- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Decentralisation: local government as the third tier
Explain the need for decentralisation, describe the 1992 constitutional amendment, the structure of rural and urban local government, and assess what local government has achieved and what difficulties remain.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define decentralisation and explain why it is needed.
- List the main provisions of the 1992 amendment and describe panchayati raj and urban local bodies.
- Assess the achievements and remaining problems of local government in India.
A vast country like India cannot be run only through two tiers. Many Indian states are as large as independent European countries and are internally very diverse, so power must also be shared within states. This is the case for a third tier: local government.
What is decentralisation?
When power is taken from the Central and State governments and given to local government, it is called decentralisation. Its basic idea is that many problems are best settled locally: people know their area's problems, have better ideas on where to spend money and how to manage things efficiently, and can participate directly in decisions, which builds the habit of democratic participation. Local government is the best way to realise the democratic principle of local self-government.
Decentralisation: shifting power from the Central and State governments to local governments, so that people can decide local matters themselves.
Before and after 1992
Panchayats and municipalities existed in all states earlier, but they were directly under state control, elections were irregular, and they had no powers or resources of their own, so there was little real decentralisation. In 1992 the Constitution was amended to make the third tier more powerful:
- Regular elections to local bodies became constitutionally mandatory.
- Seats are reserved in elected bodies and for their executive heads for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes.
- At least one-third of all positions are reserved for women.
- A State Election Commission in each state conducts panchayat and municipal elections.
- State governments must share some powers and revenue with local bodies; the nature of sharing varies from state to state.
Structure of local government
Rural local government is called panchayati raj. Each village, or group of villages, has a gram panchayat: a council of ward members (panch) and a president (sarpanch), directly elected by the adults of the ward or village. It works under the supervision of the gram sabha, which includes all the voters of the village and must meet at least twice or thrice a year to approve the panchayat's budget and review its work. A few gram panchayats together form a panchayat samiti (block or mandal), whose members are elected by the panchayat members of the area. All panchayat samitis in a district form the zilla parishad; most of its members are elected, and Lok Sabha members, MLAs and some district officials are also members. Its chairperson is its political head.
Local government in India
-
Rural (panchayati raj)
- Gram sabha: all village voters
- Gram panchayat: panch and sarpanch
- Panchayat samiti (block or mandal)
- Zilla parishad (district)
-
Urban
- Municipality in towns: headed by municipal chairperson
- Municipal corporation in big cities: headed by mayor
In towns there are municipalities, and big cities have municipal corporations, both controlled by elected representatives. The political head of a municipality is the municipal chairperson; of a municipal corporation, the mayor.
Achievements and difficulties
The textbook calls this the largest experiment in democracy anywhere, with about 36 lakh elected representatives in panchayats and municipalities (its figure). Constitutional status has deepened democracy and increased women's representation and voice. But difficulties remain: elections are regular, yet gram sabhas are not held regularly; most states have not transferred significant powers or adequate resources. India is still some way from the ideal of self-government. The textbook also describes Porto Alegre in Brazil, where residents take part in ward and city meetings to shape the city budget, so that spending also reaches poorer areas, and notes similar people's planning in parts of Kerala.
Worked example 1: before and after 1992
Question: State two differences in local government before and after 1992. Answer: (1) Before, elections were irregular; after, regular elections became constitutionally mandatory, conducted by a State Election Commission. (2) Before, local bodies had no powers or resources of their own; after, states must share some powers and revenue with them. (Also: reservations for SC, ST, OBC and at least one-third for women were introduced.)
Worked example 2: matching heads to governments
Question: Match the level with its head: Union of India, State, Municipal Corporation, Gram Panchayat - with Prime Minister, Governor, Mayor, Sarpanch. Answer: Union of India - Prime Minister; State - Governor; Municipal Corporation - Mayor; Gram Panchayat - Sarpanch. (The textbook's exercise pairs the State with the Governor, its constitutional head.)
Key takeaways: Decentralisation gives power to local governments because local problems are best solved locally and people can participate directly. The 1992 amendment made elections regular, reserved seats for SC, ST, OBC and at least one-third for women, created State Election Commissions and required states to share powers and revenue. Rural bodies run from gram sabha and gram panchayat to panchayat samiti and zilla parishad; urban bodies are municipalities and municipal corporations. Gains in democracy and women's voice are real, but gram sabhas, powers and resources remain weak.
Check your understanding
-
1. Decentralisation means:
- taking power from Central and State governments and giving it to local government
- giving all power to the Central Government
- abolishing state governments
- transferring power to foreign governments
Show answer
Answer: A. Decentralisation shifts power from the higher levels to local governments, so local matters are decided locally.
-
2. Under the 1992 amendment, what share of positions in local bodies is reserved for women?
- One-half
- One-fourth
- At least one-third
- None
Show answer
Answer: C. At least one-third of all positions in local government bodies are reserved for women.
-
3. Who are the members of the gram sabha?
- Only the sarpanch and panch
- All the voters in the village
- Only government officials
- Only MLAs and MPs
Show answer
Answer: B. All voters of the village are members of the gram sabha, which supervises the gram panchayat and approves its budget.
-
4. The political head of a municipal corporation is called the:
- Sarpanch
- Zilla parishad chairperson
- Governor
- Mayor
Show answer
Answer: D. A municipal corporation in a big city is headed by the mayor; a municipality by the municipal chairperson; a gram panchayat by the sarpanch.
-
5. Assertion (A): India is still some way from realising the ideal of local self-government. Reason (R): Gram sabhas are not held regularly, and most states have not transferred significant powers and resources to local bodies.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
- Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: B. Without regular gram sabhas and real powers and resources, local bodies cannot fully govern themselves. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.