Revision notes

Chapter 1 Power-sharing: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Belgium: accommodating diversity through power sharing

Belgium's language communities (figures as given in the textbook)
CommunityRegionShare of population
Dutch-speakingFlemish region (north)About 59%
French-speakingWallonia (south)About 40%
German-speakingSmall area in the eastAbout 1%
Brussels (capital)80% French-speaking, 20% Dutch-speaking-

Levels of government in the Belgian model

  • Central government Equal Dutch- and French-speaking ministers.
  • State (regional) governments Many powers; not subordinate to the centre.
  • Brussels government Equal representation of both communities.
  • Community government Elected by each language group; culture, education, language.

Accommodation: instead of letting the majority rule alone, Belgium gave every community a guaranteed share of power, so that no group could impose its will on the others.

Key takeaways: Belgium has Dutch, French and German speakers, with Dutch speakers a majority nationally but a minority in Brussels. Between 1970 and 1993, four constitutional amendments created a model of equal ministers at the centre, powerful state governments, an equal Brussels government and community governments for cultural and educational matters. This accommodation kept the country united.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Sri Lanka: majoritarianism and its consequences

Majoritarianism: the majority rules as it pleases and ignores the minority. It may look attractive to the majority in the short run, but it can undermine the unity of the country.

How majoritarianism led to conflict in Sri Lanka

  1. Majoritarian measures Sinhala-only language Act (1956), preferences in jobs and universities, state support for Buddhism.
  2. Alienation of Sri Lankan Tamils Felt denied equal political rights, jobs and opportunities.
  3. Demands and struggles For Tamil as an official language, regional autonomy, equal opportunity.
  4. Demand for Tamil Eelam By the 1980s, organisations sought an independent state in the north and east.
  5. Civil war Thousands killed, many became refugees; it ended in 2009.

Two democracies, two paths

  • Belgium
    • Recognised regional and cultural diversity
    • Amended constitution four times (1970-1993)
    • Shared power among communities and regions
    • Avoided division; country stayed united
  • Sri Lanka
    • Majority sought dominance after 1948
    • Sinhala-only language Act and preferential policies
    • Refused autonomy to Tamil areas
    • Distrust grew into a long civil war

Key takeaways: Sri Lanka's Sinhala majority (about 74 per cent) adopted majoritarian measures after 1948, including the 1956 Sinhala-only Act, preferential policies and state support for Buddhism. These alienated Sri Lankan Tamils, whose demands for autonomy were denied, leading to a civil war that ended in 2009. Compared with Belgium, it shows that refusing to share power threatens national unity.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Why power sharing is desirable: prudential and moral reasons

Two kinds of reasons for power sharing

  • Prudential
    • Based on gains and losses
    • Reduces conflict between groups
    • Ensures political stability
    • Stresses better outcomes
  • Moral
    • Based on values
    • Power sharing is the spirit of democracy
    • People have a right to be consulted
    • Values the act of sharing itself

Prudential reasons say power sharing brings better outcomes; moral reasons say power sharing is valuable in itself because people have a right to a say in how they are governed.

Key takeaways: Power sharing is desirable for prudential reasons (it reduces conflict and keeps the political order stable; majority tyranny harms everyone) and for moral reasons (it is the spirit of democracy; people have a right to be consulted, and legitimacy comes from participation). Fixed arrangements like Lebanon's can secure peace but involve trade-offs.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Forms of power sharing (1): among organs and levels of government

Checks and balances among the organs

  1. Legislature makes laws and holds ministers responsible
  2. Executive carries out laws and appoints judges
  3. Judiciary checks the executive and reviews laws

Then back to step 1: Legislature makes laws and holds ministers responsible

Horizontal and vertical sharing compared
BasisHorizontal distributionVertical division
Shared amongLegislature, executive and judiciaryCentral, state and local governments
LevelSame level of governmentHigher and lower levels
Key ideaSeparation of powers; checks and balancesFederal division; constitution fixes each level's powers
ExampleA court reviews a law made by ParliamentA panchayat runs village development work

Horizontal: power spread across organs at the same level, each checking the others. Vertical: power spread across levels of government, from the Union down to the panchayat.

Key takeaways: Democracy replaced the idea of undivided power with the principle that people are the source of power, so power should be widely shared. Horizontal distribution divides power among legislature, executive and judiciary, each checking the others (checks and balances). Vertical division shares power among central, state and local governments, with the constitution fixing each level's powers.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Forms of power sharing (2): social groups, parties and interest groups

Four forms of power sharing in modern democracies

  • Among organs of government Horizontal: legislature, executive, judiciary; checks and balances.
  • Among levels of government Vertical: central, state, local; federal division.
  • Among social groups Community government; reserved constituencies.
  • Among parties and groups Party competition, coalitions, pressure groups and movements.
Matching forms of power sharing with arrangements
Form of power sharingArrangement
Among different organs of governmentSeparation of powers
Among governments at different levelsFederal government
Among different social groupsCommunity government
Among two or more political partiesCoalition government

Power sharing is not a sign of weakness: spreading power across organs, levels, communities and parties prevents its concentration and gives everyone a stake in democracy.

Key takeaways: Power can be shared among social groups (community government, reserved constituencies) and through political competition (parties, alliances, coalition governments, interest groups and movements). Together with sharing among organs and levels of government, these make four forms of power sharing. Every democracy needs some form of power sharing.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery