine the unity of the nation.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Both statements are true, but R describes the long-run cost; it does not explain why majority rule looks attractive in the short run (that is because the majority gets its way at once).

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery