• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Coming together and holding together federations

Explain the two routes through which federations are formed, compare 'coming together' and 'holding together' federations with examples, and explain why the balance of power between centre and states differs.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the two routes by which federations are formed.
  • Compare coming together and holding together federations with examples.
  • Explain why some units of a holding together federation have special powers.

The balance of power between the central and state governments is not the same in every federation. It depends mainly on the historical context in which the federation was formed. There are two main routes.

Coming together federations

In the first route, independent states come together on their own to form a bigger unit. By pooling sovereignty while retaining their identity, they increase their security. Examples are the USA, Switzerland and Australia. In such federations, the constituent states usually have equal power and are strong in relation to the federal government.

Holding together federations

In the second route, a large country decides to divide its power between its constituent states and the national government. Examples are India, Spain and Belgium. Here the central government tends to be more powerful than the states, and the units often have unequal powers: some are granted special powers.

Two routes to federation

  • Coming together
    • Independent states unite voluntarily
    • Pool sovereignty, keep identity, gain security
    • States usually equal and strong
    • USA, Switzerland, Australia
  • Holding together
    • A large country divides its power
    • Keeps a diverse country united
    • Centre tends to be stronger
    • India, Spain, Belgium

Coming together: separate states unite into one federation. Holding together: one country shares power with its parts to stay united.

Comparing the two kinds of federation
BasisComing togetherHolding together
How formedIndependent states uniteA large country divides power
Main aimSecurity through pooled sovereigntyUnity while accommodating diversity
Power of statesUsually equal; strong vis-a-vis the centreOften unequal; some have special powers
Power of centreRelatively limitedRelatively strong
ExamplesUSA, Switzerland, AustraliaIndia, Spain, Belgium

Worked example 1: completing a statement

Fill the blanks: 'Since the United States is a ____ type of federation, all the constituent states have equal powers and states are ____ vis-a-vis the federal government. But India is a ____ type of federation and some states have more power than others. In India, the ____ government has more powers.' Reasoning: the USA formed when independent states united; India divided power within one large country. Answer: coming together; strong; holding together; central.

Worked example 2: why did small Belgium become federal?

Question: If federalism suits large countries, why did small Belgium adopt it? Reasoning: Step 1 - Belgium's problem was not size but deep division between language communities. Step 2 - giving regions and communities guaranteed powers let each manage its own affairs. Step 3 - this held the country together and avoided partition. Answer: Belgium is a holding together federation formed to accommodate diversity; federalism answers diversity, not only size.

Key takeaways: Federations form by two routes. Coming together federations (USA, Switzerland, Australia) unite independent states, which usually stay equal and strong. Holding together federations (India, Spain, Belgium) divide power within a country; the centre tends to be stronger and some units may have special powers. The balance depends on history.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which group lists 'coming together' federations?

    1. India, Spain, Belgium
    2. USA, Switzerland, Australia
    3. Sri Lanka, India, Nepal
    4. Belgium, Sri Lanka, Spain
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The USA, Switzerland and Australia were formed when independent states came together. India, Spain and Belgium are holding together federations.

  2. 2. In a 'holding together' federation:

    1. the central government tends to be more powerful than the states
    2. all states always have exactly equal powers
    3. independent countries unite to gain security
    4. there is no central government
    Show answer

    Answer: A. In holding together federations a large country divides power; the centre tends to be stronger and units may have unequal powers.

  3. 3. Why do independent states form a 'coming together' federation?

    1. To abolish their identities
    2. To be ruled by a foreign power
    3. To pool sovereignty while keeping their identity, increasing their security
    4. To create a unitary state
    Show answer

    Answer: C. By pooling sovereignty and retaining identity, states increase their security together.

  4. 4. Which statement about India as a federation is correct?

    1. It is a coming together federation like the USA
    2. All its units have identical powers
    3. It has no central government
    4. It is a holding together federation in which some states have special powers
    Show answer

    Answer: D. India divided power within one large country; its centre is relatively strong and some states have special provisions.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The balance of power between centre and states differs from one federation to another. Reason (R): This balance depends mainly on the historical context in which the federation was formed.

    1. A is true, but R is false.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    3. A is false, but R is true.
    4. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Federations formed by coming together tend to have strong states; those formed by holding together tend to have a strong centre. History explains the difference, so R explains A.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → What makes India a federal country?

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery